Question map
With reference to radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs), consider the following statements : 1. RTGs are miniature fission reactors. 2. RTGs are used for powering the onboard systems of spacecrafts. 3. RTGs can use Plutonium-238, which is a by-product of weapons development. Which of the statements given above are correct ?
Explanation
The correct answer is option B (statements 2 and 3 only).
**Statement 1 is incorrect**: RTGs are not fission reactors, nor is the plutonium the type that is used for nuclear weapons.[1] Instead, RTGs harness the heat produced by radioactive decay rather than a nuclear chain reaction.[2]
**Statement 2 is correct**: Radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs) have been the main power source for US space work since 1961.[3] For example, Cassini's science instruments and onboard systems was generated by three RTGs, known as [General Purpose Heat Source (GPHS) RTGs].[4]
**Statement 3 is correct**: Most RTGs use plutonium-238.[5] The high decay heat of plutonium-238 (0.56 W/g) enables its use as an electricity source in the RTGs of spacecraft, satellites, navigation beacons and so on.[6] Additionally, the documents indicate that it may be available within Europe as an unwanted by-product of the legacy nuclear fuel reprocessing cycle[7], which is associated with weapons-related nuclear programs.
Therefore, only statements 2 and 3 are correct.
Sources- [1] https://science.nasa.gov/mission/cassini/radioisotope-thermoelectric-generator/
- [2] https://marspedia.org/Radioisotope_Thermoelectric_Generators:_Advantages_and_Disadvantages
- [3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/plutonium-238
- [4] https://science.nasa.gov/mission/cassini/radioisotope-thermoelectric-generator/
- [5] https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/non-power-nuclear-applications/transport/nuclear-reactors-for-space
- [6] https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/plutonium-238
- [7] https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/plutonium-238
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewA classic 'Definition + Application' S&T question. It punishes the lazy heuristic that 'Nuclear = Fission'. While standard books miss the specific RTG definition, the answer relies entirely on distinguishing passive radioactive decay (batteries) from active chain reactions (reactors). If you catch the error in Statement 1, the question solves itself.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Are radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs) miniature fission reactors?
- Statement 2: Are radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs) used to power onboard systems of spacecraft?
- Statement 3: Do radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs) use plutonium-238 as their heat source?
- Statement 4: Is plutonium-238 (the isotope used in radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs)) a by-product of weapons development?
- Explicitly states RTGs are not fission reactors.
- Describes RTGs as 'nuclear batteries' but distinguishes them from reactors and weapon-grade plutonium.
- Contrasts RTGs with reactors by saying they harness heat from radioactive decay rather than a nuclear chain reaction.
- Makes clear RTGs do not operate via fission chain reactions like reactors do.
- Explains that Pu-238 produces heat through radioactive decay (Ξ±-particle emission), which is the basis for RTGs.
- Supports that RTG heat source is decay heat, not an ongoing fission chain reaction.
States that radioactive decay produces high temperatures in Earth's interior and contrasts that scientists consider the possibility of self-sustained nuclear fission 'as in a human-made reactor'.
A student could use this to distinguish heat from natural radioactive decay versus heat from a self-sustained fission chain reaction (the latter being what a reactor does) and ask which process RTGs rely on.
Identifies uranium-235 and plutonium-239 as materials used for fission in nuclear arms, implying that fission requires specific fissile isotopes and chain reactions.
A student can check whether RTGs use those fissile isotopes and whether RTGs operate via chain reactions or simple radioactive decay.
Describes thorium and uranium as nuclear fuels and mentions use in reactors/engines, illustrating that 'nuclear fuel' usually refers to materials used in reactors (breeding, sustained reactions).
Use this pattern to compare the isotopic fuel in reactors versus the isotope used in RTGs (if known) to see if RTGs use reactor-style fuel.
Defines nuclear energy as using nuclear reactions to produce steam that drives generators β describing the typical reactor-scale energy-conversion chain driven by controlled reactions.
A student could contrast this reactor model (reactionβsteamβturbine) with the RTG model (decay heatβthermoelectric devices) to test if RTGs match the reactor pattern.
Explains that altering atomic structure releases energy used to generate electric power and names uranium/thorium as materials used for atomic power, reinforcing that 'atomic power' usually involves deliberate nuclear processes with specific fuels.
A student might ask whether RTGs perform the same type of atomic alteration (sustained fission) as large power stations or rely on spontaneous decay of radioisotopes.
- Direct example of an operational spacecraft (Cassini) whose science instruments and onboard systems were powered by RTGs.
- Shows RTGs provide the electrical power required for onboard systems.
