Question map
Consider the following statements : I. India accounts for a very large portion of all equity option contracts traded globally thus exhibiting a great boom. II. India's stock market has grown rapidly in the recent past even overtaking Hong Kong's at some point of time. III. There is no regulatory body either to warn the small investors about the risks of options trading or to act on unregistered financial advisors in this regard. Which of the statements given above are correct?
Explanation
**Statement I is correct.** India indeed accounts for a very large portion of global equity option contracts traded, representing a significant boom in derivatives trading in the country.
**Statement II is correct.** As of March'25, the equity market capitalization of BSE and NSE witnessed significant growth of ~7% y-o-y.[1] India's stock market has experienced rapid growth in recent years and has at times surpassed Hong Kong's market capitalization, reflecting the robust expansion of Indian equity markets.
**Statement III is incorrect.** India has SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) as the regulatory body that oversees securities markets. This seminar promoted investor awareness and protection. It educated investors about the securities market, fraud prevention and smart investing practices.[2] SEBI regularly warns investors about market risks, including those related to derivatives and options trading, and has the authority to take action against unregistered financial advisors operating in violation of regulations.
Therefore, only statements I and II are correct, making option A the right answer.
Sources- [1] https://bsmedia.business-standard.com/_media/bs/data/announcements/bse/30092025/0081c928-0405-4b4a-a4b5-9629a86cca85.pdf
- [2] https://bsmedia.business-standard.com/_media/bs/data/announcements/bse/05092025/3d08fbc0-481b-43a6-b7ec-d3a38710e7df.pdf
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question masquerades as a 'Data/Trend' question but is actually solved via 'Static Logic'. While Statements I and II require awareness of financial headlines (India's F&O boom and overtaking Hong Kong), Statement III is a 'Regulatory Vacuum' trap. Recognizing that SEBI exists to regulate advisors allows you to bypass the data heavy-lifting entirely.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: What percentage of global exchange-traded equity option contracts (by annual traded contract volume) is accounted for by India?
- Statement 2: Has India's stock market market capitalization ever surpassed Hong Kong's market capitalization in recent years, and if so when?
- Statement 3: Is there a regulatory body in India that issues warnings to retail/small investors about the risks of options trading?
- Statement 4: Is there a regulatory body in India that can take enforcement action against unregistered financial advisors who provide options trading advice?
States NSE is India's largest exchange, offers a trading platform for derivatives (including equity derivatives) and has nationwide electronic volume.
A student could combine this with external global exchange volumes (e.g., top exchanges' derivatives volumes) to estimate India's share by comparing NSE derivatives volumes to global totals.
Notes that India has leading stock exchanges and specifies settlement cycle (T+2), implying operational maturity and standardized trading infrastructure that supports high contract volumes.
Use knowledge that mature, high-liquidity exchanges tend to generate larger option contract volumes; compare India's exchange infrastructure and typical volumes with other mature markets to judge plausibility.
Says India's percentage share in global trade is 'on the lower side', indicating India is a relatively smaller share of some global economic aggregates.
A student could use the idea that India often holds a smaller share of global economic activity to hypothesize a modest percentage share of global option contracts unless domestic derivatives activity is disproportionately large.
Provides concrete percentages of India's exports to major partners, demonstrating how India’s share metrics are presented and evaluated in international contexts.
Apply the practice of expressing national contributions as percentage shares of global or bilateral totals to compute India's share of global option contracts once volumes are obtained externally.
Shows breakdowns and percentage shares for commodity groups in exports, exemplifying use of percentage-share tables for national economic aggregates.
Students can follow the same method—obtain India's annual traded option contract count (from NSE reports) and divide by total global annual traded contracts to produce the requested percentage.
Defines SENSEX as a free-float market-capitalisation weighted index and gives the formula linking total weighted market capitalisation to the index.
A student can use this to understand that comparisons of market capitalisation require clarifying whether free-float or full market cap is used, and then obtain comparable market-cap series for India and Hong Kong to compare over time.
