Question map
In case of which one of the following biogeochemical cycles, the weathering of rocks is the main source of release of nutrient to enter the cycle?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 3.
Biogeochemical cycles are categorized into gaseous and sedimentary types. The Phosphorus cycle is a prime example of a sedimentary cycle. Unlike carbon or nitrogen, phosphorus does not exist in a gaseous phase in the atmosphere. Instead, its primary reservoir is the Earth's crust, specifically in the form of phosphate rocks.
- Phosphorus Cycle: Phosphorus is released into the soil and water through the weathering of rocks (chemical and physical erosion). This is the fundamental mechanism that introduces phosphorus into the biological food chain.
- Carbon and Nitrogen Cycles: These are primarily gaseous cycles where the atmosphere or hydrosphere serves as the main reservoir.
- Sulphur Cycle: While it has a sedimentary component, it also has a significant gaseous phase (SO2, H2S), making phosphorus the most direct answer for rock weathering as the primary source.
Therefore, because phosphorus is almost exclusively mineral-based, rock weathering is the critical step for its entry into the cycle.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a textbook 'Sitter' found directly in standard sources like Shankar IAS (Chapter 2) and Majid Hussain. The core concept tested is the fundamental classification of biogeochemical cycles into 'Gaseous' (Atmosphere-based) vs. 'Sedimentary' (Lithosphere-based). If you missed this, you are skimming headings rather than understanding the basic mechanics of nutrient reservoirs.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Is weathering of rocks the main source of nutrient release into the phosphorus biogeochemical cycle?
- Statement 2: Is weathering of rocks the main source of nutrient release into the carbon biogeochemical cycle?
- Statement 3: Is weathering of rocks the main source of nutrient release into the nitrogen biogeochemical cycle?
- Statement 4: Is weathering of rocks the main source of nutrient release into the sulphur biogeochemical cycle?
- Explicitly identifies phosphorus as occurring mainly as mineral in phosphate rocks.
- States that phosphates enter the cycle from erosion, mining and by weathering into rivers and streams.
- Says depletion of the exchange pool is slowly compensated by release from phosphate rocks.
- Specifies that erosion and weathering of phosphate rocks release phosphorus into the cycle; links to fertilizer production from these rocks.
- Describes geological recycling where phosphates exposed by uplift are released by weathering from rock.
- Connects long-term geochemical phase of the cycle to weathering as the mechanism releasing phosphates back into the system.
States biogeochemical cycles (including the carbon cycle) involve phases of weathering of rocks followed by uptake/storage by organisms and return to pools.
A student could combine this rule with knowledge of major carbon flux pathways (photosynthesis/respiration vs. rock weathering) to compare whether weathering is likely a dominant nutrient source for the carbon cycle.
Explains chemical weathering (solution/carbonation) dissolves minerals such as calcium carbonate when water contains CO2, showing a concrete mechanism whereby weathering moves inorganic carbon and minerals into solution.
Use basic chemistry and maps of carbonate rock distribution to estimate where and how much inorganic carbon and associated ions may be released by weathering relative to biological carbon fluxes.
Gives an explicit example: phosphates accumulated in sediments are released from rock by weathering, illustrating weathering as a source of nutrients (here P) for ecosystems.
A student could map phosphate-bearing rock exposures and consider their weathering rates to judge the contribution of rock-derived nutrients to biological carbon cycling (e.g., supporting primary productivity).
Describes carbon moving between atmosphere and organisms as a short-term cycle but also notes some carbon is stored long-term as insoluble carbonates in bottom sediments which take long to be released.
Combine this with knowledge of weathering releasing carbonate minerals to assess how weathering controls the long-term release and sequestration of carbon in the global carbon budget.
States weathering breaks rocks into soil and helps enrichment/concentration of minerals important for ecosystems, implying weathering supplies mineral nutrients that affect biological communities.
A student could use basic facts about soil formation and vegetation dependence on soil nutrients to infer how much rock weathering might indirectly control carbon uptake via plant productivity.
- Directly states how nitrogen is introduced to the ocean (atmosphere and dissolved gases), indicating other dominant sources besides rock weathering.
- Implies atmospheric and gas-phase exchange are important delivery pathways for nitrogen, countering the idea that rock weathering is the main source.
- Highlights active biological nitrogen fixation as a major process supplying nitrogen, providing an alternative primary source to rock weathering.
- Shows that biological processes can strongly control nitrogen availability in marine systems.
