Question map
Consider the following statements : 1. The weightage of food in Consumer Price Index (CPI) is higher than that in Wholesale Price Index (WPI). 2. The WPI does not capture changes in the prices of services, which CPI does. 3. Reserve Bank of India has now adopted WPI as its key measure of inflation and to decide on changing the key policy rates. Which of the statements given above is/are correct ?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 1 (1 and 2 only) based on the following structural differences between the two indices:
- Statement 1 is correct: Food items have a significantly higher weightage in the CPI (approximately 45.86%) compared to the WPI (approximately 24.38%). This makes CPI more sensitive to fluctuations in food prices, reflecting the consumption patterns of households.
- Statement 2 is correct: The WPI only tracks the prices of goods at the wholesale level (Manufactured Products, Primary Articles, and Fuel). In contrast, the CPI measures the price changes of both goods and services (such as education, healthcare, and transport), providing a broader reflection of the cost of living.
- Statement 3 is incorrect: Since 2014, following the Urjit Patel Committee recommendations, the RBI adopted CPI (Combined) as its primary anchor for monetary policy and inflation targeting, replacing the WPI.
Therefore, only statements 1 and 2 accurately describe the technical differences and current policy framework in India.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a 'Sitter' from the Core Economy module. The shift from WPI to CPI by the RBI (Urjit Patel Committee) is a landmark event in Indian economic history, not a fleeting current affair. If you missed this, your static foundation (NCERT/Standard Books) has critical gaps.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Is the percentage weight of food in India's Consumer Price Index (CPI) higher than the percentage weight of food in India's Wholesale Price Index (WPI) as of 2020?
- Statement 2: Does India's Wholesale Price Index (WPI) include prices of services in its coverage as of 2020?
- Statement 3: Does India's Consumer Price Index (CPI) include prices of services in its coverage as of 2020?
- Statement 4: Has the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) adopted the Wholesale Price Index (WPI) as its primary measure of inflation for guiding monetary policy and setting key policy rates as of 2020?
- Explicit comparison table showing food items have greater weight in CPI (around 46%) and lesser weight in WPI (around 22%).
- Directly states CPI food weight is substantially higher than WPI food weight, supporting the comparative claim.
- Gives a precise CPI (combined) weight for 'Food and beverages' as 45.86%, a high share of the CPI basket.
- This high CPI food weight supports the assertion that CPI's food share exceeds typical WPI food shares.
- Provides the WPI food articles weight as 24.4%, substantially lower than the CPI food weight.
- Numeric WPI weight allows a direct numeric comparison with CPI food weights cited elsewhere.
- Official MOSPI text explicitly states the WPI does not contain services in its basket.
- This is a direct statement about coverage, answering whether services are included.
- Another MOSPI passage reiterates that the WPI does not cover prices of services.
- Confirms the WPI's exclusion of services while contrasting with CPI coverage.
- A news explanation states services are not included because they are not sold in bulk at the wholesale level.
- Provides rationale consistent with the MOSPI statements about WPI coverage.
Explicit comparative rule: 'In wholesale market services are not traded, so WPI does not include the inflation in services, while CPI and GDP deflator capture inflation in services.'
A student could use the general fact that services are not typically traded in wholesale markets to infer WPI’s exclusion of services and then check official WPI composition for 2020.
Gives a concrete scope: 'WPI takes into account 697 commodities ... but it does not take into account services.'
One can extend this by noting 'commodities' usually means goods (not services) and therefore suspect services are excluded from WPI coverage and verify via WPI item list for 2020.
Defines WPI as tracking prices in wholesale markets where goods are traded in bulk and contrasts WPI with CPI that looks at consumer prices including goods and services.
Using the rule that wholesale markets deal with bulk goods, a student could reasonably deduce WPI focuses on goods not services and then consult official WPI documentation for 2020 to confirm.
Lists a limitation: 'Services inflation (which contributes more than 50% in GDP) is not considered here.'
