Question map
With reference to Mian Tansen, which one of the following statements is not correct?
Explanation
The correct answer is option A because Akbar gave him the title "Mian," which is an honorific meaning learned man[2], not "Tansen." Tansen was his actual name, not a title bestowed by the emperor.
Option B is correct as he composed many songs in praise of Hindu deities[3]. Option C is also correct since he composed songs in praise of Kings and Emperors, including Islamic hymns in reverence to[4] Emperor Akbar[3]. Option D is correct as Tansen of Gwalior was credited with composing many ragas[5].
Therefore, option A is the only incorrect statement, making it the right answer to this question that asks which statement is "not correct."
Sources- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tansen
- [4] https://www.rudraveena.org/theBlogMusicFiles/Indian%20Music%20and%20Mian%20Tansen%20by%20Pt.%20Birendra%20Kishore%20Roy%20Chowdhury.pdf
- [5] History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Music and Dance > p. 218
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Attribution Swap' trap. The question tests depth on a specific personality (Tansen) by mixing generic truths (B, C, D) with one specific historical falsehood (A). While standard books cover Tansen's ragas and patronage, the specific origin of his title requires reading the fine print in culture modules (CCRT/Nitin Singhania).
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Explicitly states what Akbar bestowed: the passage says Akbar gave him the title 'Mian', an honorific.
- This addresses the question by identifying the specific title Akbar conferred (Mian), rather than 'Tansen'.
- Directly reports that Akbar 'bestowed upon him the honorific title ‘Mian’', linking the emperor to the conferment of 'Mian'.
- Supports answering whether Akbar gave the name 'Tansen' by showing the title credited to Akbar was 'Mian'.
- States that 'Emperor Akbar accorded the title 'Mian' to Tansen', again naming 'Mian' as the title from Akbar.
- Reinforces the point that the imperial title from Akbar was 'Mian', not explicitly 'Tansen'.
Ain-i-Akbari explicitly mentions 'Tansen of Gwalior' as patronised by Akbar, showing the imperial record identifies the musician by the name 'Tansen'.
A student could check whether Ain-i-Akbari or related court texts list this name as a formal title or as a personal/epithet, by consulting the primary text or modern editions/translations.
The Ain-i-Akbari is described as an official compendium compiled at Akbar's order, indicating that names and court designations were recorded in an authoritative source.
One could use this to prioritize searching Ain-i-Akbari/Akbar Nama entries for wording that indicates a conferred title versus a popular name.
Abu'l Fazl (patronised by Akbar) compiled Akbar Nama and Ain-i-Akbari, implying contemporaneous histories produced under Akbar's patronage are the right place to look for court-bestowed titles.
Use this pattern to examine these specific works (or their translations/indices) for any phrase like 'given the title' or 'conferred the name' regarding musicians.
An example is given of a Mughal emperor (Akbar II) conferring a title ('Raja' to Rammohan Rai), showing Mughal emperors did formally bestow titles.
Apply this general practice to Akbar's reign: a student could look for documentary evidence that Akbar similarly conferred honorifics on courtiers and musicians.
The Mughal court actively patronised musicians and promoted a syncretic culture, indicating prominent musicians like Tansen would have been publicly recognized at court.
Combine this with a world/primary-source search to see if such public recognition took the form of formal titles, nicknames, or simply patronage records.
Identifies Tansen (of Gwalior) as a composer of many ragas and a prominent court musician under Akbar — showing he was an active composer in the classical tradition.
A student could combine this with knowledge that court musicians often composed formal pieces (like dhrupad) to infer it was plausible he composed devotional works and then seek specific repertory records.
Describes an established Indian tradition of travelling singer-devotees (Alvars/Nayanars) who composed and sang hymns in praise of gods — showing a cultural pattern of musicians producing devotional compositions.
One could extend this pattern to suggest classical composers might also create devotional pieces (dhrupads) praising Hindu deities, then check historical catalogues of Tansen's works.
Explains that Vedic hymns were composed in poetic form addressed to many deities — giving a long-standing precedent for composing musical/poetic works for gods and goddesses.
Using the precedent that composers set poetic/musical texts for deities, a student could reasonably hypothesize similar practice in later classical genres (dhrupad) and investigate Tansen's repertoire for devotional texts.
Notes ritual and textual traditions directed towards various deities, indicating composers and religious practitioners produced material for gods — a broader rule that musical/religious composition often serves devotional functions.
A student can use this general rule to prioritize searching for devotional (thematic) attributions in sources on dhrupad and Tansen rather than assuming only secular composition.
Shows rulers and capitals (Vijayanagara) publicly linked to particular gods and temple culture, implying patronage environments where devotional music could be produced and valued.
A student could infer that courtly environments often encouraged compositions honoring deities; thus, investigating Mughal-era court practices and Tansen's patrons might reveal devotional dhrupads.
- Directly states Tansen composed songs that praised royal figures.
- Specifically names 'Kings and the Emperors' as the subjects of his songs, which are patrons.
- Says he composed hymns in reverence to Emperor Akbar, indicating works honoring his patron.
- Also notes he composed songs of praise (for deities and for imperial figures), showing a pattern of composing in praise.
States that Tansen was patronised by Akbar and situates him among court musicians — establishing a patron–musician relationship common in courts.
A student could use this to infer that, given court patronage, musicians often composed pieces for their patrons and then look for examples or texts (e.g., court chronicles) linking specific compositions to praise of rulers.
Explains a general pattern: kings patronised bards and poets who composed works to glorify their patrons (gives Pattinappalai example).
Apply this rule to Mughal court culture — if South Indian kings used poets to praise rulers, a student could reasonably check whether Mughal court musicians similarly composed laudatory songs for emperors.