- States that rocks are a reservoir for phosphorus (not nitrogen), implying rock weathering is more directly linked to phosphorus cycling than to the nitrogen cycle.
- By contrasting phosphorus (rock reservoir) with nitrogen (multiple forms including atmospheric), it weakly argues against rock weathering as the main nitrogen source.
States that elements held in geologic storage pools are released into the soil by weathering, showing weathering as a route by which geologic nutrients enter soils.
A student could compare which elements weathering supplies (from lithosphere) with which forms of nitrogen are needed in the biosphere to judge if weathering could be a primary nitrogen source.
Says biogeochemical cycles (including the nitrogen cycle) involve phases of weathering of rocks, uptake by organisms and return to soil, implying weathering participates in cycles.
One could use this pattern to ask whether the nitrogen cycle’s major inputs come from lithosphere weathering or other reservoirs (e.g., atmosphere, microbes).
Explains the nitrogen cycle is dominated by a vast atmospheric reservoir and that the key link is biological nitrogen fixation in soil by microbes.
Combine this with evidence of weathering to evaluate if atmospheric fixation plus microbial activity supplies more bioavailable nitrogen than rock weathering can.
Lists the main natural nitrogen fixation pathways: microorganisms, industrial fixation, and atmospheric phenomena, highlighting fixation rather than rock-derived nitrogen.
A student could estimate relative contributions from these pathways vs. weathering (e.g., map of soil organisms/atmospheric fixation rates) to test whether weathering is the main source.
Describes chemical weathering as decomposition of rocks by air and water, which releases constituents into soil—useful for assessing which nutrient types weathering contributes.
Use this to identify which nutrient elements (e.g., P, K, Ca) are commonly released by chemical weathering and contrast that list with nitrogen forms required by plants.
Specifies sulphur reservoirs (organic and inorganic in soil and sediments) and lists weathering of rocks, erosional runoff and decomposition as processes that release sulphur into ecosystems.
A student could combine this with external data on relative flux magnitudes (e.g., rates of rock weathering vs. atmospheric inputs) to judge whether weathering is the dominant source.
States that elements held in geologic storage pools are released into soil by weathering and that sulphur can pass from ocean to atmosphere to soil by fallout/washout (showing multiple input pathways).
One could map these pathways and compare terrestrial rock-derived inputs to oceanic-atmospheric deposition using basic world/region maps and known ocean-atmosphere exchanges.
Gives a general rule that biogeochemical cycles involve phases of weathering of rocks, uptake by organisms and return to soil/atmosphere/ocean — implying weathering is a common source step for many element cycles.
Apply this general pattern to sulphur by checking if sulphur's cycle follows the same phase structure and estimating the weathering step's typical contribution.
Emphasizes that weathering produces soils and enriches or concentrates certain elements/ores, showing that weathering can be a major process making geologic elements available to ecosystems.
Use this principle with external knowledge of sulphur-bearing minerals (e.g., pyrite distribution) to infer where and how strongly weathering might supply sulphur nutrients.
Describes chemical weathering processes (dissolution, oxidation, etc.) and notes that water, air and biological acids speed these reactions — mechanisms by which buried sulphur compounds could be mobilized.
Combine these mechanisms with climate/soil data (e.g., wet vs dry climates) to predict where weathering-driven sulphur release would be strongest relative to other sources.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. Direct hit from Shankar IAS (p. 20) or Majid Hussain (p. 27).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: The distinction between Gaseous Cycles (Perfect) and Sedimentary Cycles (Imperfect).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the Reservoir for each: Carbon (Atmosphere/Ocean), Nitrogen (Atmosphere), Sulphur (Soil/Sediment + minor gaseous H2S/SO2), Phosphorus (Rocks/Guano - NO gaseous phase). Note that Phosphorus is often the 'limiting nutrient' in aquatic ecosystems precisely because it relies on slow weathering.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When reading cycles, do not just memorize the steps (fixation, assimilation). First, ask: 'Where does the inventory sit?' If the inventory is in the air, weathering is secondary. If the inventory is in the ground, weathering is primary.
Phosphorus is stored primarily in phosphate rocks and enters ecosystems when those rocks are broken down.
