Question map
Consider the following techniques/phenomena : 1. Budding and grafting in fruit plants 2. Cytoplasmic male sterility 3. Gene silencing Which of the above is/are used to create transgenic crops?
Explanation
Budding and grafting are vegetative propagation techniques, hence transgenic crops are not generally possible with these techniques.[1] Therefore, statement 1 is incorrect.
Regarding cytoplasmic male sterility, transgenic male sterility is recognized as a distinct type alongside cytoplasmic male sterility[2], and cybridization has been successfully used to transfer cytoplasmic male sterility in rice[3], indicating its application in creating modified crops. This suggests statement 2 is relevant to transgenic crop creation.
For gene silencing, gene silencing can result from unidirectional effects of one transgene on another transgene, hence statement 3 is correct.[4] When a transgene is introduced into an organism it may not show its expression, which is known as gene silencing.[5] This confirms that gene silencing is a phenomenon associated with transgenic crops.
Therefore, statements 2 and 3 are used in the context of creating transgenic crops, making option B the correct answer.
Sources- [2] https://kahedu.edu.in/naac/C-3/Additional%20documents/E-content/1115.pdf
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question is a classic 'Odd One Out' test disguised as high-tech. While 'Gene Silencing' and 'CMS' are technical, 'Budding and Grafting' is basic horticulture (NCERT Class X). The strategy is to identify the low-tech ancient method that cannot possibly be 'Transgenic' (molecular engineering) and use it to eliminate options.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Explicitly states that budding and grafting are vegetative propagation techniques.
- Directly concludes that transgenic crops are not generally possible with these techniques, refuting the statement.
- Presents the question listing 'Budding and grafting in fruit plants' among techniques being evaluated for creating transgenic crops.
- Provides context that this item is considered and contrasted with genetic mechanisms used to create transgenics (implying it's not one).
States that grafting and vegetative propagation produce plants genetically similar to the parent (clonal propagation).
A student can combine this with the fact that transgenic crops require deliberate DNA modification to infer grafting/budding alone do not create transgenics.
Explains that budding and vegetative propagation are forms of asexual reproduction producing new individuals from one parent.
Use the asexual/clonal nature to reason that these methods duplicate existing genomes rather than introduce new foreign genes as in transgenesis.
Notes practical use of grafting and budding in fruit trees to obtain earlier yields and propagation advantages.
A student could infer these techniques are horticultural/propagation tools (not genetic-modification methods) and so are unlikely to by themselves produce transgenic varieties.
Defines genetically modified (GM) crops as those whose DNA has been modified using genetic engineering techniques.
Combine this definition with the cloning/propagation clues to conclude that creating a transgenic crop requires DNA-engineering steps beyond grafting/budding.
Mentions production of 'disease-free and genetically better transplants' under protected cultivation.
A student might distinguish 'genetically better' via breeding/selection or biotech from vegetative propagation, and thus seek whether any DNA-engineering step is involved for transgenics.
- States male sterility is used for hybrid seed production and explicitly lists cytoplasmic male sterility as a type.
- Indicates CMS is a breeding/tool mechanism (for hybrids) rather than described as a transgenic method.
- Lists types of male sterility and shows 'Transgenic male sterility' as a separate category from cytoplasmic male sterility.
- Implies CMS is distinct from transgenic approaches, not itself described as creating transgenic crops.
- Describes transfer of CMS by cybridization and protoplast fusion (breeding/cytoplasmic transfer methods).
- Shows CMS is moved by cytoplasmic/biotechnical breeding techniques rather than being described as a transgenic modification.
Defines genetically modified organisms as plants whose hereditary material (DNA) is altered by inserting foreign genes (transgenes).
A student can use this to distinguish transgenic methods (direct DNA insertion) from breeding methods like CMS that manipulate fertility without inserting transgenes.
Describes artificial selection via human-created methods such as cross-pollination and hybridisation to develop new hybrid seeds.
