Question map
Consider the following pairs : I. Mallorca : Italy II. Normandy : Spain III. Sardinia : France In how many of the above rows is the given information correctly matched?
Explanation
None of the three pairs are correctly matched.
**Pair I (Mallorca : Italy) - INCORRECT**
Mallorca is the largest island of the Balearic Islands (part[1] of Spain), situated east of the Iberian[2] Peninsula in the Mediterranean Sea. Therefore, Mallorca belongs to Spain, not Italy.
**Pair II (Normandy : Spain) - INCORRECT**
Le Havre, France is located in the Upper Normandy region along the northern coastline of the country.[3] This confirms that Normandy is a region of France, not Spain.
**Pair III (Sardinia : France) - INCORRECT**
Sardinia is actually an autonomous region and island of Italy, located in the Mediterranean Sea. It is not part of France.
Since none of the three pairs show correct country associations, the answer is **Option D: None**.
Sources- [1] https://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/webapps/planet-pen/Images/EO/eo_image_list.txt
- [2] https://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/webapps/planet-pen/Images/EO/eo_image_list.txt
- [3] https://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/webapps/planet-pen/Images/EO/eo_image_list.txt
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Atlas meets History' question. While it looks like a location query, the answers lie in standard World History NCERTs (Italian Unification, Norman Conquest). It rewards the habit of opening an Atlas whenever a historical region is mentioned in static texts.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Explicitly identifies the Balearic Islands as part of Spain.
- Mentions Palma (on Mallorca) in context of the Balearic Islands being Spanish.
- States Palma is situated on the largest island of Mallorca and places it geographically east of the Iberian Peninsula.
- Notes historical context 'before becoming a province of Spain,' tying Mallorca to Spain.
- Labels Ibiza explicitly as 'Island of Ibiza, Spain' and says it is part of the Balearic archipelago.
- Reinforces that islands of the Balearic archipelago (which includes Mallorca) are Spanish, not Italian.
Lists the Balearic Islands as an example of an archipelago of the Mediterranean, implying Mallorca (a Balearic island) is in the Mediterranean Sea rather than in the Atlantic or other oceans.
A student could use a Mediterranean map to locate the Balearic Islands and then compare political borders to see which country administers them.
Classifies islands by ocean/region (Atlantic, Indian, Antarctic), indicating that knowing an island's sea/region is a key step to identifying its national affiliation.
Locate Mallorca in the Mediterranean region (per [1]) and then check which Mediterranean coastal state administers nearby islands.
Provides examples/exercises about locating specific islands (e.g., Crete) on a world map and classifying island groups, showing that map-location exercises help determine political belonging.
Apply the same map-locating exercise to Mallorca to see its proximity to particular countries.
Mentions the Lipari Islands as an example of Italian islands in the Mediterranean, illustrating that multiple Mediterranean island groups belong to different countries (some to Italy).
Compare the location of Lipari (an Italian island group) with the Balearic group to note they are distinct and may belong to different states.
- Explicitly labels the place as 'FRANCE' and names Le Havre as located in the 'Upper Normandy region'.
- Shows Normandy as a region of France, not Spain, directly contradicting the claim that Normandy is part of Spain.
Identifies Normandy as a French province (a duke from the French province of Normandy is named), implying Normandy is linked to France.
A student could check a political map of Europe to see Normandy's location within France rather than within Spain.
States William was the Duke of Normandy and crossed the English Channel to England, indicating Normandy lies on France's side of the Channel (northern France).
Combine this with a basic map to place Normandy in northern France, far from Spain's territory in southwestern Europe.
Discusses territories in western France and conflicts between England and France, reinforcing that Normandy is part of the historical/french territorial sphere, not Spanish.
Use the historical pattern of French–English disputes over French regions to infer Normandy is a French region to be located on a map relative to Spain.
Describes Spain's internal historical kingdoms (Aragon, Castile) showing Spain has its own distinct territorial identity separate from France.
A student can use this to reason that Normandy (tied to France in other snippets) is unlikely to be part of Spain's historical kingdoms.
Lists United Kingdom, France, Spain as separate countries, which implies France and Spain are distinct sovereign entities.
Using that distinction plus the snippets linking Normandy to France, a student can conclude Normandy is not within Spain's national borders when checking a map.
Mentions 'Sardinia-Piedmont' as a political entity allied with France in 1859 and later leading Italian unification, indicating Sardinia was treated as a distinct (Italian) polity rather than part of France.
A student could combine this with a basic map or timeline of Italian unification to check whether Sardinia/Piedmont belonged to Italy rather than France in modern national boundaries.
States Count Cavour rose to be Prime Minister of Sardinia and led unification under the leadership of Sardinia, implying Sardinia functioned as the core of an Italian state.
Use a map showing the Kingdom of Sardinia's location relative to France and modern Italy to infer whether Sardinia is part of France today.
Gives a general definition of 'continental islands' — islands formerly part of the mainland and now detached — supplying a geographic category useful when classifying Mediterranean islands like Sardinia.
Combine this definition with basic geographic knowledge (Mediterranean location of Sardinia and proximity to Italy/France) to reason about which mainland country an island is most closely connected to.