Gives concrete size bands (e.g., mid cap defined by market capitalisation ranges in rupees), illustrating that the texts treat market-cap thresholds as an explicit measurable quantity.
A student could convert such rupee thresholds and aggregate company caps to estimate overall market-cap scale, or use analogous banding to interpret published market-cap totals for India vs Hong Kong.
Describes financial-sector reforms (1992) that opened capital markets to portfolio investments and access to international capital, a structural factor that can drive growth in India's market capitalisation.
A student can combine this with timelines of capital-market liberalisation and subsequent GDP/market-cap growth to identify periods when India's market cap might have accelerated relative to Hong Kong's.
Notes that foreign institutional investors can buy/sell Indian securities (subject to registration/PIS), indicating channels for large cross-border inflows that affect market capitalisation.
A student could examine FII inflow records and major inflow years, correlate them with rises in India's market cap, and compare those years with Hong Kong's market-cap trajectory.
Explains liberalisation of foreign exchange and increased participation of foreign institutional investors after 1991–1999 reforms — contextual drivers of equity-market growth.
A student can use these policy-change dates as anchors and then consult time-series market-cap data (converted to a common currency) to check whether and when India overtook Hong Kong.
This snippet states that secondary markets are regulated by SEBI, implying SEBI has authority over market activities where derivatives/options trade.
A student could check SEBI's role on investor protection (e.g., 'investor education' or 'alerts' pages) or search SEBI advisories for warnings on options trading.
It notes the Forward Markets Commission (FMC) — former regulator of commodity futures — was merged with SEBI, indicating SEBI now covers derivative/commodity markets previously under FMC.
One could infer SEBI may have absorbed FMC's investor-protection activities and then look for SEBI notices or circulars relating to futures/options risk warnings.
Depositories and their participants are regulated by SEBI, showing SEBI's broad supervisory remit over intermediaries that service retail investors.
A student could extend this to expect SEBI to issue guidance or warnings aimed at retail clients serviced by these intermediaries, then search intermediary circulars or SEBI advisories.
Defines several market entities and explicitly states that certain investment vehicles (AIFs) are regulated by SEBI, reinforcing SEBI's regulatory scope across diverse financial products.
Using this pattern, a student might reasonably look for SEBI-issued investor alerts across product types, including option-related communications.
States that depositories and their agents (DPs) are regulated by SEBI, showing SEBI's role regulating market intermediaries.
A student could extend this by checking SEBI's wider remit over securities market intermediaries to see if 'financial advisors' for derivatives/options fall under its registration/enforcement rules.
Says foreign institutional investors must register with SEBI to operate in Indian capital markets, illustrating a pattern that market participants/advisors often require SEBI registration.
Use this pattern to investigate whether advisory services related to securities/options similarly require SEBI registration and whether non‑registration triggers enforcement.
Describes the Financial Stability and Development Council (FSDC) as coordinating inter‑regulatory matters across financial sector regulators.
A student could infer that issues spanning securities advice (options) and consumer protection could be coordinated among regulators (e.g., SEBI, RBI) via FSDC and check which regulator has primary authority.
Defines 'regulatory forbearance' (tolerance or not enforcing rules), highlighting that even where a regulator exists, enforcement may vary.
Combine this with knowledge of any regulator's mandate to assess not only legal authority but likelihood/practicality of action against unregistered advisors.
Summarizes the Supreme Court striking down an RBI circular banning crypto services, demonstrating that regulatory actions can be legally contested and that regulators' enforcement tools have legal limits.
A student could apply this precedent to anticipate legal constraints on enforcement against unregistered advisors and look up relevant case law or limits on regulator directives.
- Bullet 1. [THE VERDICT]: Sitter via Elimination. Statement III is logically absurd for a regulated economy. Source: General Awareness of SEBI's mandate.
- Bullet 2. [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Capital Markets & Investor Protection. The massive surge in retail F&O trading (90% loss rate reports) and SEBI's crackdown on 'finfluencers'.
- Bullet 3. [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: SEBI Act 1992 (Powers to regulate intermediaries); Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT); Difference between 'Volume' (India leads) vs 'Notional Value' (US leads); T+1 vs T+0 settlement cycles; STT (Securities Transaction Tax).
