Question map
With reference to bio-toilets used by the Indian Railways, consider the following statements : 1. The decomposition of human waste in the bio-toilets is initiated by a fungal inoculum. 2. Ammonia and water vapour are the only end products in this decomposition which are released into the atmosphere. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Explanation
Both statements are incorrect. The bio-digester tank in bio-toilets is filled with anaerobic microbial (bacterial) inoculum, not fungal [1]inoculum[2], making Statement 1 incorrect.
Regarding Statement 2, bio-toilets reduce solid human waste to bio-gas and water with the help of bacterial inoculum[2]. The end products are bio-gas (primarily methane) and water, not ammonia and water vapour as claimed in the statement. The bio-gas produced can be used as an energy source or safely released, while the water output is typically odorless and pathogen-free. Therefore, Statement 2 is also incorrect.
Since both statements are wrong, the correct answer is option D (Neither 1 nor 2).
Sources- [1] https://abhipedia.abhimanu.com/Article/4/NzIyNDIEEQQVV/-Social-Issues-4
- [2] https://indianrailways.gov.in/railwayboard/uploads/directorate/eff_res/camtech/mechanical/YearWise/Compendium%20on%20IR-DRDO%20Bio-toilets%20for%20Indian%20Railways(3).pdf
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question is a classic 'Science behind the Scheme' trap. While it appeared in Current Affairs (DRDO-Railways partnership), it tests the fundamental biological principles of the technology. If you only read the headline 'Bio-toilets installed', you failed; if you read 'How it works', you scored.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Directly states the bio-digester tank is filled with an anaerobic microbial inoculum, explicitly rejecting a fungal inoculum.
- Explains that human waste is processed by anaerobic bacteria in the bio-digester, tying the decomposition to bacteria not fungi.
- Official compendium states bio-toilets reduce human waste to biogas and water with the help of a bacterial inoculum.
- This official phrasing attributes decomposition to bacteria (bacterial inoculum), not to a fungal inoculum.
Describes biogas systems that decompose organic matter in the absence of air using microorganisms to produce gas and a digested slurry.
A student could infer that engineered sanitation systems (like bio-toilets) commonly rely on microbial decomposition (though not necessarily fungi) and therefore check whether railway bio-toilets use anaerobic microbial inocula.
Notes that rubbish in landfills is used for generation of 'landfill gas' via decomposition and that leftover slurry is digested material used as manure.
One could extend this pattern to ask whether small-scale waste-treatment units (bio-toilets) mimic landfill/biogas processes and thus use microbial consortia — prompting investigation into the specific inoculum (bacterial vs fungal) used.
Mentions mycofiltration — use of fungal mycelia to filter toxic waste and microorganisms from water/soil.
Since fungi can be intentionally applied to treat wastes, a student could reasonably hypothesise and then check whether bio-toilet designs ever use fungal inocula (myco-based treatment) rather than or in addition to bacterial systems.
Explains decomposition in nature by decomposers/saprotrophs (insects, microbes) that break down dung and recycle nutrients.
Using the general rule that decomposition can be carried out by various saprotrophs, a student could consider that engineered toilets might employ specific decomposers (bacteria or fungi) and thus investigate which organisms bio-toilets adopt.
States that sewage contains human excreta and that decomposition of organic matter in water is carried out by microorganisms (putrescibility) using oxygen.
This highlights that sewage treatment relies on microbial activity (aerobic or anaerobic); a student can use this to narrow inquiry to whether railway bio-toilets use aerobic fungal processes or anaerobic bacterial digestion.
- Provides the official MCQ answer for the bio-toilet question as 'D' (neither statement is correct).
- An official solution answer of 'neither' indicates that ammonia and water vapour are not the only end products.
- States that bio-toilets reduce solid human waste to 'Bio-gas and water', not just ammonia and water vapour.
- Attributes decomposition to a bacterial inoculum, contradicting the fungal inoculum claim and indicating production of biogas (other gases) released.
States that untreated wastes ferment slowly and release 'toxic biogas' including methane, showing methane is a common gaseous product of decomposition.
A student could infer bio-toilet decomposition likely emits methane (and other biogas components), so ammonia and water vapour are unlikely to be the only gases.
Lists gases released during planetary degassing and decomposition processes: water vapour, nitrogen, carbon dioxide, methane, ammonia, etc., providing an example set of gases associated with organic/thermal decomposition.
Use this list to check whether CO2, methane, and nitrogenous gases are plausible products from biological decomposition in bio-toilets.
Describes biogas produced from organic (including human) waste and notes the digested slurry has nutrient compounds (N, P, K), linking decomposition to both gaseous biogas and nitrogen-containing residues.
Combine this with knowledge of typical biogas composition to suspect gases other than ammonia and water vapour (e.g., methane, CO2) are emitted from bio-toilets.
Mentions landfill gas can be captured and used as biogas and reiterates large biogas potential, implying decomposition generates combustible gases (not just ammonia/water).
A student could extrapolate that systems designed to harvest biogas are targeting methane/CO2 mixtures, so similar decomposition in bio-toilets would produce such gases.
Explains that decomposition and excretion return sulfur to the environment and that hydrogen sulphide oxidizes to sulphur dioxide, showing sulfurous gases can arise from organic decay.
This suggests that, depending on inputs and anaerobic conditions, sulfur-containing gases (e.g., H2S) may be present among decomposition emissions, so ammonia/water vapour are not necessarily the only products.
