Question map
"The crop is subtropical in nature. A hard frost is injurious to it. It requires at least 210 frost-free days and 50 to 100 centimeters of rainfall for its growth. A light well-drained soil capable of retaining moisture is ideally suited for the cultivation of the crop." Which one of the following is that crop ?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 1 (Cotton). The geographical requirements mentioned in the question perfectly align with the cultivation needs of cotton in India.
- Climatic Conditions: Cotton is a tropical and subtropical crop. It is highly sensitive to cold; therefore, a minimum of 210 frost-free days and bright sunshine are mandatory for its fiber to mature.
- Rainfall: It thrives in areas with 50 to 100 cm of rainfall. Excessive rain during the boll-opening stage is harmful.
- Soil: While it grows best in the black (Regur) soil of the Deccan Plateau, any light, well-drained soil with moisture-retention capacity is suitable.
Regarding other options: Jute requires high rainfall (over 150 cm) and humid conditions. Sugarcane needs more water and a longer growing period without the specific 210 frost-free day constraint. Tea requires heavy rainfall (150-250 cm) and acidic soil on hill slopes, making Cotton the only viable choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Sitter' derived verbatim from NCERT Class X Geography. The phrase '210 frost-free days' is the unique biological signature of Cotton found in standard school textbooks. If you missed this, you are neglecting the basics while chasing advanced material.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Is cotton a subtropical crop that is injured by hard frost, requires at least 210 frost-free days, needs 50-100 cm of annual rainfall, and prefers light well-drained soils that retain moisture?
- Statement 2: Is jute a subtropical crop that is injured by hard frost, requires at least 210 frost-free days, needs 50-100 cm of annual rainfall, and prefers light well-drained soils that retain moisture?
- Statement 3: Is sugarcane a subtropical crop that is injured by hard frost, requires at least 210 frost-free days, needs 50-100 cm of annual rainfall, and prefers light well-drained soils that retain moisture?
- Statement 4: Is tea a subtropical crop that is injured by hard frost, requires at least 210 frost-free days, needs 50-100 cm of annual rainfall, and prefers light well-drained soils that retain moisture?
- Explicitly states cotton grows in drier parts of the Deccan and requires 210 frost-free days.
- Specifies cotton needs light rainfall or irrigation and bright sunshine, matching the 'frost‑free days' and rainfall components.
- States cotton is grown in tropical and subtropical conditions, directly supporting the crop's climatic zone.
- Gives a rainfall requirement of about 50 cm and notes irrigation is needed if rainfall is scanty; describes cultivation on well‑drained alluvial to black clayey soils.
- Declares cotton is very sensitive to frost, supporting the 'injured by hard frost' claim.
- Gives an expected frost‑free period (~200 days) and describes medium loam/ample moisture as preferred soil/moisture conditions.
- Explicitly states the crop is subtropical and that hard frost is injurious.
- Specifies the requirement of at least 210 frost-free days and 50–100 cm of rainfall.
- Repeats the 210 frost-free days and 50–100 cm rainfall requirement.
- Begins to state the soil preference as a light, well-drained soil capable of retaining (moisture).
Describes jute growing on well-drained fertile floodplain soils and requiring high temperature during growth (links jute to soil and temperature preferences).
A student could combine this with knowledge that subtropical regions have high temperatures and floodplain soils to assess the plausibility of the soil/temperature part of the statement.
Gives jute's preferred temperature range (25–35°C), warns that waterlogging is harmful and states 'Rain below 100 cm is not harmful' (implies tolerance to rainfall levels under 100 cm).
Using a climate map, one could compare regional rainfall and temperatures in jute-growing areas to judge whether 50–100 cm and susceptibility to frost are consistent.
Contains the exact phrasing 'It requires at least 210 frost-free days and 50 to 100 centimetres of rainfall' in a crop-identification question (links those numerical requirements to a crop option list including jute).
A student could check which crop the question designates (by using basic MCQ logic or cross-referencing crop lists) and then map frost-free day and rainfall figures onto jute-growing regions.
Explains that fibre crops (cotton example) are sensitive to frost and that a minimum number of frost-free days is used as a geographical requirement for fibre crops.
A student could generalize that fibre crops like jute may also need long frost-free periods and then compare typical frost-free-day maps to jute cultivation zones.
States that frost-free period and rainfall amount/distribution are key climatic factors determining crop yield (gives a general rule for testing crop-climate claims).
Use this rule plus local climate data (frost occurrence, annual rainfall) for major jute areas to assess whether the stated requirements are reasonable.
- Explicitly states the crop is subtropical and that hard frost is injurious.
