Question map
With reference to forced labour (Vishti) in India during the Gupta period, which one of the following statements is correct?
Explanation
Gupta inscriptions mention terms like klipta, bali, udranga, uparikara, and iranyavesti that meant forced labor.[1] Forced labour (vishti) in lieu of taxes was practised in some regions.[2] This indicates that vishti was treated as a form of tax obligation rather than wage-based employment, serving as a source of revenue for the state. The practice essentially substituted labor service for monetary taxation, making it a revenue mechanism for the Gupta administration.
Option B is incorrect as there is no evidence suggesting vishti was totally absent in specific regions like Madhya Pradesh and Kathiawar. Option C is incorrect because forced labor by definition was unpaid service rendered in lieu of taxes, not wage-based employment with weekly wages. Option D is also incorrect as there is no documented practice of specifically sending the eldest son as the forced laborer during the Gupta period.
Sources- [1] History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > 7.5 Economic Condition > p. 95
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Term Definition' question derived directly from standard Ancient History texts (TN Board/RS Sharma). The question tests if you understand the *nature* of the term (tax/obligation) rather than just its translation. It rewards conceptual clarity over rote memorization of obscure facts.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Was forced labour (Vishti) in India during the Gupta period considered a source of income for the state, functioning as a sort of tax paid by the people?
- Statement 2: Was forced labour (Vishti) in India during the Gupta period totally absent in the Madhya Pradesh and Kathiawar regions of the Gupta Empire?
- Statement 3: Were forced labourers (Vishti) in India during the Gupta period entitled to weekly wages?
- Statement 4: Was the practice during the Gupta period that the eldest son of a labourer was sent as the forced labourer (Vishti) in India?
- Specifically places discussion of revenue and the revenue department alongside terms for forced labour (klipta, bali, udranga, uparikara, iranyavesti).
- Naming forced-labour terms in the revenue context implies these labour obligations were treated within the state's fiscal/administrative framework.
- Connects forced labour terminology directly to records kept by revenue officials (akshapataladhikrita).
- Notes the rise of feudalism and that the system put people under hardship, which implies compulsory obligations such as labor services existed.
- Provides contextual support that social structures of the period enabled extraction of labour as an imposed duty from subjects.
Describes provincial and district administrative structure (deshas/bhuktis, uparikas, vishyapatis) showing the Guptas appointed local officers to control regions.
A student could check whether these local officers were known elsewhere to levy corvée or compulsory services, and therefore infer the likelihood of vishti being practised in Madhya Pradesh (Malwa/Mekala) and Kathiawar when under Gupta administration.
Explains agrarian structures, punishments for crop damage, and role of religious endowments in cultivating land, indicating state and institutional involvement in rural labour relations.
One could compare these agrarian controls with known mechanisms for extracting labour (e.g., corvée), to evaluate whether similar coercive labour practices like vishti might have existed regionally.
States that feudalism began to take root and that the feudal system put people in some form of hardship during the Gupta period.
Using general knowledge that feudalization often involves obligations of service and labour, a student could hypothesize that forced labour practices may have been present in feudalized regions such as parts of Madhya Pradesh and Kathiawar.
Notes military campaigns and the conquest of Malwa and Gujarat by contemporary rulers, indicating that these regions (part of present-day Madhya Pradesh and Kathiawar/Gujarat) were contested and sometimes under Gupta influence.
Knowing these regions were under Gupta control at times, a student could investigate local inscriptions or administrative records from Malwa and Gujarat to look for references to forced labour or corvée practices.
Says Gupta kings consolidated power through land grants and matrimonial alliances, highlighting land grant policy as a tool of governance.
Since land grants elsewhere often changed labour obligations (granting land could exempt certain services or transfer labour rights), a student could examine whether grants in Madhya Pradesh or Kathiawar created or abolished obligations like vishti.
Defines 'begar' as compulsory work without remuneration and describes 'forced labour' as work compelled against a person's will, including economically compelled underpayment.
A student could compare the definition of begar/forced labour with the term 'Vishti' from other sources to infer whether Vishti was likely unpaid or underpaid.
States that money was used, borrowed and loaned in Gupta times and that many gold coins were issued, indicating an active monetary economy.
Combine this with knowledge that a monetized economy can support regular wage payments to test if labour (including Vishti) might have been compensated.
Describes large-scale mining and metallurgy and the prominence of blacksmiths, implying significant organized labour requirements in the period.
A student could ask whether large organized industries typically used paid labour versus compulsory corvée and seek primary inscriptions/accounts naming Vishti in mining contexts.
Prompts examination of land classification, tenures and the role of guilds in the Gupta period, pointing to institutional arrangements that could determine labour remuneration.
Use this to investigate whether guild records or land-tenure documents mention payment practices for labourers like Vishti (wage vs. unpaid service).
Notes prolonged peace, economic strength and state support for culture/science during the Gupta 'classical age', suggesting fiscal capacity to remunerate workers.
A student could weigh the state's fiscal ability to pay against known practices (e.g., begar) to assess plausibility of regular wages for forced labourers.
This source lists 'land classification and land tenures' as a topic discussed for the Gupta period, implying the texts treat agrarian arrangements and obligations.
A student could consult standard summaries of Gupta land-tenure systems (e.g., royal grants, rent-in-kind, corvée) to see if a forced-labour practice assigning eldest sons is recorded.
The snippet emphasises prolonged peace, economic stability, and state support for scholars/artisans, indicating a functioning economy that relied on organized labour arrangements.
