Question map
Consider the following statements: 1. In India, credit rating agencies are regulated by Reserve Bank of India. 2. The rating agency popularly known as ICRA is a public limited company. 3. Brickwork Ratings is an Indian credit rating agency. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 2 (2 and 3 only). Below is the comprehensive explanation:
- Statement 1 is incorrect: In India, Credit Rating Agencies (CRAs) are primarily regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) under the SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999, and not the RBI.
- Statement 2 is correct: ICRA (Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency) was incorporated in 1991 and is a public limited company listed on both the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and the National Stock Exchange (NSE). Its majority shareholder is Moody’s Investment Company India Private Limited.
- Statement 3 is correct: Brickwork Ratings (BWR) is indeed an Indian credit rating agency. It is registered with SEBI and empanelled by the RBI. It offers ratings for bank loans, NCDs, commercial papers, and other financial instruments.
Since statement 1 is false while statements 2 and 3 are factually accurate, Option 2 is the right choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question is a classic 'Wolf in Sheep's Clothing'. It looks factual and tough (asking about ICRA's corporate structure), but it is actually a simple elimination game. Statement 1 is a standard static fact found in every basic economy book. If you know SEBI regulates CRAs, the entire question is solved instantly.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Are credit rating agencies in India regulated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)?
- Statement 2: Is the rating agency ICRA (Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency of India) incorporated as a public limited company in India?
- Statement 3: Is Brickwork Ratings an Indian credit rating agency?
- Directly states which regulator primarily oversees credit rating agencies in India.
- Names the applicable SEBI regulation (SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999), implying primary regulation is by SEBI, not RBI.
- Confirms CRAs are those registered with SEBI for specified purposes.
- Also notes RBI may specify other credit rating agencies from time to time, indicating RBI can play a limited/occasional role but not primary regulator.
Explicitly states that SEBI is responsible for regulation of CRAs in India (identifies the regulator for credit rating agencies).
A student could use this to infer CRAs fall under securities-market regulation (SEBI) rather than central-bank supervision and then check SEBI rules or the list of entities it regulates.
Says Credit Information Companies (CICs) are regulated and licensed by RBI under a specific Act, showing RBI's regulatory role over some credit-related agencies.
A student can contrast the statutory regulator for CICs (RBI) with the regulator named for CRAs (SEBI) to distinguish the two types of credit-related entities.
Lists major Acts administered by RBI and includes the Credit Information Companies (Regulation) Act, 2005 — indicating which credit-related entities fall under RBI's legal remit.
A student could use the list of Acts to map which institutions RBI oversees and then check whether CRAs appear under any RBI-administered Act (they do not here).
Describes categories RBI regulates (Financial Institutions, NBFCs, Primary Dealers, CICs) showing RBI's scope and implying other financial regulators may cover remaining entities.
A student could note RBI's stated scope and, using that scope plus the regulator named for CRAs (snippet 9), deduce CRAs likely fall outside RBI's regulatory domain.
Explains that certain financial activities (payment systems) require RBI authorisation under a specific Act, illustrating the pattern that India assigns regulation of specific financial functions to appropriate statutes/authorities.
A student could apply this pattern: identify the statute that covers CRAs or the regulator mentioned for them (SEBI) to conclude which authority oversees that function.
- Identifies the agency using the corporate suffix 'Limited', indicating incorporation as a 'Limited' company in India.
- Explicitly states the former and current corporate name forms, linking 'Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency of India' to 'ICRA Limited'.
- Refers to the agency as 'ICRA Ltd.' and 'ICRA Limited', showing the company operates under the 'Limited' corporate form.
- Uses the full name 'Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency of India', linked to the 'Ltd.' suffix.
- An official-looking government document lists the agency as 'Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency of India Limited (ICRA)'.
- The use of 'Limited' in the official list supports that ICRA is incorporated with a 'Limited' company designation.
Lists major credit rating agencies in India and shows differing name-forms (e.g., 'CRISIL Ltd' vs 'India Ratings & Research Pvt Ltd' and also lists 'ICRA'), implying companies in this sector use formal company suffixes that signal corporate form.
A student could use the pattern of company name suffixes ('Ltd' vs 'Pvt Ltd') and check official corporate registry (MCA) or ICRA's legal name to see whether ICRA uses 'Ltd' (often public) or 'Pvt Ltd' (private).
States that SEBI is responsible for regulation of CRAs in India, showing CRAs are regulated corporate entities under Indian law.
Knowing CRAs are regulated by SEBI, a student could consult SEBI registrations/listings or SEBI publications that typically record the legal form (public/private) of registered CRAs like ICRA.
Uses ICRA among named rating agencies used as credit-rating benchmarks for regulatory rules, treating ICRA like other accredited rating agencies.
Because regulators reference specific agencies by name for compliance, one could check regulatory documents (RBI/SEBI) that often identify the agency's corporate form or require public company disclosures, helping infer ICRA's incorporation status.
Provides a concrete example (IFCI) of a financial institution becoming a 'Public Limited Company' by registration under the Companies Act, illustrating the legal pathway for entities in finance to acquire public limited status.