A student could combine this limitation with knowledge of services’ GDP share to understand why WPI would omit services and then check whether any service categories appear in the WPI 2020 basket.
Provides a short statement in a set of true/false style items: 'The WPI does not capture changes in the prices of services, which CPI does.'
A student could treat this as a textbook rule to be cross-checked against the WPI itemization or official methodology for 2020.
- Explicitly states CPI 'includes both goods and services'.
- Describes CPI as measuring retail price changes and reflecting cost of living, implying services are part of the consumer basket.
- Directly contrasts indices: says WPI does not include services while CPI and GDP deflator capture inflation in services.
- Frames CPI as an index that captures services inflation, strengthening the claim about service coverage.
- Defines CPI as the percentage change in a basket of consumption goods and notes 'consumption goods... may include services as well'.
- Links the concept of consumption basket to inclusion of services, supporting why CPI can include services prices.
- Official statement that RBI follows flexible inflation targeting and explicitly targets CPI (headline) inflation.
- Specifies the numeric CPI target (4% with ±2% tolerance), showing CPI is the operative guide for policy.
- Affirms RBI's policy framework targets CPI and notes CPI has been within the tolerance band.
- Explicitly states that WPI is not a specifically targeted inflation rate for the RBI.
- Describes the Urjit Patel committee recommendation that RBI adopt CPI (combined) based inflation to guide monetary policy.
- Shows institutional move toward CPI as the standard measure for headline inflation guiding policy.
States the RBI Act/monetary framework identifies the inflation measure as 'CPI – Combined' and ties the inflation target to that series.
A student could infer that if the statutory target is CPI (Combined), RBI would not adopt WPI as the primary anchor and should check MPC communications around 2020 for conformity.
Explains that a committee recommended adopting CPI (Combined) instead of WPI as the nominal anchor for inflation targeting, with reasons (WPI ignores services, CPI is broader).
Using this rule, a student can argue that policy-makers preferred CPI over WPI and look for official adoption dates or MPC minutes around 2015–2020 to confirm practice.
Describes the creation of the MPC (2016) entrusted with inflation targeting and gives the numeric target (4% ±2% until Mar 2021), implying an institutional mechanism using a specific index.
A student could use this to check which price index the MPC was mandated to target (linking back to CPI as per the framework) when evaluating whether RBI switched to WPI by 2020.
Defines WPI: who publishes it (DIPP/DPIIT), its coverage and methodology (ex-factory prices), indicating WPI is a wholesale measure compiled by a ministry, not by RBI.
One can use this to reason that since WPI is compiled by a government ministry and excludes services, it is less likely to be the RBI's primary inflation target without an explicit institutional change.
Contains an exam-style item listing as a statement to be judged that 'Reserve Bank of India has now adopted WPI as its key measure', suggesting this claim is contested and taught as questionable.
A student could treat this as a prompt to verify official RBI/GOI documents or MPC statements (circa 2020) because textbooks present it as a proposition to evaluate.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. Directly available in Singhania (Ch 4), Vivek Singh (Ch 1), and NCERT Macroeconomics. No hidden traps.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Inflation Metrics & The Monetary Policy Framework (Urjit Patel Committee recommendations).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the 'Index Matrix': 1) Publisher (WPI: DPIIT vs CPI: NSO vs CPI-IW: Labour Bureau). 2) Base Year (WPI: 2011-12 vs CPI: 2012). 3) Basket (WPI: 697 items, No Services vs CPI: Goods + Services). 4) Highest Weight (WPI: Manufactured Products ~64% vs CPI: Food & Beverages ~46%).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Never study an index in isolation. Always study in 'Versus Mode' (WPI vs CPI). Create a comparison table for every economic indicator: Who releases it? What is the base year? What is the dominant component? What is it used for?
CPI assigns a much larger share to food items than WPI, so food-driven price changes influence CPI more strongly.
