Question map
Consider the following statements : 1. Other than those made by humans, nanoparticles do not exist in nature. 2. Nanoparticles of some metallic oxides are used in the manufacture of some cosmetics. 3. Nanoparticles of some commercial products which enter the environment are unsafe for humans. Which of the statements given above is/are correct ?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 4 (2 and 3) because of the following reasons:
- Statement 1 is incorrect: Nanoparticles occur abundantly in nature. They are found in volcanic ash, ocean spray, mineral composites, and are even produced by certain biological processes. Therefore, the claim that they only exist due to human activity is false.
- Statement 2 is correct: Metallic oxide nanoparticles, particularly Titanium Dioxide (TiO2) and Zinc Oxide (ZnO), are widely used in cosmetics like sunscreens and foundations. They are preferred because they provide effective UV protection while remaining transparent on the skin.
- Statement 3 is correct: Due to their high surface-to-volume ratio, nanoparticles can be chemically reactive and penetrate biological membranes. Studies indicate that certain commercial nanoparticles entering the environment can accumulate in the food chain, posing potential toxicological risks to human health.
Since statements 2 and 3 are scientifically accurate while statement 1 is factually wrong, Option 4 is the right choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Applied Science' question. While Statement 3 is directly in standard books (Shankar IAS), Statements 1 and 2 require 'Scientific Common Sense' rather than rote memorization. The key was realizing that nature operates at all scales, not just the ones humans invented.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Do naturally occurring nanoparticles exist in nature independent of human manufacturing?
- Statement 2: Are nanoparticles of metallic oxides (for example titanium dioxide or zinc oxide) used in the manufacture of some cosmetics such as sunscreens and makeup?
- Statement 3: Do nanoparticles released from commercial products into the environment pose health risks to humans?
- Explicitly states that human exposure to naturally occurring nanoparticles has been a constant feature of the environment.
- Distinguishes naturally occurring NPs from engineered/anthropogenic sources, implying they exist independent of human manufacturing.
- States that nanomaterials have been present since Earth's origin, indicating their natural occurrence long before human manufacturing.
- Links naturally occurring nanomaterials to the evolution of life, reinforcing their natural, pre-anthropogenic presence.
- Identifies weathering and mineral formation in soils as main producers of Earth's natural nanomaterials.
- Specifically names clays as the most abundant naturally occurring inorganic nanomaterial, showing natural formation processes create NPs.
Says some elements are 'naturally occurring' while others are artificially made, establishing a category distinction between naturally present substances and human-made ones.
A student could combine this with knowledge that elements/compounds can form extremely small particles (e.g., dust, soot, mineral grains) to infer that naturally occurring very-small-scale particles might exist.
Explains atoms combine to form molecules and gives examples of naturally occurring elements and simple molecules, implying natural formation of small-scale particles from atoms.
Using basic chemistry and scale facts (atoms β molecules β clusters), a student could reason that natural processes could produce particulate clusters at nanometer scales.
Defines 'Nature' as life and non-life forms that exist independently of humans and treats materials from nature as resources when used, implying many materials exist without human manufacture.
Combine this with geological and biological knowledge (minerals, volcanic ash, biogenic particles) to suspect naturally formed tiny particles exist independent of humans.
Discusses microparticles (micron-sized plastic beads) being present in the environment and ingested by organisms, illustrating that small particles exist in ecosystems and are relevant at small scales.
A student could note that if micron-scale particles occur and affect organisms, then by analogy and known size ranges, even smaller (nano-scale) particles may also be present naturally (e.g., from biological or geological sources).
Provides a classification 'according to their existence in nature', distinguishing 'qualitative pollutants' that do not occur in nature, which implicitly acknowledges that some pollutants/particles do occur naturally.
Use this rule to reason that since the classification separates man-made from naturally occurring substances, there is a recognized category of naturally occurring particulate matter that could include nanoparticles.
