Question map
In 1920, which of the following changed its name to "Swarajya Sabha" ?
Explanation
In 1920, Gandhi accepted the presidentship of the All India Home Rule League, and changed the organisation's name to Swarajya Sabha.[1] This transformation marked a significant shift in the Indian independence movement as Gandhi's fresh approach to the freedom struggle was gaining momentum. Annie Besant had set up her All-India Home Rule League in September 1916 in Madras[2], and in 1916, two Home Rule Movements were launched in the country: one under Tilak and the other under Besant.[3] However, by 1920, Gandhi's fresh approach to the struggle for freedom was slowly but surely catching the imagination of the people, and the mass movement that was gathering momentum pushed the home rule movement onto the side lines till it petered out.[1] The renaming to Swarajya Sabha reflected this transition under Gandhi's leadership and his emphasis on complete self-rule (Swaraj) rather than just home rule within the British Empire.
Sources- [1] Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Home Rule League Movement > p. 299
- [2] Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Besant's League > p. 297
- [3] History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 3: Impact of World War I on Indian Freedom Movement > 3.1 All India Home Rule League > p. 33
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Spectrum footnote' question. It rewards the student who reads the *end* of a chapter (Decline of Home Rule League) as carefully as the beginning. It marks the precise moment Gandhi hijacked the existing political machinery to launch Non-Cooperation.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Did the All India Home Rule League change its name to "Swarajya Sabha" in 1920?
- Statement 2: Did the Hindu Mahasabha change its name to "Swarajya Sabha" in 1920?
- Statement 3: Did the South Indian Liberal Federation change its name to "Swarajya Sabha" in 1920?
- Statement 4: Did The Servants of India Society change its name to "Swarajya Sabha" in 1920?
Gives a clear example that an Indian 'Home Rule' organisation underwent a formal renaming (Indian Home Rule League → Commonwealth of India League), showing name changes did occur.
A student could compare dates and contexts of known renamings to see if a 1920 renaming of the All India Home Rule League is plausible or documented elsewhere.
Describes the All India Home Rule League as an organised body (two leagues with defined objectives), implying such bodies could be restructured or renamed as leadership and aims shifted.
Use this pattern to check whether organisational shifts around 1920 (leadership changes, objective shifts) might have prompted a renaming to 'Swarajya Sabha'.
Notes that two distinct Home Rule Leagues existed (Tilak's and Besant's), indicating multiple related organisations and possible consolidation or rebranding events.
A student could look for evidence of consolidation or rebranding between these leagues around 1920 that could explain a new name like 'Swarajya Sabha'.
Reports that in 1920 Gandhi accepted the presidency of the All India Home Rule League and (according to this source) changed its name to 'Swarajya Sabha'—an explicit example of a claimed renaming event in that year.
Cross-check this specific claim against other contemporary records or histories (newspapers, Congress/Gandhi writings from 1920) to verify the asserted renaming.
Summarises the rise and significance of the Home Rule League movement, highlighting the political vacuum and leadership changes that could create conditions for renaming.
Investigate whether the political vacuum and leadership transitions around 1920 correspond with any formal renaming or reorganisation to a body called 'Swarajya Sabha'.
Shows an explicit historical example where an organisation (All India Home Rule League) was renamed 'Swarajya Sabha' in 1920 under Gandhi's leadership.
A student could use this to check whether 'Swarajya Sabha' was associated with the Home Rule League/Gandhi rather than the Hindu Mahasabha by comparing leadership, founding dates and known name-changes.
Gives the founding details and identity of the All-India Hindu Mahasabha (founded 1915, headquarters at Dehra Dun), establishing its separate origin and leadership context.
One can compare the Mahasabha's founding facts and leadership with those of organisations known to adopt the 'Swarajya Sabha' name to test continuity or a name-change claim.
Notes first session of All-India Hindu Mahasabha in April 1915 and mentions later distinct organisations (e.g., RSS in 1925), indicating separate organisational trajectories.
Use this pattern of distinct founding dates/team to judge whether a 1920 name change is plausible for the Mahasabha versus a different body formed/renamed at that time.
Mentions 'Swarajya party' (a distinct Congress-related formation) showing that the term 'Swarajya' was used by multiple, different organisations in this period.
A student could infer that 'Swarajya' names were used by varied groups and therefore should verify which specific organisation adopted 'Swarajya Sabha' in 1920 rather than assuming it was the Mahasabha.
Describes efforts to revive Hindu Mahasabha activity around 1921 (cow-protection propaganda), indicating the Mahasabha remained an active, distinct entity in the early 1920s.
Compare this evidence of ongoing Mahasabha activity with any claimed 1920 organisational renaming — if Mahasabha continued particular activities under the same name, a wholesale name-change is less likely.
- States the South Indian Liberal Federation officially came into existence in 1917 and became known as the Justice Party.