Use this to check whether stable economies typically formalise hereditary labour obligations (compare with known corvée systems) to assess plausibility of a Vishti-like practice.
Discussion of flourishing mining and metallurgy and importance of agriculturists suggests sizeable skilled and unskilled labour forces and organized occupational roles in the period.
A student might investigate whether labour for mines/metalworks was supplied by coerced/assigned family members (eldest-son obligations) in contemporary inscriptions or texts.
Mentions 'Feudalism: The social formation of feudalism was the characteristic of the medieval society in India,' pointing to changing social formations and labour obligations across periods.
Compare timelines: if feudal labour obligations arose later, that may weaken claims of a specific eldest-son forced-labour practice in the Gupta era; consult periodisation to test timing.
Describes how colonial-era indentured labour and slavery differed and were documented, offering a contrast that highlights the need for documentary evidence to identify labour practices.
Use the contrast to argue that to accept a claim about Gupta forced-labour, one should seek similarly explicit documentary or inscriptional evidence from the Gupta period rather than later analogies.
- Bullet 1. [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. Directly covered in TN Class XI (p. 95) and RS Sharma (Chapter on Gupta Economy).
- Bullet 2. [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Gupta Administration > Revenue System. Specifically, the transition from 'voluntary tribute' to 'feudal obligation'.
- Bullet 3. [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the Revenue Glossary: *Bhaga* (King's share, usually 1/6), *Bali* (compulsory offering), *Udranga* (tax on permanent tenants), *Uparikara* (tax on temporary tenants), *Hiranya* (tax paid in cash/gold), and *Vata-Bhuta* (cess for wind/spirits rites).
- Bullet 4. [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When studying the 'Golden Age', actively look for the 'Dark Side'—the plight of the commoner. UPSC loves to deconstruct the Golden Age myth by asking about *Vishti* (forced labour), *Chandalas* (untouchability), or the decline of trade.
Understanding the range of Gupta state revenues (land tax, fines, trade levies) is necessary to judge whether forced labour was treated as a fiscal extraction.
High-yield for revenue-and-state-formation questions; links fiscal institutions to political power and administration. Mastery helps answer questions about state finance, military funding, and administrative offices in ancient India.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 7: The Gupta Era: An Age of Tireless Creativity > Thriving trade > p. 156
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > 7.5 Economic Condition > p. 95
Forced-labour terms appear within the revenue/administrative context, framing vishti as an imposed obligation comparable to other state levies.
Directly relevant for questions on corvée, peasant obligations and non-monetary taxes; useful for comparing fiscal systems (monetary vs. labour levies) across periods and regions.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > 7.5 Economic Condition > p. 95
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Introduction > p. 89
The emergence of feudal relations created compulsory duties and hardships that could take the form of labour services extracted by rulers or lords.
Helps answer polity-society questions where social structure explains mechanisms of resource extraction; connects land tenure, peasant status, and fiscal obligations in ancient and medieval contexts.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Introduction > p. 89
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > 7.5 Economic Condition > p. 95
Local governors (uparikas) and district officers (vishyapatis) administered provinces and districts, determining how imperial policies were implemented regionally.
High-yield for UPSC: understanding administrative tiers explains regional variation in law, labour obligations and revenue. Connects to topics on state formation, decentralization and interpretation of inscriptions. Enables answers about why a policy might vary across regions and how to read administrative evidence.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Division of the Empire > p. 94
Feudal social formation and land tenures shaped rural hierarchies and labour relations during and after the Gupta era.
Important for essays and mains answers on socio-economic change: links political decline to rise of feudal relations, land grants and labour obligations. Helps analyze causes of regional differences in obligations such as corvée or vishti.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Introduction > p. 89
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Agriculture and Agrarian Structure > p. 95
Brahmin, Buddhist and Jain sanghas received donated lands and cultivated waste lands, influencing local land tenure and labour patterns.
Useful across polity, history and economy: explains non-state landholders' impact on agrarian relations and labour mobilization. Enables candidates to assess multiple actors (state, caste groups, religious institutions) when explaining regional labour practices.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Agriculture and Agrarian Structure > p. 95
Begar defines compulsory work without remuneration and the concept of forced labour includes economic compulsion such as working for less than a minimum wage.
High-yield for questions on labour history and rights: clarifies the definition of unfree labour versus paid labour and connects ancient practices to later legal frameworks. Useful for comparative questions on labour forms and state obligations.
- Indian Polity, M. Laxmikanth(7th ed.) > Chapter 8: Fundamental Rights > II I Prohibition of Traffic in Human Beings and Forced Labour > p. 93
The Junagarh Inscription of Rudradaman (Saka ruler, pre-Gupta) explicitly boasts that he repaired the Sudarshana Lake *without* levying 'Vishti' or 'Pranaya' (emergency tax). This implies Vishti was a hated practice even before the Guptas formalized it.
Apply the 'Anachronism Filter'. Option C mentions 'weekly wages'—the concept of a 'week' (Sunday to Saturday) and 'weekly wage cycles' is a modern industrial construct, not an ancient agrarian one. Option B uses 'Totally absent' for Madhya Pradesh (the Gupta heartland/Malwa)—extreme statements about core regions are almost always false.
Link 'Vishti' to **Polity (Article 23)**: The Constitution prohibits 'Begar' and other forms of forced labour. 'Begar' is the direct medieval/modern descendant of the ancient 'Vishti'. This connects Ancient History to Fundamental Rights.