Question map
Consider the following statements : The India-Africa Summit 1. held in 2015 was the third such Summit 2. was actually initiated by Jawaharlal Nehru in 1951 Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Explanation
The Third India-Africa Forum Summit was held on 29 October 2015 in New Delhi.[1] This confirms that statement 1 is correct—the 2015 summit was indeed the third such summit. Since the first India Africa Forum Summit in 2008, India has committed 7.4 billion dollars in concessional credit[2], which further corroborates that the India-Africa Forum Summit is a relatively recent initiative that began in 2008, not in 1951.
Statement 2, claiming that the summit was initiated by Jawaharlal Nehru in 1951, is incorrect. The India-Africa Forum Summit mechanism was launched only in 2008, making it a 21st-century initiative. While India had historical ties with Africa dating back to the independence era and Nehru's support for African decolonization, the formal India-Africa Summit framework was not established during his time.
Therefore, only statement 1 is correct, making option A the right answer.
Sources- [1] https://cms.rajyasabha.nic.in/UploadedFiles/Debates/OfficialDebatesDatewise/Floor/237/F03.12.2015.pdf
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question is a classic 'Current Event vs. Historical Origin' trap. The 2015 summit was a headline event, making Statement 1 a sitter for active aspirants. Statement 2 tests your ability to distinguish between the general 'Afro-Asian Solidarity' era of the 1950s and specific modern institutional mechanisms like the IAFS.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Explicitly names the 29 October 2015 event as the Third India-Africa Forum Summit.
- Provides date and location tying the 2015 summit to the 'Third' designation.
- Refers to speeches delivered at the 'Third India-Africa Forum Summit' in New Delhi on October 29, 2015.
- Connects the 2015 summit explicitly with the 'Third' forum summit phrasing.
- Lists 'Delhi Declaration 2015, Third India Africa Forum Summit, 29 October 2015' in its references.
- Explicitly identifies the 2015 Delhi summit as the Third India-Africa Forum Summit.
States India was a staunch supporter of newly independent African nations and that India engaged in high‑level multilateral diplomacy (e.g., Bandung → NAM).
A student could use this to infer India has a pattern of hosting/participating in periodic multilateral summits with African states and therefore check the sequence and dates of India–Africa summits to see if 2015 is the third.
Gives an example that India has hosted major international summits (NAM, Delhi 1983), showing precedent for India convening summit-level meetings.
Use the precedent of India hosting summits to justify searching official records of India‑Africa summits (host years and ordinal numbers) to verify whether 2015 was the third.
Describes India as a leader of the developing world with active roles in international organisations, implying sustained diplomatic engagement with regions like Africa.
Combine this with knowledge that such leadership often involves periodic summits; a student can therefore look up the timeline of India–Africa summit meetings to determine the ordinal number of 2015.
Notes India forges relationships specifically with African countries (e.g., South Africa), indicating targeted bilateral and multilateral engagement with Africa.
A student could use this to justify investigating India–Africa diplomatic initiatives and summit histories (dates/sequence) to judge whether the 2015 meeting was the third.
- Contains the exact claim as statement (2) to be evaluated, showing the assertion exists in study material.
- Presents the proposition as part of a question about the India-Africa Summit's origins (implying it is a contested claim).
- States when the first India-Africa Forum Summit actually took place, directly contradicting the 1951 initiation claim.
- Refers to the sequence of summits (first in 2008, third in 2015), showing the forum was launched much later than 1951.
States the Bandung Conference (1955) was the zenith of India's engagement with newly independent Asian and African nations and that Bandung later led to NAM.
A student could infer that major multilateral India–Africa diplomatic initiatives are documented around mid‑1950s onward, so they should check whether a formal India–Africa Summit existed as early as 1951 or emerged later (e.g., after Bandung).
Links Nehru directly to the Bandung Conference (1955) and to the founding momentum behind the Non‑Aligned Movement culminating in 1961.
Use the timeline (Nehru active in pan‑Asian/African diplomacy from mid‑1950s to 1961) to question the plausibility of a separate India–Africa Summit already being initiated in 1951.
Explains Nehru's dominant role in shaping India's foreign policy (he acted as his own foreign minister from 1946–1964).
If an India‑Africa Summit had been initiated in 1951, this source suggests Nehru would likely be the initiator — so a student should look for contemporaneous records of such a summit in Nehru's diplomatic activities in 1951.
Notes India hosted a NAM summit in Delhi in 1983, showing India hosted major Africa‑Asia/Non‑Aligned meetings much later.
Compare dates of known India‑hosted multilateral events (e.g., 1983) to test whether earlier pan‑Africa summits are regular/recorded or if notable India–Africa Summits appear later in history.
Situates Nehru firmly as the leading architect of India's post‑1947 foreign policy up to 1964.