A student could infer that cytoplasmic male sterility (a breeding tool to produce hybrids) fits under hybridisation/cross-pollination methods rather than transgenic modification.
Explains that pollen grains in the anther are the male gametes and that pollination carries pollen between flowers.
Knowing CMS prevents pollen production, a student can connect the biological role of pollen to how CMS facilitates hybrid seed production (without altering DNA via transgenes).
Mentions GM mustard (DMH-11) and notes concerns about cross-pollination contaminating other fields.
A student might use this to explore overlaps and distinctions between GM crops and hybrid breeding (both involve pollination concerns), helping judge whether CMS is a transgenic technique or a hybrid-breeding tool.
Gives a basic definition of genetically modified (GM) crops as plants whose DNA has been modified using genetic engineering techniques.
A student can contrast this definition with breeding-based approaches (like CMS-mediated hybrid production) to assess whether CMS constitutes creating transgenic crops.
- Directly answers a multiple-choice question that lists gene silencing as a technique used to create transgenic crops.
- Explicit answer states that gene silencing (statement 3) is correct as one of the techniques used.
- Describes gene silencing in the context of introducing transgenes into organisms.
- States that when a transgene is introduced it may not show expression, and this is known as gene silencing, linking the phenomenon to transgenic work.
- Places 'gene silencing' in the section about status and expression of transferred genes for gene transfer methods.
- Lists mechanisms (antisense, RNA interference) relevant to gene silencing in the context of creating/transferring transgenes.
Defines GM crops as plants whose hereditary material (DNA) is altered and states that foreign genes (transgenes) are artificially inserted into a plant's genes.
A student could reason that 'altering DNA' and inserting genes can include techniques that reduce or turn off gene expression (i.e., silencing) as one form of genetic modification and then check specific methods used in transgenics.
States GM crops are created by modifying DNA using genetic engineering and gives examples of desired traits (resistance to pests, viruses, etc.).
One can extend that genetic engineering tools used to confer such traits might include both adding genes and modifying expression levels (including silencing endogenous or viral genes) to achieve resistance.
Gives the concrete example of GM mustard containing genes from a soil bacterium conferring pest resistance (an example of introducing novel genetic elements to provide a trait).
From this example, a student could infer that different molecular strategies (adding bacterial genes or suppressing plant/virus genes) are plausible routes to create pest-resistant transgenic crops and then look up which are actually used.
Explains that genes control characteristics via the efficiency of their products (showing trait expression depends on gene activity levels).
A student could extend this to reason that modifying trait expression can be achieved not only by adding genes but also by reducing gene activity (gene silencing) and then verify whether that technique is applied in transgenic crops.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter via Elimination. Statement 1 (Grafting) is ancient gardening, not genetic engineering. Eliminating it removes Options A and C. Knowing Gene Silencing is a biotech tool (Option 3) confirms B.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Biotechnology > Applications in Agriculture. Specifically, distinguishing between Conventional Breeding (Grafting, Selection) and Molecular Breeding (Transgenics, RNAi).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the toolkit: Agrobacterium tumefaciens (Natural Genetic Engineer), Biolistics (Gene Gun), RNA Interference (RNAi), CRISPR-Cas9, and Antisense Technology. Know the products: Bt Cotton (Cry genes), GM Mustard (Barnase/Barstar), Golden Rice (Beta-carotene).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Classify techniques by 'Scale of Intervention'. Grafting = Macro (Physical joining). CMS = Cellular/Reproductive (Breeding). Gene Silencing = Molecular (DNA/RNA manipulation). Transgenics always require Molecular intervention.
References describe budding and grafting as vegetative methods used to grow fruit plants and produce genetically similar offspring.
High-yield for horticulture/agriculture questions: explains how commercial orchards multiply desirable varieties, why grafted plants bear earlier, and implications for uniformity and cultivar maintenance. Connects to topics on crop improvement and plantation management. Prepare by learning methods, advantages/disadvantages, and crop examples (banana, orange, rose, tamarind).
