UPSC Mains 2021 GS2 Q3 — Fiscal Federalism
How have the recommendations of the 14th Finance Commission of India enabled the States to improve their fiscal position? (Answer in 150 words)
Similar Previous Year Questions
Related Prelims MCQs
Build factual foundation — these MCQs cover facts/concepts you'll need for this Mains question.
-
IAS 2015 Finance Commission transfers
With reference to the Fourteenth Finance Commission, which of the following statements is/are correct? 1. It has increased the share of States in the central divisible pool from 32 percent to 42 percent. 2. It has made recommendations concerning sector-specific grants. Select the correct answer using the code given below.
-
CDS-II 2015 Government Finance & Budget
Which one of the following is not a recommendation of the Fourteenth Finance Commission?
-
UPPCS 2021 Constitutional & Statutory Bodies
The primary duty of the Finance Commission of India is
-
NDA-I 2009 Finance Commission of India
Which of the foil!owing is/are the function/ functions of the Finance Commission of India? 1. Making recommendations as to the principles governing grant-in-aid of the revenues of the States. 2. To suggest measures to augment Consolidated Fund of India. Select the correct answer using the code given below :
-
CAPF 2024 Finance Commission transfers
Consider the following statements: 1. The 15th Finance Commission used fiscal effort as a criterion for horizontal devolution unlike the 14th Finance Commission 2. Both the 14th and the 15th Finance Commission used pre-2011 demographic variables as a criteria for horizontal devolution Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Source Map — where to read
"The 14th Finance Commission has submitted its recommendations for the period 2015-16 to 2020-21. They are likely to have major implications for the Center-State relations. The 15th Finance Commission was constituted in November 2017 to give recommendations on the transfer of resources from the Centre to States for the five-year period from 2020 to 2025. The 15th Finance Commission has been constituted with the objective of strengthening co-operative federalism and improving the quality of public spending, and helping protect fiscal stability. Safeguarding the interests of the States in the sha…"
"33 1. As rightly observed by 1) P. V. Rajwani, the Chairman of the Fourth Finance Commission, 'Since the Finance Commission is a constitutional body expected to be quasi-judicial, its recommendations should not be turned down by the Government of India unless there are very compelling reasons. The Constitution of India envisages the Finance Commission as the balancing wheel of fiscal federalism in India. However, till 2014, its role in the Centre-state fiscal relations was under determined by the erstwhile Planning Commission, a non-constitutional and a non-statutory body. The Dr. P. V. Report…"
"2. The measures needed to improve the financial position of the panchayats. 3. Any other matter referred to it by the governor in the interests of sound finance of the panchayats. The legislature may provide for the composition of the commission, the required qualifications of its members and the manner of their selection. The governor shall place the recommendations of the commission along with the action taken report before the state legislature. The Central Finance Commission shall also suggest the measures needed to augment the consolidated fund of a state to supplement the resources of th…"
"The measures needed to improve the financial position of the panchayats. • 3 . Any other matter referred to it by the governor in the interests of sound finance of the panchayats. The state legislature may provide for the composition of the commission, the required qualifications of its members and the manner of their selection. The governor shall place the recommendations of the comm ission along with the action taken report before the state legislature. The Central Finance Commission shall also suggest the measures needed to augment the consolidated fund of a state to supplement the resource…"
"t ADVISORY ROLE It must be clarified here that the recommendations made by the Finance Commission are only of advisory nature and hence, not binding on the government. It is up to the Union government to implement its recommendations on granting money to the states. 1b put it in other words, 'It is nowhere laid down in the Constitution that the recommendations of the comm ission shall be binding upon the Government of India or that it would give rise to a lega l right in favour of the benefic iary states to receive the money recom me nded to be offered to them by the Comm ission,J.…"
How this topic is evolving
No related current-affairs trend found for this question yet.
Question Decoded — examiner's intent
- Directive verbs
- How
- Scope keywords
- recommendations of the 14th Finance Commissionenabled the Statesimprove their fiscal position
- Implicit sub-parts
- What were the specific structural shifts in the 14th FC recommendations compared to previous commissions?
