Question map
In India, under cyber insurance for individuals, which of the following benefits are generally covered, in addition to payment for the loss of funds and other benefits ? 1. Cost of restoration of the computer system in case of malware disrupting access to one's computer 2. Cost of a new computer if some miscreant wilfully damages it, if proved so 3. Cost of hiring a specialized consultant to minimize the loss in case of cyber extortion 4. Cost of defence in the Court of Law if any third party files a suit Select the correct answer using the code given below :
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 2 (1, 3 and 4 only). Cyber insurance for individuals is designed to mitigate financial losses and legal liabilities arising from digital threats, rather than physical damage to hardware.
- Statement 1 is correct: Most policies cover the "Cost of Restoration," which includes expenses incurred to reinstall software or remove malware to restore the system to its pre-attack state.
- Statement 3 is correct: In cases of cyber extortion (e.g., ransomware), policies generally cover the costs of hiring specialized consultants or IT experts to investigate the threat and minimize potential losses.
- Statement 4 is correct: Cyber insurance typically includes "Defense Costs" to cover legal expenses if a third party sues the policyholder for defamation or data breaches resulting from the insured's system.
- Statement 2 is incorrect: Cyber insurance covers intangible digital assets and liabilities. Wilful physical damage to hardware is a matter of property or fire insurance and is a standard exclusion in cyber-specific policies.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a 'Financial Literacy' question derived from the launch of retail cyber insurance products (e.g., Bajaj Allianz, HDFC ERGO) around 2018-19. It tests the logical boundary between 'Cyber' risks (intangible/data) and 'Physical' risks (hardware). Standard books won't help; reading the 'Key Features' of major financial reforms/products is the key.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Does individual cyber insurance in India typically cover the cost of restoring a computer system disrupted by malware?
- Statement 2: Do individual cyber insurance policies in India typically pay for replacement (cost of a new computer) if a miscreant willfully damages it, when wilful damage is proven?
- Statement 3: Do individual cyber insurance policies in India typically cover the cost of hiring a specialized consultant to mitigate losses in a cyber extortion incident?
- Statement 4: Do individual cyber insurance policies in India typically cover legal defence costs if a third party files a lawsuit arising from a cyber incident?
Defines cyber crime and notes that cyber criminals use computers to access information and harm targets, framing cyber incidents (like malware) as recognized risks.
A student could infer that insurance products exist to manage such risks and then check typical cyber policy wordings to see if system restoration is listed as a covered loss.
Highlights that digital payment/CBDC ecosystems are vulnerable to cyber-attacks, showing institutional acknowledgement of cyber risk to digital systems.
A student could extend this recognition of systemic cyber risk to reason that insurers might offer products addressing loss from cyber-attacks (including restoration) and then examine product coverage details.
Distinguishes life and non-life insurance penetration in India, indicating an established non-life insurance market where cyber-risk products could be categorized.
A student can use this to narrow enquiries to non-life insurers and review standard non-life (e.g., specialty cyber) policy clauses for malware-related restoration coverage.
Lists the structure of the insurance sector (life, general, agricultural, deposit insurance), implying that specialized coverages are organized under general/non-life insurers.
A student could therefore focus on 'general insurance' companies when investigating whether individual cyber insurance policies include system restoration after malware.
Defines 'general (nonlife) insurance' as protection against losses and damages (fire, motor, home etc.), indicating cyber risks would be handled within the broad nonlife insurance domain or as a specialized product.
A student could use this to infer that coverage depends on policy wording within nonlife products and then compare typical cyber policy clauses (exclusions/coverage for physical damage) to judge if replacement is likely.
Explains cyber crime includes criminal activities using computers and that cyber criminals can 'harm the target', connecting miscreant willful damage of a computer to the category 'cyber crime'.
One could extend this by mapping 'willful physical damage by a miscreant' onto insured perils in cyber or property policies and check typical insurer lists of covered perils/exclusions.
States that a consumer has the right to get compensation 'depending on the degree of the damage', suggesting remedies (compensation) are available but contingent on assessment of damage.
A student might combine this with knowledge of how insurers assess loss (actual cash value vs replacement cost) to investigate whether replacement is ordinarily paid or only depreciation-adjusted compensation is given.