- Explicitly names creams containing nanoparticles of titanium dioxide and zinc oxide, linking these metal-oxide NPs to cosmetic formulations.
- Gives particle size range (10 to 200 nm), indicating these are nanoscale materials used in topical products.
- Specifically states that titanium dioxide and zinc oxide (metal oxides) are used in industries including sunscreen manufacturing.
- Links these metal oxides to product manufacturing relevant to cosmetics (sunscreens).
- Mentions nanoparticles (titanium dioxide, zinc oxide) in the context of toxicological studies and safety tests of cosmetic products.
- Implicates TiO2 and ZnO nanoparticles as materials of concern in cosmetics, supporting their use in such products.
Explicitly names zinc oxide as a common metal oxide and describes its chemical behaviour (e.g., amphoteric nature).
A student could take that ZnO is a wellβknown, stable metal oxide and check external sources on common consumer uses (e.g., sunscreens) and whether nanoβforms are used.
Shows zinc oxide is a discrete, isolable compound that is handled in chemical processes (e.g., reduced to metallic zinc).
Knowing ZnO is a distinct, manufacturable oxide helps a student plausibly consider its formulation into products and then look up formulation details (particle sizes, nano vs. bulk) in cosmetics data sheets.
Lists zinc among commonly produced and refined metals, indicating zinc and its compounds are industrially important and widely available.
Availability and industrial production of zinc make its oxide a plausible candidate for largeβscale uses like cosmetics; a student could then consult product ingredient lists or regulatory guidance about nanoparticle use.
Notes that many metals and their alloys are important for daily use and modern technologies, establishing a pattern that metal-derived materials are used in everyday products.
From the general fact that metal-derived materials are used in daily life, a student can reasonably check whether specific metal oxides (e.g., TiO2, ZnO) are included in cosmetic formulations.
- Defines nanotoxicology and links it to the study of nanomaterial toxicity.
- Explains that nanoparticles have unique properties (quantum effects, high surface-area-to-volume) that alter behavior and potential harm compared with larger forms.
- Describes hazardous waste from manufacturing of commercial products causing toxic releases.
- Connects unscientific disposal and industrial waste to emissions and health-related problems.
- Provides the contaminant β pollutant concept and notes transport via environmental pathways.
- Explains that if a released substance is not transformed it becomes a pollutant with potential targets (including humans).
- [THE VERDICT]: Logical Trap / Application-based. Statement 1 is the 'Extreme Negative' trap. Source: General awareness of science + Shankar IAS (Chapter on Pollution/Nanotoxicology).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Emerging Technologies (Nanotech) β Daily Life Applications β Environmental Impact.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: (1) Natural Nanoparticles: Volcanic ash, forest fire soot, sea spray, viral capsids. (2) Cosmetic Nanoparticles: Titanium Dioxide (TiO2) & Zinc Oxide (ZnO) for UV blocking; Fullerenes in anti-aging. (3) Health Risks: Crossing the Blood-Brain Barrier, oxidative stress (ROS generation), similarity to asbestos fibers (carbon nanotubes).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When studying any new tech (Nano, Bio, AI), apply the 'Lifecycle Framework': Does it exist naturally? β How do we use it (Cosmetics/Food/Agri)? β What happens when it degrades (Toxicity/Waste)?
Distinguishes materials that exist independently in nature from those manufactured by humans.
High-yield for questions on resource origin, material classification, and environmental impact; helps separate naturally occurring substances from anthropogenic compounds in policy and science contexts. Connects to chemistry (elements vs synthetic elements) and environmental studies (man-made pollutants).
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 1: Natural Resources and Their Use > When does Nature become a Resource? > p. 2
- Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 4: The World of Metals and Non-metals > Activity 4.8: Let us explore > p. 53
Natural resources are materials and substances that occur in nature and are valuable to humans, and they can be classified as renewable or non-renewable.
