Question map
What is/are unique about 'Kharai camel', a breed found in India? 1. It is capable of swimming up to three kilometres in seawater. 2. It survives by grazing on mangroves. 3. It lives in the wild and cannot be domesticated. Select the correct answer using the code given below.
Explanation
The correct answer is option A (statements 1 and 2 only).
The Kharai camel can indeed swim up to three kilometres into the sea[3], making statement 1 correct. These camels graze on saline/mangrove trees and can swim up to three kilometres into the sea in search of mangroves, their primary food[4], confirming statement 2 is also correct.
However, statement 3 is incorrect. The Kharai is classified among domesticated camel breeds[5], and breeders own Kharai camels, with one breeder and 8 others together owning 350 Kharai camels[6]. This clearly demonstrates that Kharai camels are domesticated and do not live exclusively in the wild.
Therefore, only statements 1 and 2 are correct, making option A the right answer.
Sources- [5] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0378111924004220
- [6] https://www.downtoearth.org.in/wildlife-biodiversity/save-these-camels-of-kutch-61548
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Species in News' question derived directly from environmental reporting (Down To Earth/The Hindu) on the 'Swimming Camels of Kutch'. It targets an 'Ecological Anomaly'—a desert animal adapted to water. While the specific swimming distance is a hard fact, the question is solvable by logic if you understand that 'breeds' are inherently domesticated concepts.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Can Kharai camel (a breed found in India) swim in seawater for distances up to three kilometres?
- Statement 2: Do Kharai camels (a breed found in India) survive by grazing on mangrove vegetation?
- Statement 3: Do Kharai camels (a breed found in India) live in the wild rather than under human ownership?
- Statement 4: Are Kharai camels (a breed found in India) incapable of being domesticated?
- Explicitly states the Kharai camel 'can swim upto three kilometres into the sea' in search of mangroves.
- Notes the breed is tolerant to high saline water and adapted to coastal ecosystems, tying swimming to seawater context.
- States Kharai camels 'regularly swim up to three or four kilometers into the Arabian Sea' to reach island mangrove groves.
- Connects the swimming behavior directly to foraging on mangroves in seawater.
- Clearly states the camels 'can swim up to three[kilometres]' and describes their coastal, saline habitat.
- Mentions adaptations (cushioned hooves) for traversing damp saline terrain, supporting sea-swimming capability.
Gives a general biological rule: animals have intrinsic abilities (including swimming) that determine their capacity to cross water barriers.
A student could use this rule to ask whether any camel breed has evolved intrinsic swimming ability and then seek geographic/ethnographic evidence that a coastal camel population might have such adaptation.
States that India contains a broad spectrum of native livestock breeds (including many camel breeds), implying local genetic diversity and possible local adaptations.
A student could combine this with knowledge of coastal environments in India to hypothesize that a camel breed living near the sea might have developed unusual behaviors (e.g., entering water).
Notes that arid areas include the Rann of Kachchh and the Thar Desert — places where camels live, some of which are close to sea/coastal regions (Rann of Kachchh is a coastal salt marsh).
A student could use a map to locate these coastal/near-coastal camel habitats and then investigate whether local camel populations interact with seawater.
Describes pastoral movements to coastal agricultural tracts (Konkan), showing pastoralists and their livestock operate in near-coastal zones.
A student might infer that pastoralists living/traveling near coasts could expose camels to seawater, prompting inquiry into behavioral adaptations like swimming.
Explains that some aquatic mammals are obligate to particular water types (marine vs freshwater), illustrating that affinity for water is a specific, specialized trait.
A student could use this pattern to reason that swimming long distances in seawater would be a specialized trait for a typically terrestrial mammal, so evidence of such behavior would require strong ecological or ethological support.
- Explicitly states Kharai camels feed on mangroves and saline plants.
- Connects their swimming ability to accessing these coastal food sources.
- Says the camel 'grazes on saline/mangrove trees' and that mangroves are their primary food.
