Question map
Consider the following statements : Statement I : As regards returns from an investment in a company, generally, bondholders are considered to be relatively at lower risk than stockholders. Statement II : Bondholders are lenders to a company whereas stockholders are its owners. Statement III : For repayment purpose, bondholders are prioritized over stockholders by a company. Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?
Explanation
The correct answer is option A because all three statements are accurate and Statements II and III together explain Statement I.
Debt securities (bonds/debentures) represent money borrowed that must be repaid with defined terms, where holders receive interest and principal repayment[1], while equity securities represent ownership held by shareholders in a company[2]. This establishes that bondholders are lenders and stockholders are owners (Statement II is correct).
If the issuer faces bankruptcy, bondholders have priority over shareholders in repayment, with bondholders having[4] priority claim before[3] stockholders on the company's assets (Statement III is correct).
These two facts together explain why bonds are generally safer than equities and[3] are considered lower risk investments compared to stocks[5] (Statement I is correct). The combination of bondholders' status as creditors with fixed claims and their priority in repayment directly accounts for their relatively lower risk position compared to stockholders who bear residual ownership risks.
Sources- [1] Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.4 Securities > p. 42
- [2] Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.4 Securities > p. 41
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a conceptual 'Sitter' from the Financial Markets chapter. It tests the fundamental 'Risk-Return Trade-off' principle found in every standard Economy textbook (Vivek Singh, Singhania, NCERT). The challenge isn't the facts, but the 'Assertion-Reasoning' logic—recognizing that legal priority (Statement III) and ownership status (Statement II) are the *causes* of the risk profile (Statement I).
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: In corporate finance, are bondholders generally considered to be at lower risk than stockholders with respect to returns from an investment in a company?
- Statement 2: In a company's capital structure, are bondholders lenders to the company?
- Statement 3: In a company's capital structure, are stockholders owners of the company?
- Statement 4: In corporate finance, are bondholders prioritized over stockholders for repayment (for example in insolvency) by a company?
- Statement 5: Does the fact that bondholders are lenders to a company explain why bondholders are generally at lower risk than stockholders regarding investment returns?
- Statement 6: Does the priority of bondholders over stockholders for repayment explain why bondholders are generally at lower risk than stockholders regarding investment returns?
- Debenture holders are owed a specified amount with interest, creating a fixed payment obligation for the company.
- Interest on debentures is treated as a charge against profits, implying priority of the debt claim over residual equity claims.
- A deep corporate bond market can provide a stable source of finance, especially when the equity/share market is volatile.
- Bonds are presented as a tool to supplement banking and reduce vulnerability when equity is subject to volatility.
- Equity investments (e.g., mid-cap stocks) are described as riskier and potentially more volatile than larger-cap equity, illustrating equity risk characteristics.
- The text contrasts varying risk levels within equities, supporting the view that ownership (equity) carries higher return variability than fixed-income claims.
- Debenture holders are entitled to a specified amount plus interest, showing a contractual payment obligation by the company.
- Debentures are treated as part of the capital structure but explicitly not as equity, implying a creditor (not owner) relationship.
- Interest on debentures is a charge against profits, a characteristic of debt obligations rather than equity returns.
- Investors provide funds either as debt (receive fixed interest) or as equity (share profits/losses), distinguishing debt investors from owners.
- The company records debt securities (bonds/notes) on the liability side, indicating those investors are creditors/lenders.
- Discussion of bondholders contrasts borrower (debtor) and lender (creditor) outcomes, linking bondholders to the lender/creditor role.
- Bonds provide fixed returns after maturity, a defining feature of loan-like claims rather than ownership.
- Capital is divided into shares, and each share functions as a unit of ownership in the company.
- Shareholders receive dividends and gain/lose from changes in share value, reflecting ownership stakes.
- Equity shares are explicitly described as representing ownership of the company.
- Equity shares carry voting rights, linking shareholding to control/ownership.