Notes low insurance penetration and 'lack of understanding of insurance products', implying that policyholders may not be aware of specific exclusions/coverages in cyber policies.
This could prompt checking sample Indian cyber policy wordings or insurer FAQs to see whether willful damage and replacement costs are standard inclusions or commonly excluded.
Discusses tort liability where proven wrongdoing can lead to compensation by the liable party (in that case the State), which is a parallel legal principle that proven willful damage creates a basis for recovery.
A student could use this to separate legal remedies (sue the miscreant for replacement) from insurance remedies (claim under policy) and thus test whether insurers typically cover such losses or leave recovery to tort claims.
Defines cyber crime as activities that threaten a person's or nation's security and finances, identifying cyber incidents as sources of financial harm.
A student could combine this with the idea that insurable products often respond to financial harms to ask whether cyber insurance products explicitly cover incident-response/consultant costs for extortion.
Gives the general insurance definition: policies protect against non‑life losses (fire, marine, motor, home etc.), implying non‑life insurance is the category that would house cyber coverages.
Use this to reason that cyber risk would be a non‑life product and then check typical non‑life policy wordings or market product features to see if consultant/forensic costs are included.
Notes that digital payment systems and CBDC ecosystems face cyber‑attack risk, highlighting systemic exposure of financial services to cyber threats.
A student could infer financial-sector exposure increases demand for incident response services and thus examine whether insurers cover those response costs in marketed cyber policies.
Summarises the insurance sector structure and reforms, indicating an active insurance market and institutional framework where new product types (like cyber insurance) could be offered.
One could use this to justify checking current general/non‑life insurance product offerings or regulatory FAQs in India for coverage of specialist consultant fees.
Provides data on insurance penetration and the division between life and non‑life markets, suggesting scope and limits of non‑life insurance products in India.
Combine this with knowledge that cyber is a niche non‑life product to assess whether market scale makes inclusion of consultant/response costs a common feature or an add‑on.
Notes that the insurance sector is governed and regulated (Union list) and that many private insurers operate under defined laws and rules.
A student could infer that regulated insurance products typically have standard-wording coverages/exclusions and therefore should check standard cyber policy wordings or IRDAI guidance to see if defence costs are listed.
Summarises the organised insurance sector and its schemes, implying insurance offerings are structured and can specify precise benefits.
Use the pattern that insurance products enumerate covered events and benefits to look up sample cyber policy schedules for inclusion/exclusion of legal defence costs.
Describes a specific insurance product (deposit insurance) with clear monetary limits and defined scope, illustrating that insurance covers specified risks and costs rather than open-ended liabilities.
Apply this rule: since some insurance types explicitly limit cover, check whether cyber policies similarly itemise defence-cost coverage or cap it.
Describes a government insurance scheme (PMFBY) with detailed premium splits and claim-settlement issues, showing that policy documents and scheme rules determine who pays what and how claims are settled.
A student could extend this by examining cyber-insurance policy wordings and insurer claim procedures to see whether defence costs are included or treated as separate reimbursable items.
Defines cyber crime categories and notes a central nodal agency for cyber reporting, demonstrating that cyber incidents can generate criminal and civil consequences including potential third‑party actions.
Given that cyber incidents can lead to third‑party lawsuits, a student might check typical cyber policy sections (e.g., third‑party liability/legal defence) in sample policies to judge whether defence costs are normally covered.
- [THE VERDICT]: **Logical Trap / Current Affairs Application**. Not found in static economy texts. Solvable purely by distinguishing 'Hardware' vs. 'Software' risks.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: **New Financial Products**. The rise of ransomware (WannaCry, Petya) created a market for individual cyber cover, moving beyond corporate liability.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: **Cyber Policy Scope**: Covers Identity Theft, Social Media Liability, Cyber Stalking (psychological counseling), Malware (data restoration), Phishing, and Legal Defence costs. **Exclusions**: Physical hardware damage, wear and tear, dishonest acts by the insured, and trading losses (crypto/stocks).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: **The Definition Test**. When a new niche insurance appears (e.g., Title Insurance, Cyber Insurance), ask: What is its *core* domain? Cyber = Digital. Therefore, physical smashing of a laptop is out of domain.