Describes historical territorial ties and how regions (like provinces) gave rise to modern nation-states (example: Gaul → France), illustrating that historical rule affects modern national boundaries.
A student could apply the same logic to investigate Sardinia's historical rulers and see whether its modern affiliation aligns with France or Italy.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. This is basic European geography accessible via Class X/XI History NCERTs or any standard Oxford Student Atlas.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Mediterranean Islands and Historical Provinces of Europe (World History-Geography overlap).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize these pairs: Corsica (France), Sicily (Italy), Crete (Greece), Cyprus (Country), Azores & Madeira (Portugal), Canary Islands (Spain), Catalonia (Spain), Brittany (France).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Do not treat History and Geography as silos. When reading about 'Cavour and Sardinia' (Italian Unification) or 'D-Day in Normandy' (WWII), immediately locate these regions on a map. Visual memory beats rote memorization.
Identifying an island's archipelago (e.g., Balearic Islands in the Mediterranean) is the first step in locating its political and geographic affiliation.
High-yield for map-based and polity questions: knowing major archipelagos helps quickly narrow national jurisdictions and sea-region contexts (Mediterranean, Atlantic, Indian Ocean). It links physical geography (grouping of islands) with political geography (sovereignty, administrative units) and is frequently used in UPSC map and prelims-main linkage questions.
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 11: Islands and Coral Reefs > Gontinental islands > p. 97
Knowing whether an island group is continental or oceanic helps infer proximity, geological origin, and biological links to nearby mainland, which often correlate with administrative ties.
Important for physical geography and biogeography questions: this concept explains why some islands share flora/fauna with adjacent continents and can guide answers about likely political connections or historical colonisation patterns. It connects to tectonics, island formation, and region-specific case studies in mains answers.
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 11: Islands and Coral Reefs > Gontinental islands > p. 97
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 11: Islands and Coral Reefs > Ouestions and Exercises > p. 102
Mediterranean archipelagos belong to different Mediterranean states (e.g., Balearic Islands in the Mediterranean; Italy has island groups like Lipari/Stromboli).
Useful for distinguishing sovereignty across the same sea basin: questions often ask which country administers a named island or archipelago. Mastery prevents conflating island groups across neighbouring states and aids in answering polity, history, and geopolitics questions involving the Mediterranean region.
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 11: Islands and Coral Reefs > Gontinental islands > p. 97
- Physical Geography by PMF IAS, Manjunath Thamminidi, PMF IAS (1st ed.) > Chapter 11: Volcanism > 3) Strombolian Eruption > p. 145
Normandy is a province of France and its dukes (notably William of Normandy) led the 11th-century conquest of England.
High-yield for medieval European history and Anglo‑French relations; explains origins of the English monarchy, feudal ties across the Channel, and grounds many later territorial disputes. Useful for questions on state formation, feudalism, and cross‑border dynastic claims.
- Themes in world history, History Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: The Three Orders > France and England > p. 88
- Themes in world history, History Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: The Three Orders > England > p. 95
The Basque region is an autonomous region within Spain with active nationalist demands for greater self-determination.
Essential for modern nation-state and political integration topics; connects to federalism, minority rights, internal security, and contemporary secessionist movements—frequently examined in polity and modern history questions.
- Political Theory, Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: Nationalism > DEMAND FOR NATIONAL SELF-DETERMINATION IN BASQUE > p. 105
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: Regional Aspirations > Accommodation and National Integration > p. 131
England and France contended over territories, with English possession of parts of western France and prolonged conflict culminating in the Hundred Years' War.
Crucial for understanding medieval diplomacy, dynastic wars, and the evolution of European states; links to military history (e.g., Joan of Arc) and the political consequences of cross‑Channel claims.
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 10: Modern World: The Age of Reason > France as Nation-State > p. 145
- Themes in world history, History Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: The Three Orders > England > p. 95
Sardinia‑Piedmont was a distinct polity whose leadership (Cavour) drove the unification of Italy.
High‑yield for modern Indian and world history questions on 19th‑century nationalism; links political geography with unification movements and helps answer questions about which states led nation‑building. Mastering this enables candidates to place events (wars, diplomacy, leaders) in the correct state context.
- India and the Contemporary World – II. History-Class X . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 1: The Rise of Nationalism in Europe > Activity > p. 21
- History , class XII (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 12: Europe in Turmoil > Count Cavour (1810–1861) > p. 185
Corsica (France). It lies immediately north of Sardinia (Italy) and is Napoleon's birthplace. UPSC will likely swap these two in a future 'Match the Following' to confuse you.
Use 'Historical Association' logic.
1. Normandy: Think 'Norman Conquest' of England (1066) -> originated from France. Not Spain.
2. Sardinia: Think 'Kingdom of Sardinia' which led the Unification of Italy (Class 10 NCERT). If it unified Italy, it must be Italian.
Result: Pairs II and III are definitely wrong.
Link this to GS-1 (World History) and GS-2 (International Relations/Separatism). Regions like Catalonia (Spain), Scotland (UK), and Kurdistan (Middle East) are hotspots for self-determination movements. Knowing the parent country is the first step to understanding the conflict.