- Ownership is represented by an ownership document divided into shares proportional to each owner's stake.
- Changes in company assets or profits affect share value, underscoring the economic reality of ownership.
- Defines debt security as borrowed money that must be repaid under specified terms.
- Specifies holders of debt receive interest and repayment of principal, implying a contractual claim on company cashflows.
- Contrasts equity as ownership (shareholders) with debt as a financial obligation.
- By distinguishing equity (ownership) from debt (repayable obligation), it implies equity is not a contractual creditor claim.
- Describes insolvency process where creditors (financial or operational) can initiate resolution, showing creditors have enforceable remedies.
- Creditors' ability to approach NCLT to recover dues indicates creditor claims are actionable during insolvency.
- Direct contrast between equity (returns tied to company performance) and debt (fixed interest and principal).
- Shows debt investors receive predetermined payments while equity holders face variable dividends/profits.
- Implies bondholders' returns are less dependent on firm performance, reducing variability of outcomes versus stockholders.
- Explains that isolating assets (SPV) reduces risk exposure and provides comfort to lenders.
- States that such isolation makes the SPV subject to fewer risks, thereby lowering lenders' risk relative to other claimants.
- Describes how credit rating assesses borrowers' creditworthiness and thereby quantifies lender risk.
- Notes that better ratings secure lower interest because underlying credit risk is low, showing debt risk is identified and priced.
- Explicitly states bondholders have priority in bankruptcy, which reduces recovery risk relative to shareholders.
- Directly links this priority to the claim that bonds are generally safer than equities.
- Specifies bondholders have a priority claim on assets before stockholders in bankruptcy, supporting the repayment-priority mechanism.
- Notes that bonds have a known upper limit if held to maturity, implying more predictable (and typically lower-risk) returns compared with stocks' unlimited upside.
- States bonds aim to provide regular income and capital preservation—characteristics associated with lower investment risk.
- Concludes bonds are generally considered to be lower risk investments compared with stocks, consistent with repayment priority reducing bondholder risk.
Defines debentures as debt instruments with fixed interest and notes that credit rating affects interest because risk to debt-holders varies.
A student can combine this with the basic legal fact that debt typically ranks ahead of equity in bankruptcy to infer that fixed claims + seniority imply lower expected loss relative to equity.
Explains zero-coupon bonds repay face value at maturity rather than periodic interest — emphasises the contractual, time-fixed nature of bond repayment.
Use the idea of fixed contractual repayment timing together with the creditor-priority principle to judge that bondholders' returns are more certain than equity's residual claims.
Notes convertible bonds pay lower interest because they include an option to convert to equity — showing a trade-off between bond-like security and equity upside.
From this example, a student can infer that pure debt (without conversion) offers steadier returns and less upside but also generally lower risk compared with equity-linked instruments.
Describes capital loss to bondholders from falling bond prices when interest rates change — identifying market (interest rate) risk for bonds separate from credit/priority issues.
Combine this market-risk rule with creditor priority to see that bonds have lower credit/claim risk but still face price/interest-rate risk, so overall risk comparison with equity depends on both.
Says inflation causes loss to bondholders because bonds give fixed returns, showing bonds are exposed to real-value risk.
A student can weigh this inflation/real-return risk against the residual-claim risk of equity to assess why bondholder priority reduces some risks but does not eliminate others.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. Direct concept from standard texts like Vivek Singh (Ch: Money & Banking) or Nitin Singhania (Ch: Financial Market).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Capital Markets > Instruments > The structural difference between Debt (Bonds) and Equity (Shares).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the 'Risk Hierarchy': G-Secs (Risk Free) < Corporate Bonds < Preference Shares < Equity Shares. Also, study 'Hybrid Instruments': Convertible Bonds (lower interest due to equity option), AT-1 Bonds (perpetual, write-down risk), and Zero-Coupon Bonds (issued at discount).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Move beyond definitions. Ask 'Why?'. Why is equity riskier? Because it is a 'Residual Claim' (paid last). Why are bonds safer? Because they are a 'Contractual Obligation' (paid first). The exam is testing your grasp of this causal mechanism.