Cyber insurance is a form of non-life (general) insurance and understanding the life/non-life split clarifies which regulatory and product frameworks apply.
High-yield for UPSC because many policy questions require distinguishing insurance types; helps link regulatory scope, market players, and product examples (e.g., cyber risk sits under non-life). Useful for questions on insurance reforms, market structure, and policy design.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 7: Indian Economy after 2014 > There are two main types of insurance namely: > p. 245
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 14: Service Sector > CHAPTER SUMMARY > p. 435
Deposit insurance is a specialised insurance scheme with fixed coverage rules, illustrating that insurance in India can be specific in scope and capped — a contrast useful when evaluating whether cyber losses are typically covered.
Important for aspirants because it exemplifies how government-backed insurance schemes operate, the role of regulators, and the concept of insured limits and exclusions — skills applicable to analysing other insurance products and public policy safeguards.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > Commercial Banks > p. 67
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > Commercial Banks > p. 66
Malware and related threats are categorized under cyber crime, which establishes the underlying risk that cyber insurance seeks to address.
Valuable for UPSC essays and mains answers linking digital security, law enforcement, and economic policy. Helps frame questions on cyber security policy, the need for risk transfer mechanisms, and interactions between technology risk and financial protection.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 17: Contemporary Issues > Cyber Crime > p. 93
General (non-life) insurance covers losses other than life such as fire, motor, home and is the category under which cyber-related property losses would be classified.
High-yield because identifying the correct insurance category determines whether a loss is potentially claimable; connects to questions on insurance policy design, regulatory scope and consumer protection. Mastery enables clear comparison of policy types and formulation of policy recommendations in answers.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 7: Indian Economy after 2014 > There are two main types of insurance namely: > p. 244
Knowing categories of cybercrime and the national cybercrime reporting setup is essential to link a criminal act against a computer to legal remedies and investigative records that may support insurance claims.
Relevant for GS and optional papers on internal security and law; helps construct answers on cyber threat mitigation, legal procedures and the evidentiary basis insurers require for claims. Enables arguments about policyholder responsibilities and state mechanisms.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 17: Contemporary Issues > Cyber Crime > p. 93
A consumer's right to compensation and access to consumer commissions is central when pursuing indemnity or disputing an insurer's claim decision.
Important for questions on consumer protection, dispute resolution and regulatory reform in insurance; mastering this concept helps draft solutions on how aggrieved policyholders can seek remedies and how policy terms should be regulated.
- Understanding Economic Development. Class X . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: CONSUMER RIGHTS > 13. Say True or False. > p. 87
Understanding types of cyber crime (hacking, cyber stalking, cyber terrorism, extortion) is essential to assess what losses and response services a cyber insurance policy might need to cover.
High-yield for UPSC because it links digital security risks to public policy and law-and-order topics; helps answer questions on cyber security preparedness, legal frameworks, and the demand for specialised services. Mastery enables tackling questions that require evaluation of incident types, state responses, and insurance/mitigation needs.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 17: Contemporary Issues > Cyber Crime > p. 93
Parametric Insurance. Unlike traditional indemnity insurance (which pays for assessed actual loss), Parametric Insurance pays a pre-agreed amount instantly upon a specific trigger event (e.g., rainfall < 50mm). This is the next logical 'mechanism' question in the insurance sector.
The 'Hardware vs. Software' Razor.
Look at Statement 2: 'Cost of a new computer if some miscreant wilfully damages it'. This is **Physical Hardware Damage**.
Look at the Topic: 'Cyber Insurance'. Cyber deals with Data, Software, and Liability.
Logic: Physical damage is covered under 'Home/Electronic Equipment' insurance, not Cyber.
Eliminate Statement 2.
Options A, C, and D all contain 2.
Only Option B remains. Answer derived in 10 seconds.
GS-3 Internal Security: Cyber Insurance is the 'Market Solution' to the 'State Failure' in preventing cybercrime. It monetizes the risk discussed in the National Cyber Security Policy (2013) and links to the Data Protection Bill debates.