Question map
With reference to street-lighting, how do sodium lamps differ from LED lamps? 1. Sodium lamps produce light in 360 degrees but it is not so in the case of LED lamps. 2. As street-lights, sodium lamps have longer life span than LED lamps. 3. The spectrum of visible light from sodium lamps is almost monochromatic while LED lamps offer significant colour advantages in street-lighting. Select the correct answer using the code given below.
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 3 (1 and 3 only). This is based on the technical and physical properties of both lighting technologies.
- Statement 1 is correct: Sodium lamps are omnidirectional, emitting light in 360 degrees, which often requires reflectors to direct light downwards. Conversely, LEDs are directional light sources, emitting light in a specific direction (usually 180 degrees), reducing light pollution and wastage.
- Statement 2 is incorrect: LED lamps generally have a much longer lifespan (typically 50,000 to 100,000 hours) compared to High-Pressure Sodium (HPS) lamps, which usually last between 12,000 to 24,000 hours.
- Statement 3 is correct: Sodium lamps produce a monochromatic yellow-orange glow due to their specific gas discharge. LEDs offer a broad spectrum of light, providing better Color Rendering Index (CRI), which improves visibility and safety in street-lighting.
Therefore, since statements 1 and 3 are scientifically accurate while statement 2 is factually wrong, Option 3 is the right choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question is less about textbook physics and more about 'Technological Rationale'. It tests why the Indian Government (via UJALA/SLNP) aggressively replaced Sodium lights with LEDs. If you only studied the definition of an LED, you failed. If you studied 'Why LED is better than Sodium' (the policy logic), this was a sitter.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Do sodium street-light lamps emit light in all directions (approximately 360 degrees)?
- Statement 2: Do LED street-light lamps emit light in all directions (approximately 360 degrees)?
- Statement 3: Do sodium street-light lamps have a longer operational lifespan than LED street-light lamps?
- Statement 4: Is the visible light spectrum emitted by sodium street-light lamps nearly monochromatic (dominated by narrow sodium emission lines)?
- Statement 5: Do LED street-light lamps offer significant colour advantages for street-lighting, such as substantially better colour rendering (higher CRI) than sodium street-light lamps?
- Explicitly states that most sources of visible light (except lasers) emit light in various directions.
- Notes that such multi-directional emission allows light to scatter into the atmosphere, relevant to outdoor lamps.
- Defines electric light sources as luminous objects that emit their own light, placing street lamps in the category covered by general emission rules.
- Helps connect the general principle about light-source behaviour to actual lamps used in lighting.
- Explicitly describes LEDs as "directional" and contrasts them with lamps that emit in all directions.
- States LEDs emit light in a specific direction, which directly answers whether they emit 360Β°.
- Directly states the angular emission for LEDs (180Β°) versus sodium lamps (360Β°).
- Provides a clear comparison showing LEDs do not emit in all directions.
- Lists "Directional light (over 180 degrees, unlike other lights with 360 degrees light direction)" as a characteristic of LED street lights.
- Reinforces that LED street lights are not 360Β° emitters but have a limited directional output.
The LED symbol shows arrows indicating that an LED emits light, giving a rule-like representation that LEDs produce directed light output.
A student could combine this with knowledge that real LEDs are often packaged with lenses/reflectors to shape those emission arrows into specific beam patterns for streetlights.
States that most visible light sources (except lasers) emit light in various directions, a general pattern about emission spread.
Use this general rule plus knowledge of lamp design (streetlight optics) to suspect that uncontrolled sources tend toward multi-directional emission, so streetlight design must manage that.
Describes an incandescent bulb with a glowing filament viewable from all sides, an example of an essentially omnidirectional lamp.
Compare this with LEDs: if incandescent bulbs emit in many directions, a student could ask whether LEDs (different emitter geometry) are similar or are optically constrained by housings.
Notes that many torches use LED lamps β an example context where LEDs are used with housings/lenses to produce directed beams.
A student could inspect a torch or streetlight: if torch LEDs use reflectors to focus light, streetlight LEDs likely also use optics rather than emitting uniformly.
Demonstrates that light changes direction when reflected by mirrors/plates, highlighting that fixtures and surroundings can redirect emitted light.
Combine this with the fact that streetlight housings and nearby surfaces reflect or block light to infer that even if an LED emits broadly, the net pattern at street level depends on optics and reflection.
- Directly compares lifespans in hours for LED vs HPS (sodium) lamps.
- Explicitly concludes LED has a longer lifespan than HPS (sodium) street lights.
- States a typical multi-year lifetime for LED street lights, supporting that LEDs are long-lived.
- Provides a longevity figure (20-25 years) for LEDs versus 'traditional sodium' mentioned earlier.
Explicit general rule: 'LED lamps ... are ... and last longer than traditional lamps.'
A student could treat sodium street lights as a form of 'traditional' street lamp and compare typical rated lifetimes (manufacturer specs) for sodium vs LED to test the claim.
Summary repeats that LEDs have properties (two terminals, directional current) and are contrasted with incandescent behaviour, reinforcing the text's general favourable framing of LEDs versus older lamp types.
