Question map
In India, the use of carbofuran, methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos is viewed with apprehension. These chemicals are used as
Explanation
The correct answer is option A because carbofuran, along with other similar formulations, are being used as pesticides (PPC) in India[2], and bans for methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos have been announced by the Central Government in 2018 and 2020[5]. The apprehension mentioned in the question stems from the fact that pesticides are noted contaminants and are defined as harmful to human health[2]. Additionally, Methyl Parathion formulations are banned for use on fruits and vegetables[7], indicating their classification as agricultural pesticides. The fact that carbofuran remains among the nine pesticides banned in Kerala but still in use nationally with no plans for regulatory action[8] further underscores the concern around these chemicals as agricultural pesticides rather than food preservatives, fruit-ripening agents, or cosmetic ingredients.
Sources- [1] https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/687321468268482001/pdf/E1241.pdf
- [2] https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/687321468268482001/pdf/E1241.pdf
- [3] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7031890/
- [4] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7031890/
- [5] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7031890/
- [6] https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099070924080580800/pdf/P178418150fcb303d18a2716224eddb3e0f.pdf
- [7] https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099070924080580800/pdf/P178418150fcb303d18a2716224eddb3e0f.pdf
- [8] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7031890/
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Group Identification' question triggered by current regulatory bans. While the specific news (bans in 2018/2020) makes it current affairs, the static knowledge of 'Carbofuran' or 'Phorate' as hazardous pesticides is available in standard Environment textbooks (Shankar/Majid Hussain). You only needed to identify ONE chemical to crack the whole group.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: In India, are carbofuran, methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos used as pesticides in agriculture?
- Statement 2: In India, are carbofuran, methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos used as preservatives in processed foods?
- Statement 3: In India, are carbofuran, methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos used as fruit-ripening agents?
- Statement 4: In India, are carbofuran, methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos used as moisturising agents in cosmetics?
- Peer-reviewed PMC article states central government announced bans for methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos, implying prior agricultural use.
- The same passage explicitly lists carbofuran as a pesticide remaining in use nationally.
- World Bank document explicitly states Carbofuran is being used in India despite bans in developed countries.
- This supports that carbofuran is (or was) used as an agricultural pesticide in India.
- Government/plant protection document discusses regulatory restrictions on Methyl Parathion, indicating its use in agriculture and subsequent limited bans.
- Shows methyl parathion was permitted on certain crops, demonstrating agricultural application in India.
Gives a concrete list of pesticides banned for manufacture/import/use in India and explicitly names 'Carbofuran (50% wp)'.
A student could check whether the other named chemicals (methyl parathion, phorate, triazophos) appear on similar official banned/registered lists or historic use lists to infer past or present use.
Lists specific insecticides (neonicotinoids) used as soil applications and discusses registration and environmental concernsβshows that named chemical classes and products are tracked and regulated.
Use this pattern (that particular active ingredients are listed by class and registration status) to look up registration/usage status of methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos in Indian regulatory documents.
States that use of pesticides in India has increased significantly since the 1960s because HYV crops are pestβsusceptible, implying wide agricultural reliance on various pesticide compounds.
Combine this general increase with knowledge of common historical pesticide classes to suspect that organophosphates and carbamates (families that include the named chemicals) were/are used, then verify against lists.
Notes that modern farming in Punjab required chemical pesticides and fertilisers and that chemicals have leached into groundwater, indicating heavy local pesticide use.
A student could use the regional example (Punjab) plus crop patterns to check whether specific pesticides (such as phorate or triazophos) were known to be used there historically or presently.
Reports detection of multiple pesticides in human blood samples from Indian villages, showing environmental/personal exposure to agricultural pesticides.
Use the fact that pesticide residues are detectable to motivate searching residue studies or monitoring reports for the specific chemicals named in the statement.
- Names methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos in the context of government bans on pesticides in India.
- Shows these chemicals are regulated as pesticides (subject to bans), not listed as food preservatives.
- Explicitly discusses 'pesticides' as contaminants under food regulation and lists Carbofuran among pesticide formulations used in India.
- Frames Carbofuran as a pesticide/contaminant, implying it is not a preservative used in processed foods.
- Lists Carbofuran, Phorate and Triazophos among hazardous pesticides (WHO class listings) used/recognized in India.
- Includes Parathion-methyl (methyl parathion) in the same hazardous pesticide list, supporting that these are pesticide chemicals.
Lists carbofuran (50% wp) among pesticides banned for manufacture, import, use β showing at least one named chemical is officially prohibited for use in India.
A student could check whether a substance banned for manufacture/import/use would legally be available or permitted as a food preservative, especially in processed foods regulated by Indian authorities.
Notes that pesticides are commonly used in India and have been detected in human blood, indicating pesticide presence/use in the environment/food chain.
One could combine this with regulatory lists to assess whether detected pesticides are agricultural contaminants versus intentionally added preservatives in processed foods.
Defines 'preserve the food items' as a key reason for food processing, implying the processed-food sector uses methods/agents for preservation that are subject to regulation and oversight.
