Question map
Which of the following factors/policies were affecting the price of rice in India in the recent past ? 1. Minimum Support Price 2. Government's trading 3. Government's stockpiling 4. Consumer subsidies Select the correct answer using the code given below :
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 4 (1, 2, 3, and 4). In India, rice prices are influenced by a complex interplay of various government interventions and market policies.
- Minimum Support Price (MSP): By setting a floor price for procurement, the government directly influences the market price and incentivizes production levels.
- Government’s Trading: Through the Food Corporation of India (FCI), the state engages in large-scale procurement and occasional open market sales (OMSS) to regulate domestic supply and stabilize prices.
- Government’s Stockpiling: Maintaining buffer stocks ensures food security during lean periods. Large-scale hoarding in central pools can reduce immediate market liquidity, thereby impacting prices.
- Consumer Subsidies: Distribution of rice at highly subsidized rates through the Public Distribution System (PDS/NFSA) reduces the demand pressure on the open market, indirectly affecting commercial pricing.
Since all four factors play a critical role in the demand-supply dynamics and price discovery of rice in India, option 4 is the most comprehensive and accurate choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Applied Economics' question. It tests if you understand the ecosystem of Indian Food Policy (MSP → Procurement → Buffer Stock → PDS) rather than just memorizing definitions. It is highly fair and solvable using standard NCERT or Economy reference books by applying basic demand-supply logic.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Did India's Minimum Support Price (MSP) policy affect the price of rice in India during 2019–2020?
- Statement 2: Did government trading (procurement and market operations by state agencies) affect the price of rice in India during 2019–2020?
- Statement 3: Did government stockpiling of rice affect the price of rice in India during 2019–2020?
- Statement 4: Did consumer subsidies for rice (for example the Public Distribution System) affect the price of rice in India during 2019–2020?
This exam-style snippet lists MSP alongside government trading, stockpiling and subsidies as factors 'affecting the price of rice' in recent past, implying MSP is considered a relevant policy lever for rice prices.
A student could take this as a hypothesis that MSP influences rice prices and then check 2019–20 MSP changes and rice market price movements or procurement volumes that year.
Defines MSP as the pre-announced price at which government buys rice/wheat for the central pool with no procurement volume limit (subject to quality).
Knowing government buys rice at MSP, a student could compare MSP levels in 2019–20 with market prices and quantities procured to infer likely price pressure effects.
Explains that if market prices are above MSP the government may not procure, and that government procurement focuses mostly on wheat and rice (from certain states).
A student can use this rule to test whether 2019–20 market prices were above/below MSP and whether procurement actually occurred for rice that year, affecting supply in markets.
States that MSP-backed guaranteed procurement shifts cropping patterns toward MSP crops (like rice), affecting relative supplies and prices of other crops and contributing to food price dynamics.
A student could assess whether MSP incentives in 2019–20 affected rice acreage/production relative to other crops and thus the rice price that year.
Notes that rising MSPs have raised the government's maintenance cost for procuring foodgrains, implying fiscal/operational impacts that can feed back into food policy and prices.
A student might examine whether MSP increases near 2019–20 led to larger buffer stocks or distribution changes that influenced market rice prices in that period.
- Describes open-ended procurement of paddy/rice by FCI and state agencies at MSP into the Central Pool.
- Shows systematic government market purchases—an intervention that alters supply available to private markets.
- Identifies the institutional channel (FCI/state agencies) through which trading occurs.
- Explains the interaction between mandi (market) prices and government procurement decisions.
- States that procurement is conditional on market prices relative to MSP, implying procurement influences price formation.
- Connects procurement behaviour to incentives for farmers and market supply responses.
- Explicitly links government purchase at MSP (price subsidy) to market distortions and food price inflation.
- Explains how guaranteed procurement changes cropping incentives and supply patterns, thereby affecting prices.
Lists 'Government's stockpiling' as one of the factors/policies affecting rice prices in India (question prompt identifying relevant policy drivers).
A student could treat this as a hypothesis (stockpiling can influence price) and seek FCI stock data and price series for 2019–20 to test correlation/causation.
Repeats the same listing of factors (including government stockpiling) affecting rice price and also mentions MSP/procurement rules, linking procurement policy to market outcomes.
Use procurement/MSP and procurement-quantity rules from 2019–20 to estimate government purchases and compare with market price movements.
Defines 'Buffer Stock' as government procurement of rice/wheat via FCI and explains MSP payments and storage — provides the institutional mechanism by which stockpiling occurs.
Combine this mechanism with actual buffer stock levels (e.g., FCI reports) to infer potential market withdrawal/injection effects on prices in 2019–20.
Gives rice production figures showing an increasing trend, including 2019–20 production — a supply-side indicator that interacts with stockpiling to affect prices.
Compare production volumes in 2019–20 with government procurement/stock changes to see whether high output plus stockpiling would raise or lower market prices.
Mentions central foodgrains (wheat + rice) stock and 'Minimum Buffer Norm' with a source referencing FCI stocks for 2020–21, implying official stock level benchmarks.
A student could obtain the FCI stock vs minimum buffer norm for 2019–20 to judge whether excess/shortfall stocks likely pressured market prices.
- Specifies PDS retail prices for beneficiaries (e.g., AAY rice at Rs. 3/kg), demonstrating a government-set consumer price for rice.
- Shows that PDS pricing directly alters the price paid by a large class of consumers.
- Defines consumer subsidy as the difference between economic cost (procurement, storage, distribution) and the Central Issue Price (CIP).