- Shows the organisation's public name was Justice (the newspaper) and that the federation 'Thus was born the Justice Party', contradicting a renaming to 'Swarajya Sabha' in 1920.
- Refers to the Justice Party being in power and winning a majority in elections to the Madras Legislative Council constituted in 1920.
- Directly indicates the organisation active in 1920 was called the Justice Party, not 'Swarajya Sabha'.
- Describes the 1916 founding meeting and formation of associated organisations (South Indian People’s Association) to publish a newspaper and form a political association.
- Supports the timeline and organisational names around 1916–1917 that led to the Justice Party, with no mention of a renaming to 'Swarajya Sabha' in 1920.
Reports that in 1920 Gandhi accepted presidency of the All India Home Rule League and changed that organisation's name to 'Swarajya Sabha'—showing a documented instance (and date) of an organisation being renamed to 'Swarajya Sabha' in 1920.
A student could use this precedent to ask whether other contemporary organisations (e.g., regional liberal federations) also adopted the 'Swarajya Sabha' name in 1920 or if this renaming was unique to the Home Rule League.
Notes the existence of an 'Indian Liberal Federation' formed by moderate/liberal leaders—demonstrates that organisations with 'Liberal Federation' in their name existed around this period.
One could check if regional bodies like the South Indian Liberal Federation were organizationally linked to or followed naming patterns of the Indian Liberal Federation and thus might plausibly have renamed themselves.
Describes regional Madras organisations using the term 'Sabha' (e.g., Madras Mahajana Sabha), showing that 'Sabha' was a common suffix for regional political groups.
Combining this naming convention with the 1920 example could suggest it was plausible for a South Indian body to adopt 'Swarajya Sabha' as a name, so a student could look for regional records using 'Swarajya Sabha'.
Mentions the emergence of 'Swaraj'/'Swarajya' political terminology and parties (e.g., Swaraj Party formed 1923), indicating 'Swaraj(a)'-based names were in currency in the early 1920s.
A student could use this to argue that adoption of 'Swarajya' in organisation names around 1920–1923 was part of a broader naming trend and search dated sources for such name changes.
Discusses 'Swarajists' and Swarajist activity in councils, showing active usage of the 'Swaraj' label in political movements of the era.
A student could survey contemporaneous reports of regional liberal federations to see if they aligned with or adopted the 'Swaraj' label used by these political currents.
Reports a 1920 name change to 'Swarajya Sabha' — but explicitly attributes this change to the All India Home Rule League under Gandhi, not to the Servants of India Society.
A student could use this to test the claim by checking which organisation actually renamed itself in 1920 (Home Rule League) and comparing organisational identities/timelines to see if Servants of India Society and the Home Rule League were the same.
Describes the Servants of India Society (founded 1905) and states it 'chose to remain aloof from political activities and organisations like the Indian National Congress.'
Using the political character implied here, a student could judge the plausibility of a 1920 renaming to an explicitly political-sounding 'Swarajya Sabha' by comparing the Society's apolitical stance with the name's political connotations.
Explains the emergence of the Swarajya/Swarajist political formations within Congress and their electoral/legislative activity — showing 'Swarajya' as a label used for political parties/movements.
A student could extend this by noting that 'Swarajya' was commonly used by political groups around 1920–22, and therefore check whether the Servants of India Society (an apolitical reform body) adopted such a political name.
Describes formation of the Congress-Khilafat Swarajya (Swarajist) Party in the early 1920s, reinforcing that 'Swarajya' labels were associated with new political parties at that time.
A student could use this pattern to hypothesize that a renaming to 'Swarajya Sabha' would more likely be associated with a political organisation active in the Swarajya/Swarajist movement than with a reform society.
Lists the Servants of India Society among socio-cultural reform movements (not under political associations), underscoring its reformist, social character in contrast to the explicitly political usages of 'Swarajya' elsewhere.
Combine this classification with the political uses of 'Swarajya' in 1920 to infer that a name change to 'Swarajya Sabha' would be atypical for an organisation placed in the reform movements category.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. Verbatim in Rajiv Ahir (Spectrum), Chapter 14 ('Home Rule League Movement').
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: The 'Gandhian Takeover' phase (1919-1920). How Gandhi absorbed existing cadres (Home Rule Leagues, Khilafat Committees) into the Congress fold.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: (1) South Indian Liberal Federation (1916) → Justice Party → Dravidar Kazhagam (1944). (2) Indian National Liberal Federation (1919) → Formed by S.N. Banerjee (Moderates) supporting Mont-Ford reforms. (3) Swaraj Party (1923) → C.R. Das & Motilal Nehru. (4) Independence for India League (1928) → Nehru & Bose.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Stop memorizing just the 'Founding Year'. Create a 'Lifecycle Tracker' for major bodies: Birth → Split → Merger/Renaming → Death. The *end* of the Home Rule League is as important as its start.