- Notes tolerance to saline water and swimming up to three kilometres to reach mangroves.
- Identifies mangrove-associated plants as part of the primary diet of Kharai camels.
- Describes camels swimming to mangrove 'bets' and living in the mangrove ecosystem to access vegetation.
Describes camels (Raika) as animals that survive on dry, thorny bushes in arid/desert areas, implying a typical feeding ecology of camels.
A student could contrast this typical camel diet with mangrove plant types to judge whether mangrove vegetation is a likely camel food.
Lists camels among animals of thorn forests and scrubs in north-western India, reinforcing the association of camels with arid/thorny habitats rather than coastal mangroves.
Use a map to see if Kharai camel ranges overlap thorn-scrub vs. mangrove zones to assess plausibility of mangrove grazing.
Details mangrove occurrence on the west coast and names Gujarat (Gulf of Kachchh and Kori creek) as areas with mangroves, pointing to geographic locations where mangroves and some camel populations might be proximate.
A student could check whether Kharai camels live in Gujarat/Kutch (Gulf of Kachchh) and therefore could encounter mangrove stands.
States mangroves are salt-tolerant, intertidal forests with specific plant species and distribution, indicating mangrove vegetation is ecologically distinct from inland thorn scrub.
Compare mangrove plant types (salt-tolerant, often fleshy/prop-rooted) with the known diet and digestive adaptations of camels to evaluate eating feasibility.
Notes camels are a distinct livestock genetic resource in India, implying existence of local breeds adapted to local habitats (so breed-specific feeding specializations are plausible).
Investigate whether any local camel breeds (e.g., a Gujarat/Kutch breed) have documented adaptations to coastal/mangrove foraging versus typical desert browsing.
- The multiple-choice question lists 'It lives in the wild and cannot be domesticated' as statement 3 and the provided correct answer is A (1 and 2), implying statement 3 is not true according to this source.
- This passage therefore treats the claim that Kharai camels 'live in the wild and cannot be domesticated' as incorrect.
- Describes local people as breeders and states: 'Adambhai and 8 other breeders together own 350 Kharai camels.'
- Direct ownership by breeders shows these camels are kept under human ownership, not living solely in the wild.
- Lists Kharai among 'old world domesticated camel breeds/populations' included in the study.
- Identification as a domesticated breed indicates they are a human-managed/owned population rather than a wild-only population.
Discusses 'camels' among livestock genetic resources and lists native breeds, treating camels as part of farm/animal husbandry diversity.
A student could infer that named camel breeds are managed by people and check if Kharai is listed among livestock breeds (suggesting ownership rather than wild).
Shows Raika camels grazing with pastoralist groups, illustrating camels used in nomadic herding rather than being wild animals.
One could extend this pattern to ask whether Kharai camels are similarly associated with pastoralists in coastal/desert areas, implying domestication.
Describes nomadic pastoralists who move with herds of camels and cattle, establishing a general pattern of human ownership and movement of camel herds in India.
Use this rule to check whether Kharai camels occur where nomadic herding is practiced (if so, likely under human ownership).
States that arid areas like the Thar Desert are 'habitat for ... camels', which links camels to specific natural regions.
A student could combine this with maps of Kharai distribution (coastal Kachchh) to evaluate whether presence in a habitat implies wild populations or domesticated use.
Gives a general rule that animal distribution is tied to habitat (e.g., 'camels habitat is arid region'), useful for locating where camels live.
One could use this ecological rule plus local human land-use maps to judge if camels in that habitat are likely managed by people (pastoralism) or truly wild.
- The passage lists the claim 'It lives in the wild and cannot be domesticated' as option 3 in a multiple-choice question and gives the official correct answer excluding that option.
- By showing the correct answer is A (1 and 2), it implies statement 3 is false according to the source.
- Explicitly lists Kharai among the 'old world domesticated camel breeds/populations included in the study'.
- Directly contradicts the claim that Kharai camels cannot be domesticated.