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.2.5 Vegetative Propagation > p. 117
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Tamarind (Tamarindus indica) > p. 67
Evidence contrasts vegetative (asexual) propagation creating genetically similar plants with sexual reproduction that generates variation via gametes and seeds.
Core biology concept often tested in UPSC prelims/mains: underpins breeding, biodiversity, and crop improvement debates. Helps distinguish conventional breeding/selection from molecular methods. Study NCERT descriptions, processes (pollination, fertilisation) and consequences for genetic variation.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > What you have learnt > p. 126
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 13: Our Home: Earth, a Unique Life Sustaining Planet > Sexual reproduction in plants > p. 222
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.2 Sexual Reproduction in Flowering Plants > p. 121
One reference defines GM crops as plants whose DNA is modified using genetic engineering techniques—conceptually different from vegetative propagation.
Essential for questions on modern agriculture, biotechnology policy, biosafety and GM debates. Distinguishes transgenic methods from grafting/budding and from hybridisation/artificial selection. Revise definitions, techniques, and policy implications from reliable sources and NCERT-level biotech summaries.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 25: Agriculture > Beneficial effects of weeds > p. 365
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 2: PLANT AND ANIMAL KINGDOMS > 2.4 Environment and Ecology > p. 5
The statement mentions 'transgenic crops'; several references define GM crops and describe insertion of foreign genes (transgenes).
Understanding the basic definition and mechanisms of GM/transgenic crops is high-yield for GS and science sections; it links to biotechnology, agriculture policy and biosafety debates. Prepare by learning definitions, common methods of genetic modification, and examples.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 25: Agriculture > Beneficial effects of weeds > p. 365
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > GENETICALLY MODIFIED (GM) CROPS > p. 301
Cytoplasmic male sterility is a method used in producing hybrids; the references discuss artificial selection, cross-pollination and hybridisation for developing improved seeds.
Mastering conventional breeding methods (hybridisation, selection) is useful for comparing with biotechnological methods and for questions on agricultural improvement. Relate these concepts to seed technology and plant breeding topics; revise examples and roles of hybrid seed production.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 2: PLANT AND ANIMAL KINGDOMS > 2.4 Environment and Ecology > p. 5
The references reference the GM mustard (DMH-11) case and GEAC's role in field trials and commercial release decisions, linking policy/regulation to GM crop deployment.
Knowledge of regulatory frameworks and notable cases (e.g., GM mustard, GEAC actions) is often tested in polity/environment/agriculture contexts. Study institutional roles, approval steps, and controversies to answer policy and ethics questions effectively.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > 9.16 Indian Economy > p. 302
Several references define GM crops as plants whose DNA has been altered by inserting foreign genes (transgenes), which is the basic mechanism contrasted with other methods such as gene silencing.
High-yield concept for biotechnology questions: UPSC asks definitions, basic mechanisms and to distinguish methods (e.g., transgene insertion vs other genetic approaches). Master this to answer questions comparing techniques, their purposes and implications. Prepare by consolidating textbook definitions and mechanism sketches, and practice short comparisons.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > GENETICALLY MODIFIED (GM) CROPS > p. 301
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 11: Agriculture - Part II > 11.8 Genetically Modified (GM) Crops > p. 342
Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Since the question covers methods to create transgenics, the 'vector' is the next logical question. Agrobacterium is the most common vector for plants, often called nature's genetic engineer.
The 'Timeline Test'. Budding and Grafting have been used since Roman times. Transgenic crops appeared in the 1980s. An ancient technique cannot be the definition of a modern invention. If an option mixes the Stone Age with the Space Age, the Stone Age item is the eliminator.
Link this to GS-3 Agriculture & IPR. GM crops (like Bt Cotton) involve 'Terminator Technology' or 'Trait Fees', creating dependency on MNCs. Contrast this with Grafting, which is farmer-controlled and open-source.