Question map
Which of the following is not a bird ?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 1: Golden Mahseer.
The Golden Mahseer (Tor putitora) is a large species of freshwater fish found in the Himalayan rivers. It is often referred to as the "Tiger of the Water" and is categorized as Endangered on the IUCN Red List. It is not a bird.
The other options are categorized as follows:
- Indian Nightjar: A nocturnal bird characterized by its cryptic plumage and distinctive calls, commonly found across the Indian subcontinent.
- Spoonbill: A genus of large, long-legged wading birds, easily identified by their unique flat, spatula-shaped bills used for filter-feeding in shallow water.
- White Ibis: A species of wading bird belonging to the Threskiornithidae family, known for its long, down-curved bill and white plumage.
Since the Golden Mahseer is an ichthyological species (fish) and the others are avian species, Option 1 is the correct choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a 'Flagship Species' test disguised as a taxonomy question. Golden Mahseer is the 'Tiger of the Water' and a conservation priority. The typo 'Mahsecr' was a minor hurdle. If you follow 'State Symbols' or 'Project Species', this was a 10-second kill.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
Shows an example of a bird name formed with 'Golden' (Eurasian Golden Oriole), indicating 'Golden + noun' is a common bird-naming pattern in these sources.
A student could check whether 'Mahsecr' appears as a noun in bird name lists or field guides (or on a world map/region lists) to see if 'Golden Mahsecr' fits the same naming pattern for a bird.
Contains lists of winter and summer birds including 'Eurasian Golden Oriole' and many compound bird names, reinforcing the pattern of descriptive compound names for bird species.
Compare 'Golden Mahsecr' against such published bird lists (migratory/resident lists) to see if it appears among named species.
Lists 'golden-eagle' among wildlife examples, giving another instance where 'golden' prefixes a well-known bird species name.
Use the repeated occurrence of 'golden-' prefixed bird names to suspect 'Golden Mahsecr' might be intended as a bird name and then search authoritative bird checklists or taxonomic databases for 'Mahsecr'.
Gives the scale of avian diversity in India (1,200 species), implying many named bird species exist and that unfamiliar names might still be valid bird taxa.
Recognize that absence from a small list doesn't disprove existence; a student should consult comprehensive species lists or regional checklists to confirm whether 'Golden Mahsecr' is listed.
- The passage is a section of the 'List of birds of India' showing 'Indian nightjar' among bird entries.
- It gives the scientific name (binomial) for Indian nightjar, indicating it is a recognized bird species (Caprimulgus asiaticus).
- This passage is the introduction to the 'List of birds of India', confirming the context that the listed names are bird species.
- Presence of Indian bird listings in this source supports that 'Indian nightjar' appears in an authoritative bird list.
This snippet gives an example of a species described explicitly as a 'nocturnal bird' (Jerdon's Courser), showing that books treat named taxa as bird species and note nocturnality as a species trait.
A student could use this pattern to check bird species lists or field guides for other named nocturnal birds (like 'Indian Nightjar') to see if they are listed similarly.
This snippet states India has about 1,200 species of birds, indicating extensive avifauna and that many named forms are catalogued as bird species.
A student could consult the referenced kinds of inventories or national bird lists (or check if 'Indian Nightjar' appears among the catalogued species) to evaluate the statement.
This snippet gives a bird count for India (~2,000 species) and examples of common named birds, showing that named vernacular forms are commonly used in Indian avifaunal records.
Using this, a student might look up national/regional checklists or bird guides (which list many named species) to see whether 'Indian Nightjar' is recorded.
This snippet lists many bird types found in India (peacocks, cranes, parakeets), illustrating that common names refer to species/groups in these texts.
A student could apply the same approachβsearching such common-name lists or local field guides for 'Indian Nightjar'βto judge if it corresponds to a recognized bird species.
This snippet shows the texts name particular bird species (peacock, sarus-crane, great Indian bustard) as entries in fauna lists, implying that similarly formed names (e.g., 'Indian Nightjar') may denote species.
A student could compare the format and usage of named birds here with the term 'Indian Nightjar' and then verify via a species checklist or field reference.
- Lists 'spoon-bill' among dominant species protected at Keoladeo (a national park and bird sanctuary), grouping it with other bird species.
- Placement in a bird sanctuary's species list implies spoon-bill is a bird species found in protected wetland habitats.
- Describes Pulicat Lake as habitat for numerous local and migratory birds and explicitly names 'spoonbills' alongside flamingos, pelicans, herons and ducks.
- Inclusion in a list of birds at a major lake confirms spoonbills are part of avian assemblages in wetlands.
- Defines Threskiornithidae as a family of terrestrial and wading birds.
- Explicitly states that this family "includes the ibises", linking ibises to birds.
- Refers to the sanctuary's avian population and lists the White ibis among them.
- Directly treats White ibis as part of the site's bird fauna (avian population).
- Lists 'White Ibis' together with known bird species such as egrets and terns.
- Positions White Ibis as one of the birds observed in the sanctuary.
Lists of migratory birds include species with common names using a colour + bird-type pattern (e.g., 'White Wagtail'), showing that 'White X' is a standard naming pattern for birds.
A student could use this naming pattern plus a bird field guide or checklist to look for 'White Ibis' as a similarly formed common name.
Mention of 'White-rumped vulture' and other 'white'-prefixed bird names demonstrates that 'White-' is commonly used in English bird common names.
Extend the pattern: if 'White' commonly prefixes bird names, search regional or global bird lists for 'White Ibis' as a plausible common name for a species.
A published inventory of Indian vultures shows detailed species-level common names are used in these references, implying similar treatment for other bird groups (e.g., ibises) in such lists.
Use similar species lists or national bird checklists (which these books compile) to check whether an entry named 'White Ibis' appears.