Core concept for geography and environment papers, useful in questions on resource management, sustainability, and developmental policy. Enables analysis of exploitation, conservation, and economic implications across topics like forestry, minerals, and energy.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 1: Natural Resources and Their Use > Before we move on ... > p. 19
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 1: Natural Resources and Their Use > THINK ABOUT IT > p. 3
Some pollutants do not occur in nature and are explicitly classified as man-made, while others form through natural interactions or secondary processes.
Essential for environment and pollution questions, distinguishing natural background levels from human-caused contamination; aids in framing mitigation strategies and regulatory responses. Links to topics on microplastics, primary/secondary pollutants, and biodegradability.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > 5.r.r. Classifications > p. 63
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > Impact of Microparticles > p. 96
Zinc oxide and aluminium oxide exhibit amphoteric behaviour, meaning they can react with both acids and bases, a key chemical property of some metal oxides.
Understanding amphoteric behaviour is high-yield for chemistry questions on oxide classification and reactivity; it links to materials selection and surface chemistry relevant to product formulations and environmental reactions. Mastery enables answering questions about how oxides behave in different pH environments and why certain oxides are chosen in industrial applications.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 3: Metals and Non-metals > Activity 3.9 > p. 41
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 3: Metals and Non-metals > ZnCO (s) ZnO(s) + CO (g) 3 2 β Heat > p. 51
Metal oxides such as zinc oxide can be reduced (e.g., by carbon) to produce the pure metal, showing common metallurgical processing routes.
This concept is important for questions on extraction and refining of metals, industrial chemistry, and resource economics. It connects metallurgy with topics like industrial processes and material availability, and prepares students for questions on methods of extraction and their environmental/technological implications.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 3: Metals and Non-metals > ZnCO (s) ZnO(s) + CO (g) 3 2 β Heat > p. 51
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 3: Metals and Non-metals > At cathode Na+ + eβ β Na At anode 2Clβ β Cl2 + 2eβ > p. 52
Most metallic oxides tend to be basic, reacting with acids to form salts and water, which distinguishes them chemically from non-metal oxides.
Key for answering standard inorganic chemistry questions on oxide classification and neutralization reactions; links to corrosion, environmental chemistry, and product formulation. Knowing this helps solve reaction-prediction and classification problems in exams.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 2: Acids, Bases and Salts > Activity 2.7 > p. 22
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 3: Metals and Non-metals > Activity 3.8 > p. 40
Nanotoxicology explains that nanoparticles possess quantum effects and high surface-area-to-volume ratios that change their toxicity compared with larger materials.
High-yield for environment and health topics: helps answer questions on emerging contaminants, risk assessment, and regulatory responses to new technologies. Connects to pollution health impacts, industrial regulation and scientific risk communication.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 29: Environment Issues and Health Effects > ffi7 v.2)' EHVINONHENT txJ > p. 423
Since they asked about Metal Oxides (TiO2/ZnO), the next logical target is **Silver Nanoparticles (AgNPs)**. They are used in anti-bacterial clothing, water filters, and food packaging. The specific risk is that they release silver ions that are toxic to beneficial bacteria in soil and aquatic ecosystems.
Apply the **'Nature is Infinite' Heuristic**. Statement 1 claims nanoparticles *do not exist* in nature. This is a 'Universal Negative' in science. Nature creates matter at all scales (atoms, molecules, dust, viruses). It is scientifically arrogant to claim nature skips the 'nano' scale. Therefore, Statement 1 is False. Eliminate options A and C. You are left with B or D. Statement 2 is a specific application (cosmetics), which is usually true in S&T questions. Mark D.
Link Nanoparticles to **GS-3 (Disaster Management & Pollution)**: Nanoparticles are a class of 'Invisible Pollutants' similar to Microplastics. They challenge current regulatory frameworks (like the Hazardous Waste Rules) because they are hard to detect and trace, complicating the 'Polluter Pays Principle'.