A student can use this to reason that any major diplomatic initiative in 1951 would likely be traceable to Nehru's official actions; thus absence of such mention in these sources suggests checking primary records from 1951.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter for current affairs readers; Trap for history guessers. Source: Front-page news in Oct 2015 (The Hindu/IE) covering the 'Third India-Africa Forum Summit'.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: India's Foreign Policy > Engagement with the Global South > Institutional Mechanisms (Summits).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the IAFS timeline: IAFS-I (2008, New Delhi), IAFS-II (2011, Addis Ababa), IAFS-III (2015, New Delhi). Know the 'Banjul Formula' (only 15 countries invited in I/II) vs the 2015 shift (all 54 nations invited). Contrast with China's FOCAC (started 2000).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Whenever a summit is in the news, immediately Wikipedia its 'First Edition'. UPSC loves swapping the founding year or founder. If the news says '3rd Summit', calculate backward—it cannot be 1951.
Bandung is cited in the references as the key early moment of India's engagement with newly independent Asian and African states, anchoring India–Africa diplomatic history.
High‑yield for UPSC: questions on post‑1945 decolonisation, Afro‑Asian solidarity, and India's early foreign policy often center on Bandung. It links to NAM origins and India's leadership in the developing world; study primary outcomes, date (1955), and its role in shaping later India–Africa interactions.
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Indi External Relations > Afro-Asian unity > p. 58
References note the NAM's establishment following Bandung and mention India's hosting of a NAM summit, highlighting India's central role in multilateral summits that shaped relations with Asia and Africa.
Frequent UPSC topic in modern history and international relations: know NAM's origins, key summits (e.g., Belgrade First Summit 1961), and instances of India hosting NAM summits. This helps answer questions on Cold War non‑alignment and India's leadership among developing nations; crosslink with foreign policy and geopolitics topics.
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Indi External Relations > Afro-Asian unity > p. 58
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 39: After Nehru... > India's Man in Space > p. 715
Evidence highlights India's support for decolonisation and opposition to apartheid, showing ideological and historical foundations for India–Africa diplomatic ties and summitry.
Relevant for questions on India's moral diplomacy and bilateral/multilateral relations with African states. Knowing India's anti‑colonial posture and anti‑apartheid activism helps explain later summits and partnership frameworks; integrate with contemporary foreign policy and human rights themes.
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Indi External Relations > Afro-Asian unity > p. 58
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 15: Emergence of Gandhi > Early Career and Experiments with Truth in South Africa > p. 315
References link Bandung (1955) to heightened engagement with Asian and African countries and to the later establishment of the NAM, which is relevant when assessing claims about earlier India‑Africa initiatives.
High-yield for UPSC: questions often ask about post‑1947 Indian foreign policy milestones and multilateral group origins. Understanding Bandung → NAM helps place summits and initiatives chronologically and prevents attributing later developments to earlier dates or leaders. Prepare by memorising key conferences, dates, outcomes, and their causal links.
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Indi External Relations > Afro-Asian unity > p. 58
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 8: Reconstruction of Post-colonial India > Nehru and Chou En-lai > p. 111
Several references state Nehru was India’s primary foreign policy architect and a co‑founder of NAM, which bears on evaluating claims that he personally initiated major international summits.
Important for UPSC: Nehru’s foreign policy is frequently tested across polity and modern history sections. Master his functions (PM + de facto FM), objectives (sovereignty, territorial integrity, development), and association with non‑alignment to answer source‑based chronology and cause‑effect questions. Study through timelines, primary speeches, and linkage to events like Bandung and Belgrade.
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Indi External Relations > Nehru's role > p. 57
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Indi External Relations > Afro-Asian unity > p. 58
The references mention India’s strong support for decolonisation and opposition to apartheid—contextual factors that influenced India’s engagement with African nations and multilateral fora.
Useful for UPSC essays and polity/history questions on foreign policy motivations. Knowing India’s ideological drivers helps explain why India attended and promoted Afro‑Asian cooperation rather than attributing specific summit initiations without evidence. Revise through thematic notes linking ideology to diplomatic actions and key events.
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Indi External Relations > Afro-Asian unity > p. 58
The 'Banjul Formula': The first two summits (2008, 2011) restricted participation to 15 African countries chosen by the African Union. The 2015 Summit was historic because India abandoned this formula and invited all 54 African heads of state.
The 'Math Mismatch' Hack: If Statement 1 says it is the 'Third' summit in 2015, and Statement 2 says it started in 1951, the math fails. A recurring summit starting in 1951 would be in its 20th+ edition by 2015, not the 3rd. Unless there was a 60-year hiatus (unlikely for a 'Summit' series), the statements contradict each other.
Mains GS-2 (IR): This marks the shift from 'Political Solidarity' (Nehru's 1950s anti-colonialism/NAM) to 'Developmental Partnership' (21st Century trade, capacity building, and energy security). Use this transition to critique India's changing priorities in Africa.