- [THE VERDICT]: Conceptual Trap. Source: Current Affairs (DRDO Bio-digester technology) filtered through Basic Science (Anaerobic digestion principles).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Waste Management & Sanitation Technologies. Specifically, the DRDO Bio-digester Mk-II used in Indian Railways.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: 1. The inoculum is a consortium of *Anaerobic Bacteria* (originally developed for Siachen/High-altitude). 2. Anaerobic digestion outputs: Methane (CH4) + CO2 + Water (Biogas), not just Ammonia. 3. Aerobic digestion outputs: CO2 + Water + Sludge. 4. Mycoremediation uses Fungi (usually for heavy metals/dyes, not primary sewage). 5. 'Bio-tank' output is pathogen-free water; 'Septic tank' output is toxic sludge.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When a new technology hits the news (e.g., Nano-urea, Bio-toilets, GM Mustard), do not stop at the 'Benefits'. You must dig into the 'Mechanism': What is the active agent? (Bacteria/Fungi/Virus)? What are the by-products? Is it Aerobic or Anaerobic?
References describe biogas production from animal and human waste by decomposition of organic matter in the absence of air — the common engineered process for treating organic waste.
High-yield for environment and resource questions: explains technologies for rural energy, waste-to-energy and linkages between sanitation and energy policy. Useful for questions on decentralized energy, sanitation programmes, and comparative treatment methods. Prepare by understanding process steps, inputs/outputs (gas + slurry), and policy examples.
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 5: Print Culture and the Modern World > Biogas > p. 117
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 8: Energy Resources > Bio-Energy > p. 30
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 6: Environmental Degradation and Management > ix) Landfills > p. 53
Classroom references explain decomposition by organisms (saprotrophs) recycling nutrients from animal/human wastes and the ecological role of decomposers.
Core ecological concept frequently tested in GS and environment sections; underpins topics on waste management, soil fertility and sanitation impacts on health. Master definitions, agents (microbes, insects), and links to composting/manure, enabling answers on ecological and policy implications.
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 12: How Nature Works in Harmony > 12.6 What Happens to Waste in Nature? > p. 201
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Life Processes > 5.5 EXCRETION CRETION > p. 96
One reference explicitly references using fungal mycelia to filter toxic waste and microorganisms from water/soil, showing a fungal application in waste treatment/remediation.
Important niche concept for innovative remediation technologies in environment papers and case-based questions. Knowing fungal bioremediation methods helps answer questions on alternative treatment technologies and sustainable sanitation. Learn examples, mechanisms (mycelial filtration), and limitations.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > Mycofiltration > p. 100
Several references describe decomposition of organic matter under anaerobic conditions producing 'biogas' (used for cooking/lighting) — directly relevant to gases emitted from waste decomposition.
High-yield for UPSC environment questions: connects waste management, renewable energy (biogas), and sanitation policy. Understanding the biogas process helps answer questions on rural energy, sewage treatment and waste-to-energy schemes. Study by linking textbook descriptions of biogas plants, uses, and by practising case-based questions on sanitation and clean energy.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 8: Energy Resources > Bio-Energy > p. 30
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 5: Print Culture and the Modern World > Biogas > p. 117
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 6: Environmental Degradation and Management > ix) Landfills > p. 53
Evidence notes 'toxic biogas including methane' and discusses atmospheric sulphur compounds (H2S → SO2) indicating multiple gases besides just ammonia and water vapour.
Important for answering questions on pollution and atmospheric chemistry: shows decomposition emits multiple gases with environmental/health impacts (methane as greenhouse gas; H2S as toxic). Master by memorising common decomposition gases, their impacts, and links to biogeochemical cycles.
- INDIA PEOPLE AND ECONOMY, TEXTBOOK IN GEOGRAPHY FOR CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 9: Geographical Perspective on Selected Issues and Problems > Case Study : A Role Model to Restore the Ecology and Safeguard Human Health in Daurala > p. 100
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 2: Functions of an Ecosystem > b) Sulphur Cycle > p. 21
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 6: Environmental Degradation and Management > ix) Landfills > p. 53
References state leftover digested slurry from biogas plants serves as manure and nutrient source — tying decomposition outcomes to resource recovery, not just gaseous emissions.
Useful for questions on sustainable waste management and agriculture: connects sanitation technologies to circular economy (energy + fertilizer). Prepare by mapping technologies (biogas, landfills) to co-benefits and trade-offs; useful in policy/GS essays and mains answers.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 8: Energy Resources > Bio-Energy > p. 30
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 6: Environmental Degradation and Management > ix) Landfills > p. 53
The specific bacteria used in these bio-toilets are 'Psychrophilic' (cold-loving), allowing them to function even in freezing temperatures (Siachen origin). A future question might swap 'Psychrophilic' with 'Thermophilic' to trap you.
Apply the 'Carbon Cycle Logic'. Statement 2 says 'Ammonia and water vapour are the ONLY end products'. Human waste is organic (Carbon-based). If Carbon isn't released as CO2 or Methane, where did it go? Matter cannot disappear. Therefore, 'Only Ammonia' is scientifically impossible. Eliminate B and C.
Connects Science & Tech to Internal Security/Defense: This technology is a prime example of 'Dual-use Technology'—originally created by DRDO for soldiers in Siachen (Defense), now solving civilian sanitation issues (Social Justice/Health).