Several references describe the founding (1915–16/1916) and leaders (Annie Besant, Tilak) of the Home Rule Leagues, which is essential context for any later organisational changes.
High-yield for questions on early 20th-century nationalist organisations: helps distinguish between multiple Home Rule bodies, their founders, and regional bases; connects to leadership shifts and subsequent movements (e.g., Gandhi's role). Study by mapping founders, dates, regions, and objectives to answer source-based and comparative questions.
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Besant's League > p. 297
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 3: Impact of World War I on Indian Freedom Movement > 3.1 All India Home Rule League > p. 33
- Modern India ,Bipin Chandra, History class XII (NCERT 1982 ed.)[Old NCERT] > Chapter 14: Nationalist Movement 1905—1918 > The Home Rule Leagues > p. 257
References record name changes and transformations of Home Rule-related organisations (e.g., claim of change to Swarajya Sabha; another reference noting renaming to Commonwealth of India League), making renaming a recurring theme.
Important for source evaluation and chronology questions—UPSC often asks about continuity, transformation, and lineage of political organisations. Master by creating timelines of organisational names, key events and leaders to identify contradictions in sources.
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Home Rule League Movement > p. 299
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 3: Impact of World War I on Indian Freedom Movement > d) Decline of Home Rule Movement > p. 34
One reference links Gandhi to the presidency of the Home Rule League and to renaming it 'Swarajya Sabha'; other references show Gandhi's use of 'Swaraj'.
Helps answer questions on Gandhi's evolving role in nationalist politics and the political vocabulary he popularised (Swaraj/Swarajya). Useful for essay and source-based questions that probe ideological shifts and nomenclature; study Gandhi's interventions and published writings alongside organisational roles.
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Home Rule League Movement > p. 299
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 35: Making of the Constitution for India > Background > p. 611
Several references state the Hindu Mahasabha was founded in 1915 at Haridwar and describe its urban, communal character — important to distinguish it from other organisations.
High-yield for UPSC: knowing founding dates, places and social base helps answer questions on communal organisations and their roles in nationalist politics. It connects to topics on communalism, leaders, and contrasts with other contemporary bodies. Practice by building timelines and comparing organisational aims and bases.
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 6: Communalism in Nationalist Politics > 6.3 Emergence of the All India Hindu Mahasabha > p. 76
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 24: Post-War National Scenario > Communal Reaction by Majority Community > p. 484
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 6: Communalism in Nationalist Politics > 6.3 Emergence of the All India Hindu Mahasabha > p. 77
One reference explicitly states that in 1920 Gandhi accepted presidency of the All India Home Rule League and changed its name to Swarajya Sabha — directly relevant to any claim about the name 'Swarajya Sabha'.
High-yield: clarifies that 'Swarajya Sabha' is associated with Gandhi and the Home Rule League, not the Hindu Mahasabha. Useful for avoiding conflation of organisations in answers. Helps in questions on Gandhi's organisational roles and mass mobilisation strategies.
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Home Rule League Movement > p. 299
The references collectively show separate identities (Hindu Mahasabha founded 1915; Swarajya Sabha name change occurs in the Home Rule League in 1920), highlighting the need to attribute name changes to the correct organisation.
Strategic for UPSC: many questions test precise identification of organisations, leaders and timelines. Mastering this prevents factual errors and supports comparative/analytical answers. Practice by creating parallel timelines of key organisations (Congress, Home Rule League, Hindu Mahasabha, RSS).
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 6: Communalism in Nationalist Politics > 6.3 Emergence of the All India Hindu Mahasabha > p. 76
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Home Rule League Movement > p. 299
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 6: Communalism in Nationalist Politics > 6.3 Emergence of the All India Hindu Mahasabha > p. 77
Reference [4] records that in 1920 Gandhi accepted the presidentship of the All India Home Rule League and the organisation's name was changed to Swarajya Sabha.
High-yield for UPSC because many questions test chronology and name-changes of nationalist organisations and Gandhi's institutional roles. Mastering this helps correctly attribute actions (who renamed which body, and when) and avoids conflating different organisations.
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 14: First World War and Nationalist Response > Home Rule League Movement > p. 299
The 'Indian National Liberal Federation' was founded in 1919 by Surendranath Banerjee. Why? To support the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms when Congress rejected them. It represents the final exit of the Moderates from Congress.
Use 'Linguistic Translation' Logic. 'Home Rule' literally translates to 'Swaraj' (Self-Rule). 'League' translates to 'Sabha'. The name change was a literal vernacular translation to appeal to the masses. Options B, C, and D have no semantic link to the term 'Home Rule'.
Connects to GS1 Post-Independence Consolidation. The Justice Party (Option C) eventually evolved into the DMK/AIADMK lineage, showing how pre-independence social movements shaped modern regional politics.