- Specifies the requirement of at least 210 frost-free days and 50–100 cm of rainfall.
- Repeats the 210 frost-free days and 50–100 cm annual rainfall requirements.
- Mentions a light, well-drained soil capable of retaining (moisture), matching the soil preference.
States frost and fog are detrimental to sugarcane and describes preferred soils (heavy with good drainage but also grows in medium/light soils with irrigation).
Combine this with a map of frost-prone zones to infer where sugarcane would be injured by hard frost and thus is unlikely to thrive.
Lists sugarcane among crops that suffer great damage from cold waves and ground frost, and notes geographic frost frequency (northern Punjab).
Use regional frost frequency data to estimate necessary frost‑free period for successful cultivation.
Explicitly calls sugarcane 'tropical as well as a subtropical crop' and gives a typical temperature range (21–27°C) and annual rainfall range (75–100 cm).
A student could compare those temperature/rainfall ranges with climatic classifications or location rainfall maps to judge the plausibility of the 50–100 cm and subtropical claim.
Explains that frost-free period is a key climatic factor affecting crop yield (mentions 'frost-free period' as contributing to final yield).
One can combine this general rule with local frost calendars to assess whether a 210-day frost-free requirement is reasonable for a perennial like sugarcane.
Describes sugarcane needing high temperature and 'ample rainfall' and liking soils 'retentive of moisture' (deep nitrate soil), linking crop to moist, well-drained soils.
Relate this soil preference to soil-type maps to judge if 'light well-drained soils that retain moisture' is consistent with known sugarcane growing areas.
- Explicitly states the crop is subtropical and that hard frost is injurious.
- Gives the 210 frost-free days requirement and the 50–100 cm rainfall range.
- Specifies the 210 frost-free days and 50–100 cm rainfall requirements.
- Mentions a light well-drained soil capable of retaining (moisture), matching the soil preference.
- Describes tea bushes as requiring a warm, moist, frost-free climate (supports frost sensitivity and frost-free requirement).
- Notes preference for deep, fertile, well-drained soils rich in humus and organic matter, aligning with well-drained moisture-retentive soils.
Describes tea as an evergreen/tree crop preferring temperatures ~20–27°C, very high moisture (over 200 cm) and well‑drained fertile soils with good water‑holding capacity.
Compare this high rainfall and temperature preference with regional rainfall maps and climate classification to judge the plausibility of the 50–100 cm and subtropical claim.
Gives geo‑climatic requirements for tea: temperature 15–25°C, rainfall 100–150 cm, and well‑drained soils on hilly slopes (explicitly tying tea to hill, well‑drained sites).
Use elevation and slope maps plus regional rainfall data to test whether tea’s typical areas match the claimed rainfall/frost‑free day thresholds.
States succinctly that 'Tea bushes require warm and moist frost-free' (phrase indicates sensitivity to frost and need for frost-free conditions).
Check frost occurrence maps or frost‑day climatologies to assess whether tea‑growing zones meet a ≥210 frost‑free‑day criterion.
Notes tea requires moderate temperatures (about 15°C), heavy rainfall (over 150 cm) and well‑drained highland slopes — linking tea to high rainfall and frost‑free upland areas.
Compare the 'heavy rainfall' (150+ cm) pattern here with the statement's 50–100 cm to see a discrepancy and to guide where to look for corroboration or contradiction.
Explains that some crops (including tea) 'thrive best on elevated ground' and that well‑drained hill slopes are homes to major tea gardens — implying sensitivity to frost (altitude, microclimate matters).
Combine this rule (tea on elevated, well‑drained slopes) with basic topographic/frost‑risk knowledge to infer vulnerability to hard frosts and the likely frost‑free day requirements.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. Direct lift from NCERT Class X, Chapter 4 (Agriculture).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Cropping Patterns & Climatic Requirements (Temperature, Rainfall, Soil, Specific Constraints).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the 'Unique Identifiers' for other NCERT crops: 1. Rice: >100cm rain, high humidity. 2. Wheat: Cool growing season, bright sunshine at ripening, 50-75cm rain. 3. Maize: 21-27°C, requires Old Alluvial Soil. 4. Bajra: Sandy & shallow black soil. 5. Tea: Well-drained slopes, >200cm rain.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Do not just read crop descriptions; extract the 'Limiting Factor' or 'Signature Number' for each. For Cotton, it is the frost-free count (210). For Tea, it is the slope (drainage). For Rubber, it is the >200cm rainfall.
Cotton is cultivated under tropical and subtropical conditions and favours hot growing seasons.