- How did increased vertical devolution (32% to 42%) translate into fiscal autonomy and space?
- What was the impact of replacing tied grants with untied funds on state-specific development spending?
- Did the commission provide a safety net through revenue deficit grants to vulnerable states?
- Common pitfalls
- Focusing too much on the 15th Finance Commission because it is more recent, ignoring the 14th's specific legacy.
- Listing all recommendations without linking them specifically to 'fiscal position' (e.g., mention of forestry or population weight without explaining the financial outcome).
- Failing to mention the corresponding reduction in 'Centrally Sponsored Schemes' (CSS) which was the trade-off for higher devolution.
- Ignoring the shift from 'Grants-in-aid' to 'Tax Devolution' as a move toward constitutional entitlement over discretionary transfers.
- Dimensions required
- Fiscal FederalismEconomic/Budgetary AutonomyConstitutional Provisions (Article 280)Governance and Decentralization
- Marks allocation hint
Dedicate 30 words to the 42% devolution shift as the centerpiece. Allocate 80 words to the qualitative impact of 'untied funds' and fiscal autonomy. Use the final 40 words to address the performance-based incentives and revenue deficit grants that stabilized state balances.
How examiners have framed this topic over the years
Evolved from testing structural mandates to evaluating revenue impact, local-level devolution, and sophisticated quantitative metrics for state fiscal performance.
Before 2021, examiners focused on the procedural mechanics and administrative mandates of the Finance Commission, such as its constitution and Terms of Reference in 2018. The 2021 question transitioned toward assessing the substantive impact of specific commission recommendations on state fiscal autonomy. Subsequently, the framing expanded to critique the downward devolution to local bodies in 2023 and introduced sophisticated performance tools like the Fiscal Health Index (FHI) in 2025, alongside a macro-analysis of how fiscal federalism evolved from the era of planned development to recent reforms.
PYQs this pattern was synthesized from
Answer Skeleton — fill this in
Introduction
The 14th Finance Commission (FFC), chaired by Y.V. Reddy, marked a paradigm shift in Indian fiscal federalism by enhancing the vertical tax devolution and promoting the autonomy of States [Laxmikanth, Ch. 45].
Body
Significant Increase in Vertical Devolution
- Quantum Jump: Increased the States' share in the divisible pool of central taxes from 32% to 42% [Economic Survey 2015-16].
- Fiscal Space: Provided States with greater "untied" resources, allowing for expenditure based on regional priorities rather than "one-size-fits-all" central schemes.
Shift Towards Fiscal Autonomy
- Reduction in Specific-Purpose Grants: Balanced the tax hike by reducing grants-in-aid under Central Sector Schemes, encouraging State-led development models [Yojana, Fiscal Federalism].
- Predictability: Created a stable financial environment for States to plan long-term capital investments.
Strengthening Local Self-Government
- Direct Transfers: Recommended fixed-sum grants to Rural and Urban Local Bodies based on the 2011 Census, bypassing discretionary state intermediaries [PRS Legislative Research].
- Performance Grants: Introduced incentives for local bodies to improve revenue collection and audit transparency.
Institutionalizing Fiscal Discipline
- FRBM Flexibility: Allowed a flexibility of 0.5% in the fiscal deficit ceiling (3%) for States maintaining a debt-to-GSDP ratio within 25% [Economic Survey 2016-17].
- Revenue Deficit Grants: Identified and provided transitionary support to 11 specific States to stabilize their post-devolution fiscal health.
Conclusion
The 14th FC recommendations transformed States from mere implementers of central projects into equal partners in national development. Moving forward, the focus must remain on balancing this fiscal autonomy with accountability to ensure long-term debt sustainability at the sub-national level.
Ready to practice?
Take this question, write your own answer in 150 words, and get an instant, rubric-based evaluation showing where you stand.
Open evaluation workspace →