Keoladeo-Ghana bird sanctuary dominant species include wetland waders such as 'spoon-bill' and 'heron', which are the same ecological group as ibises (wading water birds).
Knowing ibises are wading water birds, a student could check wetland bird lists and sanctuaries (like Keoladeo) for presence of any 'Ibis' species, including one called 'White Ibis'.
The text describes major flyways covering migratory water bird species, indicating that many named water-bird species occur across regions and are catalogued by such conventions.
A student could consult migratory water-bird lists associated with flyways to see if 'White Ibis' appears among named migratory water birds.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter (despite the typo 'Mahsecr'). Golden Mahseer is a celebrity species in Indian conservation news.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Biodiversity > Fauna Classification > Famous Indicator Species (Fish vs Bird).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize these 'Deceptive' or 'Flagship' taxa: 1. Golden Mahseer (Fish - Tor putitora), 2. Ganges River Dolphin (Mammal), 3. Dugong (Mammal - Sea Cow), 4. Gharial (Reptile), 5. Red Panda (Mammal), 6. Indian Nightjar (Bird - Nocturnal).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When reading about National Parks (e.g., Jim Corbett/Ramganga), note the famous river fauna (Mahseer) alongside the terrestrial ones. Do not ignore 'State Fish' lists.
Many Indian bird names use descriptive prefixes such as 'Golden' which can make unfamiliar names look like bird species.
High-yield: recognising naming patterns helps quickly classify or eliminate unfamiliar taxa in prelim and mains questions. Connects to taxonomy, species identification, and matching-type questions where common-name cues matter.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 12: Animal Diversity of India > tz.6.z, Migratory birds of India > p. 193
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 2: PLANT AND ANIMAL KINGDOMS > Table 2.1 (Contd.) > p. 14
Indian birds are frequently categorised as winter or summer visitors, which is how many species are presented in reference lists.
Important for UPSC: questions often test knowledge of migratory species, flyways and seasonal occurrence; this links directly to conservation topics and protected-area timing.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 12: Animal Diversity of India > tz.6.z, Migratory birds of India > p. 193
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 28: International Organisation and Conventions > India signs Raptor MOU > p. 400
Descriptions like 'endemic', 'flagship species', and listing as national symbols are primary markers used to recognise and prioritise bird species.
High-yield: mastering these indicators aids answers on biodiversity, species protection priorities, and sanctuary management; it connects to questions on endemism, protected areas, and species lists.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 12: Animal Diversity of India > t2.4.r. The Jerdon's Courser > p. 191
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: BIODIVERSITY > IndIA β A MegA-BIodIversIty nAtIon. > p. 22
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 5: Natural Vegetation and National Parks > WILDLIFE > p. 41
India hosts a large and varied avifauna, so identifying whether a named organism is a bird requires familiarity with national bird diversity and species counts.
High-yield for UPSC because questions often ask about biodiversity, species richness rankings and representative taxa. Mastery links to ecology, conservation and biogeography topics and helps eliminate implausible taxonomic assignments in MCQs and prelim/general studies questions.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 5: Natural Vegetation and National Parks > WILDLIFE > p. 41
- CONTEMPORARY INDIA-I ,Geography, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Natural Vegetation and Wildlife > WILDLIFE > p. 43
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 9: Indian Biodiversity Diverse Landscape > INI}IAN BIODIVERSITY T}IVERSE LANDSCAPE > p. 151
Some Indian bird species are nocturnal and regionally endemic, so classification often depends on learning life-history traits like nocturnality and distribution.
Important for answering questions on species ecology, habitat specificity and conservation priorities; connects to protected area management and species-level conservation examples in mains and prelims. Recognising traits (nocturnal vs diurnal, endemic vs widespread) is a common question pattern.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 12: Animal Diversity of India > t2.4.r. The Jerdon's Courser > p. 191
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 9: Indian Biodiversity Diverse Landscape > INI}IAN BIODIVERSITY T}IVERSE LANDSCAPE > p. 151
National parks and bird sanctuaries catalogue and protect characteristic bird species, providing practical lists to verify whether a species is part of Indian avifauna.
Useful for prelims and mains when questions ask for flagship species, sanctuary-specific species or habitat-based conservation measures. Learning sanctuary-species associations helps answer location-species matching and conservation policy questions.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: BIODIVERSITY > Table 4.10 (Contd.) > p. 39
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: BIODIVERSITY > Table 4.10 (Contd.) > p. 41
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: BIODIVERSITY > IndIA β A MegA-BIodIversIty nAtIon. > p. 22
Spoonbills are explicitly listed among bird species at major Indian wetlands, indicating they are wetland-associated birds.
High-yield for questions on species composition of Indian wetlands and bird ecology; connects to conservation topics and migratory bird studies. Helps answer questions that ask which species are characteristic of specific wetland habitats.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: BIODIVERSITY > Table 4.10 (Contd.) > p. 39
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Pulicat Lake > p. 30
The Hump-backed Mahseer (found in Kaveri basin) is Critically Endangered and distinct from the Golden Mahseer (Himalayan). It is known as the 'Tiger of the Kaveri'.
The 'Beak & Wing' Test: Even if you haven't heard of Mahseer, look at the others. 'Spoonbill' (Bill = Beak), 'Ibis' (famous Egyptian bird), 'Nightjar' (sounds like a bird call/behavior). Mahseer doesn't fit the avian naming convention. Also, 'Mahseer' is phonetically close to 'Matsya' (Sanskrit for Fish).
Environment & Economy: Mahseer angling is a huge eco-tourism revenue source for states like Arunachal and Uttarakhand. Its conservation is directly linked to River Interlinking Projects and Hydropower dams which block migration routes (Mains GS3).