High-yield for UPSC: directly relevant to questions comparing inflation measures and their policy implications. Links to topics on index construction, inflation drivers, and interpretation of headline inflation. Mastery helps answer MCQs and analytical questions on why one index reacts more to food-price shocks than another.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > CPI FOOD INDEX > p. 68
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > 1. Consumer Price Index (CPI): > p. 31
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > 2. Wholesale Price Index (WPI): > p. 32
CPI covers goods and services while WPI covers only goods, changing the relative weights of components like food.
Important for explaining structural differences between indices and why their weight compositions differ. Useful for questions on measurement differences, scope of indices, and implications for monetary policy.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > CPI FOOD INDEX > p. 68
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > 2. Wholesale Price Index (WPI): > p. 32
Weights are assigned based on a base year and remain fixed until revision, affecting comparisons between CPI and WPI baskets.
Valuable for understanding why index compositions differ across time and indices; helps tackle questions on index methodology, base-year effects, and interpreting changes in index weights across revisions.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > 1. Consumer Price Index (CPI): > p. 31
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > CPI FOOD INDEX > p. 68
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > 2. Wholesale Price Index (WPI): > p. 32
WPI coverage focuses on wholesale goods and does not include prices of services.
High-yield for questions on inflation measurement: explains why WPI can understate overall inflation when services inflation is strong; connects directly to differences in policy signalling from WPI versus CPI/GDP deflator and to sectors driving GDP. Mastering this helps answer comparative and policy-impact questions on inflation indices.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > a) Wholesale Price Index > p. 65
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 1: National Income > WPI is not preferred because: > p. 8
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > The following are some basic differences in CPI, WPI and GDP deflator: > p. 33
CPI captures consumer prices including services, while WPI tracks wholesale (producer/mandi/factory-gate) prices of goods.
Essential for UPSC questions that ask to contrast price indices, to evaluate which index is appropriate for policy analysis, and to interpret inflation statistics in macroeconomic context; links to monetary policy, fiscal effects, and GDP deflator comparisons.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > 2. Wholesale Price Index (WPI): > p. 32
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > The following are some basic differences in CPI, WPI and GDP deflator: > p. 33
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > a) Wholesale Price Index > p. 64
WPI uses ex-factory/wholesale prices of a defined commodity basket (e.g., 697 commodities) and excludes indirect taxes and retail margins.
Useful for questions on index construction and measurement bias: explains why WPI is less affected by indirect taxes and retail margins, and why its composition matters for interpreting inflation trends; connects to concepts of base-year weights and producer vs consumer price dynamics.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > a) Wholesale Price Index > p. 65
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > 2. Wholesale Price Index (WPI): > p. 32
CPI captures prices of services while WPI excludes them and the GDP deflator also captures services inflation.
High-yield for questions on inflation measurement and policy: helps distinguish which index policymakers use for assessing consumer-facing inflation versus wholesale or economy-wide price changes. Useful for comparing index purpose, coverage and implications for monetary/fiscal decisions.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 1: Fundamentals of Macro Economy > The following are some basic differences in CPI, WPI and GDP deflator: > p. 33
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > b) Consumer Price Index > p. 66
The 'Labour Bureau' Trap: While NSO releases CPI (Rural/Urban/Combined), the Labour Bureau releases CPI for Industrial Workers (CPI-IW), Agricultural Labourers (CPI-AL), and Rural Labourers (CPI-RL). Wages and DA are linked to CPI-IW, not the headline CPI.
Apply 'Consumer Logic' to Statement 1. CPI represents the 'Aam Aadmi' (Common Man). A common Indian household spends a huge chunk of income on Roti/Sabzi (Food). WPI represents Wholesalers/Factories who buy fuel, metals, and chemicals. Therefore, Food weight *must* be higher in CPI than WPI. Statement 1 is logically correct.
Mains GS3 (Inclusive Growth): High weightage of food in CPI (~46%) means 'Headline Inflation' in India is highly sensitive to monsoon shocks (supply side). This limits the RBI's ability to control inflation via Repo Rate (demand side), creating a policy dilemma often cited in Economic Surveys.