A student can use this to ask whether preservation agents include/allow pesticides, and then consult regulatory lists (FSSAI) or banned-pesticide lists to evaluate permissibility.
Explains 'organic' processed foods are produced without chemical pesticides and processed without chemical additives, highlighting that chemical additives (including toxic chemicals) are a distinct category from allowed preservatives in organic certification.
This helps a student distinguish between substances used as agricultural pesticides and those permitted as food preservatives, and to check certification/regulatory exclusions for the named chemicals.
Mentions APEDA and the institutional framework around processed food exports, implying processed-food inputs and safety are monitored by export/regulatory bodies.
A student could infer that export and domestic food-safety authorities maintain lists of permitted/forbidden additives and cross-check whether the named pesticides appear on permitted preservative lists.
- Specifically states methyl parathion formulations are banned for use on fruits and vegetables, implying it is not an approved fruit ripening agent.
- Shows regulatory restriction on use of methyl parathion on fruits, directly relevant to whether it could be used as a ripener.
- Notes central government bans for methyl parathion (2018) and for phorate and triazophos (2020), treating them as pesticides subject to regulatory prohibition.
- Frames these chemicals in the context of pesticide bans rather than as permitted fruit-ripening agents.
- Lists carbofuran and triazophos among highly hazardous pesticides, indicating their classification and intended role as pesticides, not as ripening agents.
- Supports the interpretation that these chemicals are pesticide products, subject to hazard classification and regulation.
Lists carbofuran among pesticides banned for manufacture/import/use in India, showing carbofuran is a known pesticide regulated at the national level.
A student could check regulatory or news sources for banned pesticide misuse (including carbofuran) as improvised ripening agents or illegal applications to fruits.
Describes India's very large and diverse fruit production (mango, banana, citrus, etc.), indicating a large market and demand where ripening practices might be applied.
Combine this with knowledge that high-volume fruit markets sometimes drive informal/illegal ripening methods, then investigate region-specific reports of chemical ripeners.
States India is the second largest producer of fruits and vegetables, reinforcing the scale of the sector where post-harvest ripening practices are relevant.
Use this production scale plus common post-harvest supply-chain pressures to motivate checking whether organophosphate/acaricide pesticides (like methyl parathion, phorate, triazophos) have been repurposed as ripeners in reported cases.
Explains the FPO mark and food-safety certification that applies to processed fruit products, implying regulatory mechanisms target chemical safety in fruit supply chains.
A student could use the existence of food-safety certification to search official enforcement records or FSSAI advisories for incidents of banned/unsafe chemicals used on fruits (including ripening misuse).
- This peer-reviewed source identifies methyl parathion, phorate and triazophos as pesticides that have been subject to regulatory bans in India.
- It also notes carbofuran among pesticides remaining in use nationally, indicating agricultural/pesticide use rather than any cosmetic use.
- This source lists Phorate, Carbofuran and Triazophos together in a roster of highly hazardous pesticides used/considered in India.
- Listing these chemicals as hazardous pesticides supports that their primary context in India is agricultural/pesticidal, not as cosmetic moisturisers.
- This government/technical document specifically discusses Methyl Parathion in the context of agricultural use and regulatory bans.
- Evidence of regulatory control on methyl parathion as a pesticide reinforces that it is not described as a cosmetic moisturising agent.
Gives a list of substances explicitly identified as pesticides banned for manufacture/import/use in India and includes 'Carbofuran (50% wp)'.
A student could infer that carbofuran is a recognised pesticide (not a cosmetic emollient) and check Indian cosmetics/medicine regulators (e.g., Drugs & Cosmetics rules, CDSCO) or INCI lists to see if any of these pesticide names appear as permitted moisturising agents.
States that pesticides are commonly used in India and can be detected in human blood, implying widespread agricultural/pesticide use rather than cosmetic application.
One could use this to argue these chemicals are primarily used agriculturally and then examine product ingredient databases or regulatory lists to confirm whether they are listed as cosmetic moisturisers.
Discusses classes of insecticidal chemicals (neonicotinoids) and concerns about environmental persistence and residues β providing a pattern that many pesticide classes are toxic, persistent, and intended for pest control.
A student could extend this general pattern (pesticides are designed for toxicity/persistence) to question their suitability as cosmetic moisturisers and then check cosmetic ingredient standards/INCI nomenclature for these specific names.
Explains that non-food oils (e.g., palm oil) are commonly used as base materials in cosmetics and toiletries, illustrating what typical moisturising/emollient ingredients look like (oils, emulsifiers).
A student can compare the chemical nature of common cosmetic moisturisers (oils, esters) with the listed pesticide names to judge plausibility, then verify via cosmetic ingredient lists/regulations.
Describes a catastrophic release from a pesticide plant (methyl isocyanate), highlighting that pesticide chemicals and their manufacture are regulated and associated with toxicity incidents.