A student could apply this rule (Companies Act registration confers 'Public Limited Company' status) and check ICRA's registration details on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) to confirm if ICRA was registered similarly as a public limited company.
Defines what a 'Listed Public company' is and notes how private companies can become public by IPO, clarifying distinctions between private and public corporate forms.
Using this definition, a student could check whether ICRA's securities are listed (indicating a listed public company) or whether it ever conducted an IPO—helping judge if it is public limited.
- Explicitly lists 'BRICKWORK' among recognised rating agencies alongside CRISIL, FITCH, CARE, ICRA.
- Appears in the regulatory context of minimum credit-rating requirement for NBFCs, implying formal recognition in India.
- States that SEBI is responsible for regulation of credit rating agencies in India.
- Provides regulatory context that applies to agencies named elsewhere (e.g., those used for NBFC rating requirements).
- Includes 'Credit Rating Agencies' within the listed functions/concerns of SEBI.
- Reinforces that credit rating agencies are an established regulatory category in India.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter disguised as a Bouncer. Solvable 100% via Statement 1 (Standard Books: Nitin Singhania Ch 9 / Vivek Singh Ch 2).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Financial Market Infrastructure & Regulatory Jurisdiction (Who regulates whom?).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the Regulator Map: CRAs → SEBI; Credit Information Companies (CIBIL) → RBI; Housing Finance Companies → RBI (taken from NHB); Chit Funds → State Govts; Nidhi Companies → MCA; Insurance → IRDAI.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When you see a mix of 'Regulatory' statements and 'Trivia' statements (like ICRA's status), attack the Regulatory statement first. UPSC often swaps the regulator to make the statement false, allowing you to bypass the trivia.
CRAs and CICs are distinct entities with different regulators: CRAs fall under SEBI while CICs fall under the RBI regulatory domain.
High-yield for UPSC because questions often require correctly matching financial entities to their regulators; mastering this distinction prevents conflation between credit scoring/data firms and rating agencies. This links to topics on financial sector regulation, market infrastructure and investor protection.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Credit Rating Agencies > p. 282
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > Peer to Peer (P2P) Lender > p. 86
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 4. Co-operative Banks: > p. 83
The RBI administers several statutes and oversees entities such as banks, NBFCs, payment systems and Credit Information Companies under specific Acts.
Important for aspirants to memorise which Acts and institutions fall under RBI control—useful for questions on central bank functions, financial stability and regulatory reforms. It connects to fiscal-monetary interface and regulatory responses to crises.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 7: Money and Banking > Major Acts Administered by the RBI > p. 173
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > Commercial Banks > p. 67
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 10.Oversight of payment and settlement systems > p. 70
SEBI is explicitly assigned regulatory responsibility for Credit Rating Agencies in India.
Crucial for answering questions on capital market regulation and market intermediaries; helps in mapping SEBI's remit versus RBI/other regulators and frames answer strategies for governance and regulatory questions.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Credit Rating Agencies > p. 282
Credit rating agencies operating in India are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India, which frames rules for their functioning.
High-yield for economy and governance: understanding SEBI's regulatory role clarifies accountability, credibility, and compliance requirements of financial intermediaries. Links to questions on financial sector regulation, investor protection, and systemic risk.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Credit Rating Agencies > p. 282
Whether a firm is a public limited company or a private company determines its disclosure, ownership, and listing status.
Essential for company law and corporate governance topics: distinguishes legal obligations, listing implications, and avenues for raising capital. Useful for questions on corporate structure, IPOs, and FDI rules.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.8 Types of Company > p. 52
ICRA is identified among the key credit rating agencies that operate in the Indian financial system.
Important for financial sector knowledge: recognizing main CRAs helps answer questions on credit assessment, bond markets, and NBFC regulation; connects to topics on credit flow and financial stability.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > The major CRAs in India are: > p. 283
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 7: Money and Banking > NBFCs Regulated by RBI > p. 186
Brickwork is named alongside major agencies (CRISIL, ICRA, CARE, FITCH) as a recognised rating agency used for regulatory purposes.
High-yield for UPSC because named CRAs are often referenced in questions on financial regulation, NBFC/banking norms and market infrastructure. Knowing examples helps answer policy, regulatory and institution-based questions and supports linkage between regulation and market practice.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 7: Money and Banking > NBFCs Regulated by RBI > p. 186
The Logical Sibling is Credit Information Companies (CICs). While CRAs (rating issuers) are under SEBI, CICs (data collectors like CIBIL, Equifax, Experian) are regulated by the RBI under the CICRA Act, 2005. Don't confuse the two.
Use the 'Domain Logic' Hack: RBI deals with Banking and Money Markets. SEBI deals with Capital Markets and Tradable Securities. Since Credit Ratings are primarily used for Bonds/Debentures (Capital Market instruments), the regulator MUST be SEBI. Statement 1 violates this domain logic.
Link this to GS-3 (Investment Models & Capital Markets). CRAs are the gatekeepers of the Corporate Bond Market. Their failure (e.g., during the IL&FS crisis) highlights the conflict of interest in the 'Issuer-Pays Model'. This is a direct fodder point for regulatory reform answers.