Notes that many songs were composed in high praise of Chola glories — another example of composers producing laudatory material for rulers.
Use this as comparative evidence that composing praise-poems/songs for rulers was a recurring historical practice and therefore plausible in Tansen's case; then seek Mughal-period parallels or records.
Describes the genre of abhangs — songs explicitly composed and sung in praise (of God) — illustrating the cultural practice of composing devotional/praise songs.
A student could generalise that composing praise was a recognized function of poets/musicians, so it would be plausible for court musicians like Tansen to compose praise-songs for patrons and then search for specific attributions.
Reiterates that Tansen was patronised by Akbar (quiz format), reinforcing the court association that often motivates praise-compositions.
Combine this repeated attestation of patronage with patterns of court poets composing laudatory works to justify targeted searches for compositions linked to Akbar or the court.
- Ain-i-Akbari explicitly credits Tansen of Gwalior with composing many ragas.
- The same passage places Tansen within Akbar's court, linking royal patronage to his musical activity.
- [THE VERDICT]: Trap. Statement A is a specific historical error (Title source swapped), while B, C, and D are broad cultural truths. Source: CCRT Website / Nitin Singhania (Indian Music Chapter).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Mughal Era > Cultural Developments > The Navratnas (Nine Gems) > Tansen's Biography.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the Tansen Bio-Data: Original Name (Ramtanu Pande); Guru (Swami Haridas); Pre-Mughal Patron (Raja Ramchandra Baghela of Rewa); Title 'Tansen' (Given by Raja of Rewa/Gwalior, NOT Akbar); Title 'Mian' (Given by Akbar); Key Ragas (Mian ki Malhar, Mian ki Todi, Darbari Kanada).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When studying historical personalities, use the 'Attribute Checklist': 1. Original Name vs. Titles, 2. Who gave the title?, 3. List of Patrons (Chronological), 4. Key Creations (Books/Ragas). Never assume the most famous patron gave the most famous title.
Emperor Akbar actively patronised musicians and incorporated music into court life, which is the context for any claim about titles or honours conferred on court artists.
High-yield for UPSC questions on Mughal cultural policy and court life; helps connect questions about royal patronage, cultural syncretism, and the status of artists under the Mughals. Mastery enables candidates to answer source-based and essay questions on imperial support for arts and its political/social implications.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Music and Dance > p. 218
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Literature > p. 219
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > 14.9 Mughal Society > p. 214
Ain-i-Akbari and the Akbar Nama are principal compilations documenting court officials and cultural figures and therefore are key references when assessing names, titles, and patronage relationships.
Crucial for source-based questions and historiography in UPSC: knowing these works helps evaluate primary claims about Mughal administration and culture, and supports critical reading of later historical assertions about figures like Tansen.
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART II, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 8: Peasants, Zamindars and the State > 8. The Ain-i Akbari of Abu'l Fazl Allami > p. 217
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Music and Dance > p. 218
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Literature > p. 219
Tansen is identified as being from Gwalior and as a musician patronised by Akbar, facts central to any inquiry into his status or titles at court.
Useful for biographical and cultural-history questions: understanding regional origins and imperial patronage helps place cultural figures within broader political and social contexts, enabling comparative questions about regional music centers and courtly patronage.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Music and Dance > p. 218
Alvars and Nayanars composed hymns in praise of Vishnu and Shiva, illustrating a sustained tradition of devotional singing to Hindu gods.
High-yield for medieval cultural history: explains the musical and devotional practices that shaped regional bhakti movements and helps answer questions on continuity between devotional poetry and later musical genres. Connects religious history, literature and performance traditions useful for culture and art syllabi.
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART II, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 6: Bhakti-Sufi Traditions > 2.1 The Alvars and Nayanars of Tamil Nadu > p. 143
Tansen was a court musician credited with composing many ragas and was patronised by Akbar, showing the central role of court musicians in composing and systematising music.
Important for questions on cultural synthesis and institutional support for the arts under the Mughals; helps evaluate claims about composers' outputs and the contexts in which they worked. Links music history to political patronage and cultural policy.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Music and Dance > p. 218
Vedic hymns were composed addressing many deities, demonstrating a long-standing practice of composing poetic-musical works for gods and goddesses in Indian tradition.
Useful for tracing continuity from ancient ritual hymns to later devotional and musical forms, aiding answers on historical evolution of religious expression and performance genres. Connects ancient rituals, literature and later bhakti developments.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 7: India's Cultural Roots > a. What are the Vedas? > p. 107
Royal courts commonly patronised musicians such as Tansen, who served under rulers like Akbar.
High-yield for Mughal cultural history: explains how rulers supported artistic production and helps answer questions on court culture, patronage networks, and the institutional basis for musical developments.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 14: The Mughal Empire > Music and Dance > p. 218
The 'Next Logical Question' is about Tansen's lineage or Guru. Tansen was a disciple of Swami Haridas of Vrindavan. Unlike Tansen, Haridas refused to sing for the court, establishing the distinction between 'Darbari Sangeet' (Court Music) and 'Bhakti Sangeet' (Devotional Music).
Apply the 'Linguistic Consistency' hack. 'Tansen' is a Sanskrit-derived name (Tan + Sen). 'Mian' is a Persian/Urdu honorific. It is historically inconsistent for Akbar (Persian-speaking court) to coin a Sanskrit title like 'Tansen'. It is far more logical that he added the Persian prefix 'Mian' to an existing name. Therefore, A is the suspicious outlier.
Mains Theme: Cultural Syncretism as Statecraft. Tansen's music (Dhrupad) blended Hindu temple traditions with Persian court etiquettes, creating a 'National Culture' under Akbar. This is a prime example of Soft Power used for political legitimacy and national integration in a diverse empire.