Debentures impose specified interest payments and repayment obligations on a company, distinguishing them from equity ownership.
High-yield for UPSC: explains fundamental difference between debt and equity, informs answers on capital structure and investor risk preferences, and helps tackle questions on corporate financing choices and investor protection.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Features of Debentures > p. 264
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Debentures > p. 263
Interest on debt is a charge against profits, giving debt holders a prior financial claim relative to shareholders.
Essential for questions on creditor rights, insolvency outcomes and settlement order in distress; links to bankruptcy law reforms and investor protection discussions in finance governance.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Features of Debentures > p. 264
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.6 Corporate Bond Market in India > p. 49
A developed corporate bond market provides stable long-term finance and can offset volatility in the equity/share market.
Valuable for macro-financial and policy questions: explains why policymakers promote bond market development, ties into financial stability, capital flows, and choices between debt and equity financing.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.6 Corporate Bond Market in India > p. 48
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.6 Corporate Bond Market in India > p. 49
Companies raise funds either as debt (fixed interest payments) or as equity (ownership sharing), making debt investors lenders rather than owners.
High-yield concept for corporate finance and economics questions; helps distinguish investor rights, balance-sheet presentation, and policy implications of financing choices. Mastery enables answering questions on capital structure, investor claims, and fiscal/monetary impacts on finance.
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.4 Securities > p. 45
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Features of Debentures > p. 264
Debentures/bonds impose a contractual obligation on the company to pay specified amounts with interest and are not classified as equity.
Essential for understanding creditor protections, fixed-income instruments, and the difference between ownership and lending. Useful across banking, corporate law, and public finance questions about obligations and investor treatment.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Features of Debentures > p. 264
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > EFFECTS/IMPACT OF INFLATION > p. 70
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 16: Terminology > 16 Terminology > p. 455
Inflation and restructuring affect lenders and borrowers differently: inflation tends to harm fixed-income holders, and restructuring negotiations involve lender rights.
Important for macro-financial and banking policy topics—explains distributional effects of inflation, bankruptcy implications, and why creditors act in restructuring. Helps answer questions on financial stability and debt relief mechanisms.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 4: Inflation > EFFECTS/IMPACT OF INFLATION > p. 70
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 16: Terminology > 16 Terminology > p. 455
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 8: Financial Market > Strategic Debt Restructuring (SDR) - 2015 > p. 229
Shares are the basic units through which ownership in a company is represented.
Foundational for corporate finance and business governance questions; explains how capital is raised and how ownership is segmented. Mastering this clarifies topics like shareholder rights, dividends, and capital structure comparisons.
- Indian Economy, Nitin Singhania .(ed 2nd 2021-22) > Chapter 9: Agriculture > Shares > p. 263
- Indian Economy, Vivek Singh (7th ed. 2023-24) > Chapter 2: Money and Banking- Part I > 2.4 Securities > p. 45
The 'AT-1 Bond' (Additional Tier-1). While bonds are generally safer, AT-1 bonds are an exception often tested. They are unsecured, perpetual, and can be written off completely if the bank's capital falls below a threshold (e.g., Yes Bank crisis), making them riskier than normal corporate debt.
Apply the 'Risk-Return Trade-off' heuristic. In finance, if you have 'Ownership' (unlimited upside potential), you must carry 'Higher Risk'. If you are a 'Lender' (capped upside/fixed interest), you must have 'Lower Risk'. Since Statement II defines the roles (Owner vs Lender), it logically *must* explain the risk profile in Statement I.
Mains GS-3 (Investment Models & IBC): This hierarchy directly links to the 'Waterfall Mechanism' under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). In liquidation, the order is: Insolvency costs > Secured Creditors/Workmen > Unsecured Creditors > Government Dues > Preference Shareholders > Equity Shareholders.