Use the text's contrast between LED and older lamps to motivate checking whether sodium lamps are grouped with those 'older' types and then compare lifetimes from product data.
Gives a failure mechanism for filament-based incandescent lamps (filament breaks β lamp 'fuses'), illustrating why some older lamp types have shorter lifespans.
A student could use this as a pattern (older filament/discrete-failure designs often fail earlier) and then ask whether sodium lamps share similar failure mechanisms or are more like LEDs (solid-state).
Describes incandescent lamp construction (thin filament in glass) and its vulnerability, reinforcing the pattern that older thermal/filament technologies can have limited life.
Apply this pattern to classify street lamp technologies (filament vs discharge vs solid-state) and then seek typical lifetime ranges for each to judge sodium vs LED.
Recommends replacing incandescent bulbs with more energy-efficient types, implying a policy/technical preference for newer, longerβlasting, efficient lamp technologies.
Treat this as support for the idea that energy-efficient replacements (like LEDs) are preferred; a student could therefore compare energyβefficiency and lifetime specs of sodium and LED street lights to evaluate the statement.
- Explicitly describes HPS (sodium) street lights as producing a 'monochromatic' yellow-orange glow.
- Directly links the appearance of sodium street lights to a narrow, single-color emission consistent with 'nearly monochromatic.'
- Gives a specific wavelength associated with HPS visible light (near 589 nm), indicating emission concentrated around the sodium D-line region.
- A single near-589 nm value supports the idea of a narrow spectral output rather than a broad spectrum.
- Shows sodium's emission spectrum and highlights the D line, the well-known narrow sodium emission near 589 nm.
- Connects elemental sodium to strong, narrow spectral lines that would dominate light emitted by sodium lamps.
A prism disperses white light into a continuous band of colours, implying some light sources produce a broad spectrum rather than narrow lines.
A student could compare the prism spectrum of an unknown lamp to that of a broad source: if sodium lamps were nearly monochromatic, a prism would show narrow lines instead of a continuous band.
An incandescent filament 'glows' (thermal emission), which by implication is a broad-spectrum source rather than emission in narrow lines.
Use the incandescent lamp as a contrast example: if sodium streetlights are nearly monochromatic, their prism or spectroscope signature would differ markedly from the filament's continuous glow.
The snippet mentions 'emission of light ... in a low-order manner' and discusses distinct absorption/emission spectra, indicating that emission spectra can be characterized (broad vs shifted/narrow).
A student could apply the concept of distinct emission spectra to expect that a lamp dominated by specific atomic lines (sodium) would show narrow emission features compared with broad absorbers/emitters.
Most sources of visible light emit in various directions and can scatter; this treats light sources generally rather than implying narrow spectral content, suggesting variation among sources.
Recognize that streetlights are a class of sources subject to scattering and reflection; one could test how a source's directional emission and scattering interact with any narrow spectral lines (e.g., observing colour casts at distance).
Atmospheric scattering depends on wavelength (shorter wavelengths scatter more), indicating that spectral composition affects how distant lights appear.
A student could reason that if a sodium lamp is dominated by longer yellow wavelengths (narrow lines), it would be less scattered than blue-rich sources, producing a distinctive colour/visibility pattern at distance.
- Directly compares CRI values for LED vs HPS, showing much higher CRI for LEDs.
- Provides numerical ranges that quantify the colour-rendering advantage of LEDs over sodium lamps.
- Describes HPS (sodium) lights as producing a 'yellow-orange, monochromatic glow', implying poor colour rendering.
- Supports the contrast that LEDs (by implication) provide more natural/multiβchromatic light than sodium lamps.
- States that LED street lights are best for outdoor applications 'requiring high color rendering accuracy', indicating LEDs are chosen for superior colour performance.
- Reinforces that LEDs are suitable where accurate colour perception is important, unlike sodium lamps.
Says LEDs are modern, brighter light sources and promoted for their advantages, implying different optical performance compared with older lamps.
A student could use this to motivate comparing spectral/colour properties of newer (LED) vs older technologies (e.g., sodium) by looking up their emission spectra or CRI values.
Explains that white light can be split into component colours (dispersion), highlighting that 'colour' of light depends on its spectral composition.
A student can use the concept to reason that a lamp with a broader, continuous spectrum will render colours differently than one with narrow spectral lines, so they should compare spectra to judge CRI.
Defines dispersion and the idea that different wavelengths make up a spectrum, reinforcing that colour rendering depends on which wavelengths are present.
A student could extend this by checking whether LED sources produce a continuous spectrum (many wavelengths) versus sources with limited lines β affecting perceived colour rendering.
Notes that different colours scatter differently (example: red scatters least), showing that human perception of colour depends on wavelength content and propagation.
A student can combine this with knowledge of lamp spectra to predict how ambient conditions and spectral content influence observed colours under different lamps.
Mentions cost and policy-driven deployment of LEDs, implying LEDs are replacing older technologies in practice, which invites comparison of their performance beyond energy (e.g., colour rendering).