- Authoritative NASA statement that RTGs are used to provide electrical power for spacecraft.
- Explains the general role of RTGs in converting heat to electrical power for missions where other options are impractical.
- Summarizes historical use, stating RTGs have been the main power source for U.S. space work since 1961.
- Explicitly links RTGs' heat output (from Pu-238) to their use as an electricity source in spacecraft and satellites.
States that altering atomic structure releases heat which is then used to generate electric power β establishes a general rule: nuclear processes produce heat that can be converted to electricity.
A student could extend this by asking whether a compact device that uses heat from radioactive decay to generate electricity (an RTG) is practical for powering systems where other power sources are limited.
Explains that geothermal (ground) heat is captured and used to drive turbines and generate electricity β demonstrates the general principle of converting local heat sources into electrical power.
One could analogously consider whether heat from radioactive decay (another local heat source) could be used similarly in environments where conventional generation is unavailable.
Mentions the existence of radio-nuclides such as uranium and thorium that produce terrestrial radiation β shows the availability of radioactive materials that can be sources of heat/radiation.
A student could combine this with the rule that nuclear materials release heat to infer that radioisotopes might serve as compact heat sources for remote power needs.
Describes fuel cells as modular power systems suitable for small-scale decentralized and remote locations β provides an example of specialized power systems used where grid power is unavailable.
Using this pattern, a student could consider RTGs as another class of specialized power supply designed for remote/isolated applications like spacecraft.
Refers to the MESSENGER spacecraft obtaining images and conducting observations β indicates spacecraft operate in environments where onboard power sources must support instruments.
A student could combine knowledge that spacecraft need dependable onboard power with the earlier clues about nuclear heat β electricity to evaluate whether RTGs are a plausible option for such missions.
- Direct statement that most RTGs use plutonium-238.
- Explains RTGs convert heat from radioactive decay into electricity, linking the isotope to the heat source.
- States the high decay heat of plutonium-238 enables its use as an electricity source in RTGs.
- Provides the decay-heat value (0.56 W/g), explaining suitability as a heat source.
- Explains that plutonium-238's high heat output (glows red hot) is the basis for its use in RTGs.
- Directly ties 238Pu's decay-heat characteristic to RTG application.
States that radioactive decay is a source of heat (general rule: decay produces heat energy).
A student could combine this with the fact RTGs convert decay heat to electricity to infer RTGs plausibly use a radioactive isotope as their heat source.
Mentions plutonium (here Pu-239) as a nuclear material, illustrating that multiple plutonium isotopes exist and are used for specific nuclear applications.
A student could use this to reason that a different plutonium isotope (e.g., one chosen for heat-producing decay rather than fission) might be chosen for RTGs.
Notes plutonium as an element heavier than uranium and discusses uranium/plutonium in the context of nuclear energy materials.
A student could infer that plutonium isotopes are relevant nuclear materials and consider that some isotopes could be used as heat sources in devices that harness nuclear energy.
Explains that altering atomic structure (nuclear processes) releases heat used to generate power and lists uranium/thorium as nuclear fuel examples.
A student could generalize that nuclear decay/transformations provide heat for power devices and therefore seek which specific isotopes (like Pu-238) are suitable for small heat sources such as RTGs.
Identifies plutonium (specifically Pu-239) as a material used in nuclear weapons, showing plutonium isotopes are produced/handled in weapons-related programmes.
A student could use this to ask whether other plutonium isotopes (like Pu-238) are produced in the same fuel/production chains used for weapons material.
States that plutonium is among radioactive substances whose environmental presence increased after the advent of nuclear weapons, implying weapons activity affects plutonium production/distribution.
One could check historical production routes (weapons labs vs civilian reactors) to see which processes increase Pu-238 versus other plutonium isotopes.
Explains that nuclear energy generation creates numerous radioactive isotopes, indicating civilian reactors are a source of various plutonium isotopes as by-products.
A student could compare reactor neutron-irradiation pathways (reactor by-products) with weapons-production pathways to judge whether Pu-238 is typically produced as a reactor by-product rather than intentionally in weapons programs.
Notes a close linkage between nuclear power plants and the development of nuclear weapons, suggesting overlap between civilian and military isotopic production capability.