- States that people breed Kharai camels and that breeders own flocks, showing human-managed/domesticated ownership.
- Concrete example (breeder Adambhai and others owning 350 Kharai camels) demonstrates domestication/use by humans.
Lists camel among 'domesticated animals' and as part of India's livestock, giving a general rule that camels are treated as domestic livestock in these sources.
A student could check whether Kharai camels are mentioned in regional livestock records or look for local pastoral practices to see if this specific breed is kept by people.
Shows Raika camels grazing in the Thar desert as part of pastoral livelihoods, giving an example of camels being managed by human pastoralists in India.
Compare Raika pastoral practices with Kharai camel locations (e.g., coastal Kachchh) to assess whether similar human management could apply to Kharai camels.
Mentions camels among the broad spectrum of native breeds and livestock genetic resources in India, implying camels have recognized local breeds.
Use breed lists and genetic-resource notes to look up whether Kharai is listed as a native breed and whether it is characterized as wild or domestic.
Identifies habitat regions (Rann of Kachchh and Thar) for wild ass and camels, distinguishing natural habitats which can inform wild vs. domestic status.
Map Kharai camel distribution (Kachchh coast) against these habitat notes to judge whether they occupy wild habitats or are associated with human landscapes.
Discusses domestication in prehistoric India (sheep, goat, etc.), providing a broader pattern that many large mammals were domesticated historically while noting which were/weren't documented.
Use the pattern of documented domestications to investigate historical records for camels in the region and whether Kharai camels appear in ethnographic or archaeological sources.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter (if logic applied) / Current Affairs Trap. Source: 'Down To Earth' articles (2015-16) on the 'Swimming Camels of Kutch' and NBAGR breed recognition.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Indigenous Livestock Breeds & Unique Adaptations. UPSC loves animals that break their biological stereotypes (e.g., a camel that swims, a buffalo that dives).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize other unique Indian breeds: 1. Bactrian Camel (Double-humped, Nubra Valley, Cold Desert). 2. Chilika Buffalo (Brackish water, feeds on weeds). 3. Vechur Cow (World's smallest cattle, Kerala). 4. Toda Buffalo (Nilgiris, semi-wild). 5. Manipuri Pony (Polo origin).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Do not just memorize IUCN lists. Filter news for 'Ecological Anomalies' (animals doing weird things) and 'Livelihood Links' (animals supporting specific tribes like Rabaris/Jats). If an animal has a unique interaction with an ecosystem (Mangroves), it is high priority.
The statement concerns a camel breed and its coastal behaviour; several references describe camels' presence in Indian arid zones (Thar, Rann of Kachchh) and their ecological contexts.
High-yield for geography and environment mains: questions often ask about species distribution, adaptations and region-specific breeds. Mastering habitat-distribution links helps answer queries on where breeds occur, why they evolved certain traits, and to eliminate improbable behavioural claims. Prepare by mapping species to eco-regions and studying examples in NCERT and standard texts.
- India and the Contemporary World - I. History-Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Pastoralists in the Modern World > 1.2 On the Plateaus, Plains and Deserts > p. 100
- CONTEMPORARY INDIA-I ,Geography, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Natural Vegetation and Wildlife > WILDLIFE > p. 43
The claim involves long-distance swimming in seawater; the references include material on physical barriers to animal dispersal and which animals can/cannot cross oceans.
Conceptually useful for ecology and environment questions about species range, dispersal mechanisms and adaptations (e.g., terrestrial vs aquatic limitations). Knowing general dispersal barriers helps critically assess claims about unlikely cross-habitat movements. Study by contrasting dispersal modes and examples in ecology chapters.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 2: PLANT AND ANIMAL KINGDOMS > Dispersal of animals > p. 9
The Kharai camel is a native breed issue; one reference addresses India's native livestock breeds and genetic resources, framing breed-specific adaptation questions.