A student could follow this policy lead to find technical specs used in procurement (e.g., required CRI) and compare typical LED vs sodium lamp datasheets.
- [THE VERDICT]: **Logical Sitter**. While technical, it relies on the 'Upgrade Heuristic' (New tech usually improves lifespan and quality). Source: General awareness of Energy Efficiency policies.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: **Applied Physics (Optics) & Energy Security**. Specifically, the technical comparison between Gas Discharge Lamps (Sodium/Mercury) and Solid State Lighting (LED).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: **The 'Bulb Wars' Cheat Sheet**: 1. **Luminous Efficacy**: LED (~100+ lm/W) > Sodium > CFL > Incandescent. 2. **CRI (Colour Rendering)**: Sunlight (100) > LED (>80) > Sodium (<25, everything looks yellow). 3. **Toxicity**: CFL/Sodium contain Mercury/Sodium; LEDs are solid-state (no gas). 4. **Failure Mode**: Sodium bulbs burn out; LEDs dim over time (Lumen depreciation).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: **The 'Why the Switch?' Framework**. Whenever a new technology (EVs, 5G, LEDs, Nano-urea) disrupts an old one, do not just define it. Create a comparison table: Efficiency, Lifespan, Waste, and Cost. UPSC asks for the *technical justification* behind the policy shift.
Street lamps are luminous objects that produce their own visible light.
Understanding what qualifies as a luminous source is high-yield for questions on lighting, visibility and environmental effects; it links basic optics to practical topics like public lighting and light pollution and enables classification-based reasoning in exam questions.
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 11: Light: Shadows and Reflections > Light: Shadows and Refl ections 11 > p. 154
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 11: Light: Shadows and Reflections > In a Nutshell > p. 165
Typical visible light sources (not lasers) emit light in multiple directions rather than a single narrow beam.
Mastering emission patterns helps solve problems about illumination, shielding, and environmental light spread; it connects to instrument design, outdoor lighting policy, and questions about sources of light pollution.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > 5.8.r. Causes > p. 81
Downward-directed light can be reflected by urban surfaces and scattered into the atmosphere, increasing upward light.
This concept is useful for policy and environment questions (urban planning, light pollution mitigation); it links optics to environmental impact assessments and supports argumentation on regulatory measures for public lighting.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > 5.8.r. Causes > p. 81
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 11: Light: Shadows and Reflections > Activity 11.5: Let us investigate > p. 160
Determines whether a lamp radiates equally in all directions or preferentially in some directions, which is central to a '360-degree' emission claim.
High-yield for questions on lighting behaviour, illumination design and light pollution; links basic optical reasoning to practical assessments of lamp performance and helps evaluate statements about beam patterns and coverage.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > 5.8.r. Causes > p. 81
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Electricity: Circuits and their Components > Activity 3.9: Let us test > p. 34
Fixtures and nearby surfaces can redirect and reflect light, so the apparent overall emission pattern depends on both source emission and environmental reflection.
Important for urban environment and infrastructure topics (e.g., light pollution, street-lighting design); connects reflection principles to real-world consequences and helps reason about net upward vs downward light.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > 5.8.r. Causes > p. 81
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 11: Light: Shadows and Reflections > Activity 11.5: Let us investigate > p. 160
LEDs are modern, energy-efficient light sources with defined electrical terminals and schematic arrows that denote light emission direction.
Useful for questions on energy-efficient technologies and electrical circuits; links device-level properties to applications (torches, lamps) and allows evaluation of how LEDs behave in lighting fixtures.
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Electricity: Circuits and their Components > LED Lamp > p. 27
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Electricity: Circuits and their Components > Activity 3.9: Let us test > p. 34
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Electricity: Circuits and their Components > In a Nutshell > p. 37
LED lamps consume much less power, are brighter and last longer than traditional incandescent lamps.
High-yield for questions on energy-efficient technologies and lighting policy; helps answer comparisons of operating cost, longevity, and environmental impact. Connects to topics in energy conservation, technology adoption, and municipal infrastructure choices, and enables elimination-style reasoning in comparative questions.
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 11: Light: Shadows and Reflections > SCIENCE AND SOCIETY > p. 154
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Electricity: Circuits and their Components > In a Nutshell > p. 37
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Electricity: Circuits and their Components > Incandescent Lamp > p. 26
The 'Blue Light' Hazard. While LEDs are efficient, their spectrum often contains a 'blue spike' (unlike Sodium's yellow). This blue light scatters more (Rayleigh scattering) causing more skyglow and suppresses melatonin in humans/animals. Expect a question on the *ecological impact* of LED streetlights.
Use 'The Upgrade Heuristic'. Statement 2 claims the *old* tech (Sodium) lasts longer than the *new* tech (LED). Governments don't spend billions upgrading infrastructure to a technology that dies faster (increasing maintenance costs). Therefore, Statement 2 is logically improbable. Eliminate 2 -> Answer is C.
GS-3 (Energy & Environment): The switch to LED is a classic Demand Side Management (DSM) strategy by the Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) to meet India's Climate Change commitments (reducing emission intensity of GDP).