- Bullet 4. [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When you see 'India accounts for a very large portion', check for recent 'Superlative' news (World's largest derivatives exchange). When you see 'No regulatory body', immediately invoke the 'Existential Negation' rule—in India's financial sector, a regulator always exists (SEBI/RBI).
NSE is India's largest exchange by trading volumes and provides the trading platform for derivatives, which is the institutional base for equity options.
Understanding the primary domestic venue for exchange-traded derivatives is high-yield for questions on market structure, financial sector reforms, and derivatives regulation. It links to topics on market depth, liquidity and how domestic trading infrastructure affects a country's share in global contract volumes.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > National Stock Exchange > p. 276
India's share in global trade and financial markets is described as on the lower side, prompting policy measures toward internationalisation of the rupee.
Grasping India's comparative global footprint helps explain why India may account for a small percentage of global contract volumes and informs answers on policy responses (e.g., rupee internationalisation, capital account liberalisation). This connects macroeconomic external sector topics with financial market questions.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 17: India’s Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade > Can Indian Rupee be Internationalised? > p. 500
India follows a T+2 settlement cycle and has modern automated electronic exchanges, which influence trading efficiency, liquidity and the capacity to handle large contract volumes.
Questions about market performance and comparative volumes often hinge on market infrastructure and settlement norms. Mastery helps link operational features of exchanges to broader themes like investor confidence, turnover rates and why some markets capture larger global shares.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > STOCK EXCHANGE > p. 275
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > National Stock Exchange > p. 276
Market capitalisation is the core metric for comparing stock‑market sizes and SENSEX is explicitly described as a free‑float market capitalisation weighted index.
High yield for questions comparing exchange sizes, index construction and valuation — mastering this clarifies how aggregate market value is measured and why index weights change. Connects to corporate valuation, index methodology and macro comparisons of capital markets.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Bombay Stock Exchange > p. 276
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > IMPORTANT TERMS RELATED TO STOCK MARKET > p. 278
Distinguishing primary (IPOs/new issues) from secondary markets is essential to understanding where market capitalisation is formed and traded.
Important for questions on how new listings and liquidity affect market size, and for policy topics on capital‑raising. Links to financial reforms, IPO mechanics and market depth assessments frequently asked in UPSC economic sections.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > CAPITAL MARKET > p. 262
Foreign institutional investor participation and capital‑flow liberalisation materially affect equity market size and cross‑border comparisons of market capitalisation.
Crucial for questions on capital account convertibility, balance of payments effects on equity markets, and regulatory impacts on market valuation. Helps answer policy and macroeconomic questions about external influences on domestic capital markets.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 16: Balance of Payments > a. Foreign Institutional Investment (FII) > p. 478
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 3. Regulation of Foreign Exchange Market, Govt. Securities Market and Money Market > p. 67
SEBI regulates secondary markets and is the principal regulator for capital market activities in India.
High-yield for UPSC because questions often ask which institution regulates market segments and investor protection. Mastering SEBI's role links to topics on market regulation, demat systems, IPO approvals and investor safeguards, enabling answers on regulatory responsibilities and policy changes.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > CAPITAL MARKET > p. 262
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > IMPORTANT TERMS RELATED TO STOCK MARKET > p. 277
Since the question highlights the 'Options Boom', the next logical question is on the fiscal response: Securities Transaction Tax (STT). Remember that STT is levied on the value of taxable securities transactions and is a direct tax collected by the exchange.
The 'Regulatory Vacuum' Fallacy. Statement III claims 'There is no regulatory body'. In a modern economy, every financial domain (Banking, Insurance, Pensions, Stocks) has a statutory regulator. An option claiming a total regulatory void is 99% false. Eliminate III → Answer A is the only remainder.
Mains GS-3 (Economy - Mobilization of Resources): The 'Financialization of Savings'. Connect the F&O boom to the decline in household net financial savings and the risk it poses to banking liquidity and capital formation for productive sectors.