High-yield concept for agrarian geography questions: knowing cotton's climatic envelope helps classify regional suitability, link crop patterns to Indian states, and answer comparative questions on fibre crops. It connects climate types, crop distribution and seasonality (kharif).
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Cotton (Gossypium spp.) > p. 39
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 4: The Age of Industrialisation > TYPES OF FARMING > p. 87
Cotton is highly sensitive to frost and needs a long frost‑free growing period (around 200–210 days) to mature.
Crucial for questions on crop vulnerabilities and regional produce: explains why cotton belts avoid frosty zones, relates to harvest windows and climatic risk management. Useful for linking climate constraints to crop yields and irrigation planning.
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 4: The Age of Industrialisation > TYPES OF FARMING > p. 87
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 26: Agriculture > A TABLE SUMMARY OF THE MAJOR AGRICULTURAL CROPS OF THE WORLD TABLE III FIBRES > p. 257
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 26: Agriculture > Factors Influencing Agriculture > p. 239
Cotton requires moderate rainfall (commonly cited ~50 cm and up) and often needs irrigation when rainfall is insufficient.
Helps answer questions on cropping requirements, water management and regional productivity; enables evaluation of statements about crop suitability in semi‑arid vs humid regions and policy questions on irrigation and cash-crop zones.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Cotton (Gossypium spp.) > p. 39
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Contd.) > p. 85
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 26: Agriculture > A TABLE SUMMARY OF THE MAJOR AGRICULTURAL CROPS OF THE WORLD TABLE III FIBRES > p. 257
The frost-free period (number of frost-free days) is a key climatic constraint used to judge crop suitability and maturity timing.
High-yield concept for UPSC: many questions require distinguishing crops by their frost sensitivity or minimum frost-free days (useful in crop–climate matching and zonation). It connects climate classification, cropping calendars, and regional crop distribution, enabling elimination of wrong options in MCQs comparing crops.
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 4: The Age of Industrialisation > TYPES OF FARMING > p. 87
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 26: Agriculture > Factors Influencing Agriculture > p. 239
Different fibre crops have characteristic annual rainfall ranges that determine suitable growing regions.
Mastering typical rainfall requirements (low, moderate, high) helps answer questions on regional suitability and cropping patterns; it links hydroclimate, irrigation needs, and spatial distribution of crops like jute, cotton and rubber.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Jute (Corchorus capsularis) > p. 50
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Contd.) > p. 85
Crop success often depends on soils that are well drained yet can retain moisture during growth — a frequent specification for crops grown on flood plains or alluvial soils.
This is repeatedly tested in geography/agriculture questions: knowing which crops prefer well-drained alluvial soils versus heavy clays clarifies regional cropping belts and land-use suitability; it ties into irrigation, floodplain agriculture and soil management topics.
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 4: The Age of Industrialisation > TYPES OF FARMING > p. 87
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Jute (Corchorus capsularis) > p. 50
Sugarcane is grown in both tropical and subtropical zones and is associated with high growing-season temperatures (around 20–27°C) and substantial annual rainfall commonly cited in the 75–165 cm range.
High-yield concept for UPSC geography: questions often ask crop–climate matches and rainfall/temperature ranges. Mastering this helps answer items on agricultural regions, crop distribution, and irrigation needs. Connects to state-wise production patterns and cropping systems.
- NCERT. (2022). Contemporary India II: Textbook in Geography for Class X (Revised ed.). NCERT. > Chapter 4: The Age of Industrialisation > Food Crops other than Grains > p. 85
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Contd.) > p. 85
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 12: Major Crops and Cropping Patterns in India > Tobacco > p. 56
Maize. In the same NCERT chapter, Maize is the only crop explicitly linked to 'Old Alluvial Soil' and a specific temperature range of '21-27°C'. A future question could describe a crop requiring 'Old Alluvial Soil' to trap students who associate all cereals with general alluvial soil.
Use the 'Rainfall Ruler'. The range '50-100 cm' is moderate-to-low.
1. Tea and Jute are water-intensive (>150-200 cm); eliminate them immediately.
2. You are left with Cotton vs. Sugarcane.
3. Apply the 'Frost Logic': Cotton is grown for its flower (boll); frost kills the flower. Sugarcane is a stem crop; frost reduces sugar content but doesn't instantly destroy the harvest like it does to cotton bolls. Hence, 'hard frost is injurious' points strongly to Cotton.
Connect Cotton to GS3 (Economy & Environment): Cotton is a 'White Gold' cash crop but also a water-guzzler (virtual water export). Link it to the 'Pink Bollworm' pest issues (Science) and the history of 'Bt Cotton' adoption in India.