High-yield for ecology and environment questions: distinguishes phosphorus from atmospheric cycles like carbon and nitrogen, explains why phosphorus availability is geologically limited, and underpins questions on nutrient limitation and eutrophication.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 2: Functions of an Ecosystem > a) Phosphorus Cycle > p. 20
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > Phosphorus Cycle > p. 26
Mechanical and chemical weathering break down rocks and liberate mineral nutrients such as phosphates into soils and waterways.
Important for linking physical geography (weathering processes, soil formation) with biogeochemical cycles; useful for questions on soil fertility, landscape evolution, and how climate influences nutrient supply.
- FUNDAMENTALS OF PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY, Geography Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Geomorphic Processes > SIGNIFICANCE OF WEATHERING > p. 41
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: Weathering, Mass Movement and Groundwater > CHEMICAL WEATHERING > p. 36
Mining phosphate rocks and producing fertilizers mobilizes rock-bound phosphorus into the exchange pool and affects its redistribution.
Crucial for questions on human impacts, agricultural sustainability and resource scarcity; explains policy-relevant issues like fertilizer loss to oceans and long-term availability of phosphate resources.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > Phosphorus Cycle > p. 27
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > Phosphorus Cycle > p. 26
Weathering of rocks participates in cycling minerals and compounds that enter soil, organisms and sediments, linking lithosphere processes to nutrient availability.
High-yield for questions on nutrient supply, soil formation and ecosystem functioning; connects physical geography (rock breakdown) with ecology (nutrient cycling) and economic geography (ore enrichment). Mastery helps answer integrated questions on soil fertility, biomes and resource genesis.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > BiogEochEmical cyclEs. > p. 18
- FUNDAMENTALS OF PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY, Geography Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Geomorphic Processes > SIGNIFICANCE OF WEATHERING > p. 41
Chemical weathering (solution, carbonation, hydrolysis, oxidation) involves water, oxygen and CO2 and alters rock minerals, releasing dissolved compounds relevant to carbon cycling.
Important for questions on carbon sequestration, weathering–climate feedbacks and geochemical fluxes; links geochemistry, climate science and geomorphology and enables reasoning about rates and mechanisms of element release.
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: Weathering, Mass Movement and Groundwater > CHEMICAL WEATHERING > p. 36
- FUNDAMENTALS OF PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY, Geography Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Geomorphic Processes > Chemical Weathering Processes > p. 40
- Physical Geography by PMF IAS, Manjunath Thamminidi, PMF IAS (1st ed.) > Chapter 6: Geomorphic Movements > Chemical Weathering > p. 90
Carbon moves rapidly through atmosphere–biosphere via photosynthesis/respiration but also enters long-term geochemical pools like carbonates and peaty deposits that are released slowly.
Crucial for framing questions on carbon sinks, anthropogenic forcing and timescales of carbon exchange; helps differentiate biological nutrient cycling from geochemical weathering impacts and supports answers on management and climate implications.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 2: Functions of an Ecosystem > L) The Carbon Cycle > p. 19
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > BiogEochEmical cyclEs. > p. 18
Nitrogen operates as a gaseous cycle with a large atmospheric reservoir, whereas many other nutrients follow sedimentary pathways tied to rocks and weathering.
High-yield for prelims and mains: distinguishes which elements are primarily atmosphere-bound (e.g., N, O, C) versus lithosphere-bound (e.g., P, certain metals). Helps answer questions about nutrient sources, reservoir sizes, and timescales of cycling; connects to soil formation, ecosystem productivity and long-term element redistribution.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > sEdimEntary cyclEs. > p. 25
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > sEdimEntary cyclEs. > p. 26
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 1: BASIC CONCEPTS OF ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY > BiogEochEmical cyclEs. > p. 18
The Sulphur Cycle is the 'Hybrid' trap. While mostly sedimentary (like Phosphorus), it *does* have a gaseous phase (H2S from swamps, SO2 from volcanoes). A future question will ask: 'Which sedimentary cycle also possesses a gaseous phase?' (Answer: Sulphur).
Apply the 'State of Matter' test. Carbon (CO2) and Nitrogen (N2) are gases in their primary entry form—eliminate A and B. Between Sulphur and Phosphorus: Sulphur smells (rotten eggs/volcanoes = gas), implying some atmospheric role. Phosphorus is used in matchsticks and rocks (solid). Therefore, P is the strictest answer for rock weathering.
Link Phosphorus to Economy & IR: India is import-dependent for Rock Phosphate (DAP fertilizers) from Morocco and Jordan. This geological constraint (weathering-limited supply) creates a National Security vulnerability in food security.