- Establishes that the government bears the subsidy that keeps consumer rice prices below economic cost.
- Explains that price subsidies and guaranteed procurement at MSP distort cropping choices and market allocation.
- Provides a mechanism by which subsidy-driven procurement/pricing can influence broader food prices and market behavior.
- [THE VERDICT]: Conceptual Sitter. Solvable by connecting basic logic of Demand & Supply with standard texts (Vivek Singh/NCERT Class IX).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Agriculture > Food Management > The interplay between MSP, FCI operations, and Inflation.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Open Market Sale Scheme (OMSS), Economic Cost of Foodgrains (MSP + Procurement Incidentals + Distribution Cost), Buffer Norms vs Strategic Reserves, Shanta Kumar Committee recommendations, Price Stabilization Fund (PSF).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Stop reading policies in isolation. When reading about MSP, ask 'Does this cause inflation?'. When reading about Buffer Stocks, ask 'How does the government use this to control prices?'. Connect the dots between Policy and Market Impact.
The government purchases rice and wheat at a declared MSP to build the central pool and buffer stocks.
High-yield for questions on food security and PDS because procurement at MSP is the primary channel through which the state intervenes in cereals markets; it links to FCI operations, central pool management, and distribution under NFSA/TPDS. Understanding this helps answer policy, budgetary and supply-chain questions.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 9: Subsidies > 9.5.1 Food Corporation of India (FCI) > p. 293
- Economics, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 4: Food Security in India > What is Buffer stock? > p. 47
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 10: Agriculture - Part I > 10.3 Minimum Support Price (MSP) > p. 306
Procurement at MSP and related government stock/issue decisions alter market supply and can contribute to price movements and inflationary pressures.
Essential for analysing causes of food price inflation and crop-mix effects; this concept connects agricultural price policy to macro inflation, rural incentives, and distributional impacts — frequent UPSC mains/essay themes and policy analysis questions.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 9: Subsidies > 2. Price subsidies distort markets in a way that ultimately hurts the poor: > p. 285
- Economics, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 4: Food Security in India > What is Buffer stock? > p. 47
- Economics, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 4: Food Security in India > Let's Discuss > p. 51
MSP is announced annually based on CACP recommendations, has no statutory backing, and actual procurement is concentrated in certain crops/states rather than universal.
Useful for evaluating debates on farmers' entitlements and reform proposals; it links to governance, center-state procurement patterns, and schemes like PM-AASHA — topics that appear in polity, governance and agriculture policy questions.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 10: Agriculture - Part I > 10.3 Minimum Support Price (MSP) > p. 305
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 10: Agriculture - Part I > 10.3 Minimum Support Price (MSP) > p. 306
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 6: Economic Planning in India > I. Contribution in major Agricultural Sector Reforms: > p. 146
MSP with open-ended procurement creates a government floor price and direct market purchases that influence rice market supply and price formation.
High-yield: MSP/procurement is central to questions on agricultural price policy, market interventions and inflation. It links to topics on food security, fiscal cost of procurement, and farmer incentives, enabling answers on policy impact, trade-offs and reforms.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 9: Subsidies > 9.5.1 Food Corporation of India (FCI) > p. 292
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 10: Agriculture - Part I > 10.3 Minimum Support Price (MSP) > p. 306
FCI purchases and stores rice as buffer stock, changing market availability and stabilising or tightening supplies depending on operations.
Important for questions on food security mechanisms, storage costs, supply management and the fiscal/operational implications of public stockholding. Connects to logistics, procurement policy and PDS/food subsidy debates.
- Economics, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 4: Food Security in India > What is Buffer stock? > p. 47
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 9: Subsidies > 9.5.1 Food Corporation of India (FCI) > p. 292
Price subsidies and trade/market operations by the state can distort cropping patterns and domestic prices, creating broader price effects beyond rice alone.
Crucial for analysing consequences of government intervention: inflationary effects, distortion of resource allocation, and impacts on exports/imports. Helps frame evaluative UPSC answers assessing policy benefits vs distortions.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 9: Subsidies > 2. Price subsidies distort markets in a way that ultimately hurts the poor: > p. 285
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 10: Agriculture - Part I > Key Recommendations: > p. 326
The government procures rice through the Food Corporation of India to create buffer stocks of wheat and rice.
High-yield concept for questions on food security and price stabilization: knowing how FCI procurement creates and maintains central stocks links supply management to market outcomes and PDS functioning. It connects to topics on public distribution, inflation control, and government intervention in agricultural markets.
- Economics, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 4: Food Security in India > What is Buffer stock? > p. 47
- Economics, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 4: Food Security in India > Antyodaya Anna Yojana (AAY) > p. 50
Open Market Sale Scheme (OMSS). While this question asked about 'stockpiling' generally, the specific mechanism used to *lower* prices by selling excess stock is OMSS. Expect a future question on the specific rules, e-auction methods, or state-eligibility of OMSS.
The 'Macro-Interconnectedness' Rule. In a complex economy, *any* massive government intervention involving buying (MSP), storing (Stockpiling), or selling (Subsidies) huge quantities of a staple good *will* mathematically affect its market price. If the factor is a major policy lever, it is almost certainly correct. Go for 'All of the above' in such broad causality questions.
Mains GS-3 (Agriculture & Food Security): The 'Price Policy Dilemma'. High MSP helps farmers (Producer interest) but raises food inflation (Consumer interest). This tension is the core of India's agricultural policy debates and subsidy burden analysis.