Use this to reinforce that pesticide-related chemicals are treated as hazardous industrial compounds rather than cosmetic emollients; follow up by checking regulatory/prohibited ingredient lists for cosmetics in India.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. If you have read any standard chapter on 'Environmental Pollution' or 'Agriculture', Carbofuran and Phorate are frequently cited examples of hazardous agrochemicals.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Agriculture > Inputs > Plant Protection. Specifically, the theme of 'Negative Impacts of Green Revolution' and pesticide toxicity (Organophosphates/Carbamates).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the 'Dirty Dozen' and recent news-makers: Endosulfan (Supreme Court ban), Monocrotophos (highly toxic), Glyphosate (herbicide controversy), Diclofenac (vultures), and Malathion (locust control). Know the difference between Insecticides, Herbicides, and Rodenticides.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When you see a list of complex chemical names in UPSC, apply the 'One-Match Rule'. Do not panic if you don't know 'Triazophos'. If you know 'Carbofuran' is a pesticide, the entire list must be pesticides. Study lists of banned items by category, not individually.
India maintains lists of pesticides that are banned for manufacture, import or use, and these lists can include specific agrochemicals such as carbofuran.
High-yield for policy and environment questions: understanding which pesticides are banned ties together agricultural practice, regulatory frameworks and public health. This concept links to questions on pesticide policy, legal controls, and impacts of bans. Mastery enables answering MCQs and mains questions on regulation, enforcement and agricultural inputs.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Pesticides Banned for Manufacture, Import Use > p. 86
Use of chemical pesticides is associated with human contamination and environmental degradation, including pesticide residues in blood and groundwater and adverse impacts from intensified agriculture.
Frequently tested topic across GS papers: connects agriculture, environment and health. Knowing pathways (residue, groundwater contamination, ecosystem effects) helps in answering questions on sustainable agriculture, public health impacts, and policy responses like bans or safe-use measures.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 29: Environment Issues and Health Effects > 2g.1.ro. Pesticide In Human Blood > p. 415
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Negative Impact of High Yielding Varieties > p. 61
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 1: Natural Resources and Their Use > Overexploitation of groundwater: a caselet from Punjab > p. 13
Pesticides comprise multiple categories (insecticides, fungicides, herbicides, rodenticides) and specific chemical classes such as neonicotinoids used in soil application.
Useful for technical clarity in GS and optional papers: distinguishes roles, application methods and environmental risks of different pesticide types. Enables precise answers on impacts, appropriate substitutes (e.g., for banned chemicals), and targeted policy measures.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > ii. Pesticidesl > p. 79
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 6: Environmental Issues > Neonicotinoids > p. 120
Carbofuran is listed among chemicals banned for manufacture/import/use, highlighting regulatory treatment of certain agrochemicals.
High-yield for environment and agriculture governance topics: knowing that specific hazardous agrochemicals can be banned helps answer questions on pesticide policy, public health risks and regulatory frameworks. Links to questions on toxic substances, food safety policy and implementation.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Pesticides Banned for Manufacture, Import Use > p. 86
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 29: Environment Issues and Health Effects > 2g.1.ro. Pesticide In Human Blood > p. 415
Organic processed foods are described as being produced and processed without chemical pesticides or synthetic additives, including preservatives.
Important for questions on food standards, organic certification and consumer safety; helps distinguish organic labelling, supply-chain implications and policy incentives (e.g., state-level organic initiatives). Useful for linking agriculture, trade and regulatory bodies.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 11: Agriculture - Part II > 11.9 Organic Farming > p. 345
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 11: Agriculture - Part II > Advantages of Organic farming/products: > p. 347
Food processing is explicitly used to preserve food items and extend availability, which is the functional role of preservatives in processed foods.
Core concept for food industry and supply-chain questions: explains why preservatives (or preservation methods) are used, connects to food safety regulation (FSSAI) and export promotion, and aids answering questions on processed-food policy and storage technologies.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 13: Food Processing Industry in India > 13.2Indian Economy > p. 408
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 13: Food Processing Industry in India > CHAPTER SUMMARY > p. 420
Knowledge of which agrochemicals are banned is directly relevant to evaluating claims about their use as fruit-ripening agents.
High-yield for environment and agriculture topics: helps answer questions on public health, regulatory frameworks, and banned substances. Connects to policy, trade restrictions, and food safety debates; enables elimination-style reasoning in MCQs about permitted versus prohibited chemicals.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Pesticides Banned for Manufacture, Import Use > p. 86
Since they asked about Insecticides here, the next logical target is Herbicides (Weedicides). Watch out for 'Glyphosate', 'Atrazine', and 'Butachlor'. Also, check the 'Stockholm Convention' list of Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) like Mirex and Heptachlor.
The 'Suffix Hack': Chemical names ending in '-phos' (Phorate, Triazophos) usually indicate Organophosphates (Phosphorus-based). Names ending in '-furan' or '-thion' are typical of synthetic agrochemicals. Conversely, food preservatives usually have friendly names like 'Benzoates', 'Sorbates', or 'Sulphites'. If the names sound like chemical warfare agents, mark 'Pesticides'.
Connect this to GS-3 (Agriculture & Food Security) and GS-2 (Health). Excessive pesticide use leads to 'Cancer Trains' (Punjab case study) and rejection of Indian export consignments (Basmati rice issues due to Tricyclazole residues). This justifies the push for Organic Farming (PKVY).