Use this to investigate whether facilities involved in weapons development also operate reactors or reprocessing plants that could yield Pu-238 as a by-product.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter (if you know the definition) / Conceptual Trap (if you equate Nuclear with Fission). Solvable via Statement 1 elimination.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Space Technology > Power Systems. Triggered by deep-space missions (Voyager, Cassini, Curiosity) where solar power is too weak.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the 'Space Power Trinity': 1) Solar (Inner planets), 2) Fuel Cells (Manned missions, produces water), 3) RTGs (Outer planets, uses Seebeck effect). Know the Isotope Swap: Pu-238 (Heat/RTG) vs Pu-239 (Fission/Bomb).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When studying Nuclear Tech, categorize devices by mechanism: Fission (Reactors/Bombs), Fusion (Stars), and Decay (RTGs/Medical). UPSC loves swapping 'Chain Reaction' with 'Spontaneous Decay'.
Differentiates spontaneous radioactive decay (continuous heat release) from chain-reactive nuclear fission, which determines whether a device is a reactor.
High-yield: many questions test the difference between passive decay heat sources and active fission reactors; links to geology (internal heat), reactor safety, and energy technology. Mastering this helps distinguish RTGs from reactor-based power systems in policy and technical questions.
- Physical Geography by PMF IAS, Manjunath Thamminidi, PMF IAS (1st ed.) > Chapter 4: Earths Interior > Radioactive Decay > p. 58
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > Atomic explosion (Nuclear fatlout): > p. 83
Identifies which isotopes undergo controlled fission and which materials are used or bred as reactor fuel, a key factor in defining a fission reactor.
High-yield: relevant to questions on nuclear fuel cycles, resource geography (uranium/thorium deposits), and energy policy; knowing fuel types enables classification of technologies (reactor vs non-reactor) and discussions of proliferation and indigenous programs.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > Atomic explosion (Nuclear fatlout): > p. 83
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 9: Distribution of World Natural Resources > thorium > p. 40
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 5: Print Culture and the Modern World > Nuclear or Atomic Energy > p. 117
Highlights that conventional reactors use nuclear heat to produce steam to drive turbines, which contrasts with other heat-to-electricity methods and is essential for judging whether a device is a reactor.
High-yield: connects nuclear engineering fundamentals to energy infrastructure and environmental impacts; useful for comparing power-generation technologies and answering questions about plant design and operational differences.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 9: Distribution of World Natural Resources > nucleaR eneRgy. > p. 23
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 5: Print Culture and the Modern World > Nuclear or Atomic Energy > p. 117
Atomic energy releases heat from altering atomic structure, which can be converted to electricity for remote or continuous-power needs.
High-yield for UPSC because it connects civilian nuclear power, resource geography (uranium/thorium distribution), and technological uses of nuclear heat. Mastering this helps answer questions on energy mix, strategic resources, and nuclear technology applications.
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 5: Print Culture and the Modern World > Nuclear or Atomic Energy > p. 117
Fuel cell systems provide modular, small-scale power solutions suited to remote or isolated installations where grid power is unavailable.
Useful for questions on alternative energy technologies, off-grid power solutions, and energy policy. Understanding fuel cells aids comparisons between decentralized power options and their environmental/social trade-offs.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 22: Renewable Energy > Fuel cells for power generation > p. 296
Geomagnetic storms and ionospheric/space radiation affect satellite operations, communications, orbital control and crew/radiation exposure.
Important for UPSC topics linking space technology, disaster effects on infrastructure, and strategic resilience. Knowing these impacts helps answer questions on satellite vulnerability, space weather policy, and satellite-based services.
- Physical Geography by PMF IAS, Manjunath Thamminidi, PMF IAS (1st ed.) > Chapter 5: Earths Magnetic Field (Geomagnetic Field) > Effects of Geomagnetic Storms > p. 68
Radioactive decay produces heat that can be harnessed for power or to contribute to Earth's internal heat.
High-yield for questions on energy sources and geophysics: explains a fundamental mechanism behind geothermal heat and some nuclear-based power devices. Connects energy geography, internal Earth heat budget, and technology discussions about alternative power supplies.
- FUNDAMENTALS OF PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY, Geography Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Distribution of Oceans and Continents > Force for the Plate Movement > p. 33
Radioisotope Heater Units (RHUs). Unlike RTGs which generate electricity, RHUs only generate heat to keep instruments warm. India used an RHU in the Chandrayaan-3 propulsion module. Expect a comparison question next.
The 'Critical Mass' Logic. A 'Fission Reactor' requires critical mass and heavy shielding (neutrons). It is engineeringly improbable to put a heavy 'reactor' on a small rover like Curiosity. 'Generator' implies passive conversion (like a battery). If Statement 1 is False, Options A, C, and D are eliminated instantly.
Geopolitics of Strategic Materials. The production of Pu-238 ceased after the Cold War, forcing NASA to buy it from Russia. The US recently restarted domestic production (Project Plutonium-238) to maintain deep-space capabilities, linking Science to National Security.