Relevant for GS papers and environment sections where breed conservation, rural livelihoods and genetic resources are tested. Understanding breed lists, local adaptations and conservation concerns enables answers on why certain breeds show unique behaviours. Preparation: consolidate breed profiles from NCERTs and livestock/diversity chapters of standard texts.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 9: Indian Biodiversity Diverse Landscape > 9.3.4. Livestock genetic diversity > p. 158
References describe camels grazing on dry and thorny bushes in desert/thorn-forest environments, which is directly relevant to claims about what camels eat and where they survive.
Understanding species-specific adaptations and typical forage types is high-yield for environment and geography questions (animal adaptations, livestock ecology, desert ecosystems). It links to pastoralism, resource availability, and livelihood questions; practice by comparing habitat descriptions across sources.
- India and the Contemporary World - I. History-Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Pastoralists in the Modern World > 1.2 On the Plateaus, Plains and Deserts > p. 100
- CONTEMPORARY INDIA-I ,Geography, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Natural Vegetation and Wildlife > The Thorn Forests and Scrubs > p. 42
Multiple references outline mangrove plant species, delta locations (Sundarbans, Godavari, Krishna, etc.) and ecological traits—essential background when assessing whether a terrestrial livestock species uses mangrove vegetation.
Mangrove ecology is frequently tested in environment sections (distribution, conservation, species). Mastering this helps answer questions on coastal ecosystems, human impacts, and species-habitat relationships; study by mapping distributions and key species lists.
- CONTEMPORARY INDIA-I ,Geography, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Natural Vegetation and Wildlife > Mangrove Forests > p. 43
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 4: BIODIVERSITY > Major Mangroves of India > p. 52
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 4: Aquatic Ecosystem > 4,8,4. Mangrove profile in India > p. 49
Evidence describes pastoralist responses to changing access to grazing (migration, finding new pastures), which frames when and where livestock graze and whether unusual grazing (e.g., near coasts) might occur.
This concept links human geography, rural livelihoods and livestock management—common UPSC themes. It helps answer questions on resource access, migration, and land-use change; prepare by studying case examples of pastoralist adaptation.
- India and the Contemporary World - I. History-Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Pastoralists in the Modern World > 2.2 How Did the Pastoralists Cope with these Changes? > p. 107
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 9: Indian Biodiversity Diverse Landscape > 9.3.4. Livestock genetic diversity > p. 158
Several references state camels are associated with arid regions such as the Thar Desert and Rann of Kachchh, which is relevant when assessing whether a camel population is wild or habitat-bound.
High-yield for geography and ecology questions: knowing species–habitat links helps answer distribution and adaptation queries. Connects to biogeography, conservation and land-use topics. Prepare by reviewing habitat–species pairings and maps of arid zones in India.
- CONTEMPORARY INDIA-I ,Geography, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Natural Vegetation and Wildlife > WILDLIFE > p. 43
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 2: PLANT AND ANIMAL KINGDOMS > Distribution of fauna > p. 10
The 'Chilika Buffalo' is the logical sibling. Like the Kharai Camel, it is a unique Indian breed adapted to a saline/brackish environment (Chilika Lake) and feeds on submerged weeds. Another sibling is the 'Bactrian Camel' of Ladakh (Critical for Silk Route history, now used for tourism).
Linguistic Logic Hack: The question calls it a 'breed'. In biology, the term 'breed' is almost exclusively used for DOMESTICATED animals (dogs, cattle, horses). Wild animals are called 'species' or 'subspecies'. Therefore, Statement 3 ('lives in the wild and cannot be domesticated') contradicts the definition of the word 'breed'. If it's a breed, it's domesticated. Eliminate 3 -> Answer is A.
Mains GS-1 (Society/Geography) & GS-3 (Environment): The Kharai camel is a perfect case study for 'Pastoralism vs Industrialization'. Their decline is linked to salt pans destroying mangroves in Kutch. Use this example to argue how destroying an ecosystem (Mangroves) destroys a unique culture (Maldhari pastoralists).