Question map
Consider the following statements : I. No virus can survive in ocean waters. II. No virus can infect bacteria. III. No virus can change the cellular transcriptional activity in host cells. How many of the statements given above are correct?
Explanation
None of the three statements are correct.
**Statement I is incorrect:** Viruses are ubiquitous in natural environments, and their extremely high abundance, diversity, and activity make them indispensable to various Earth's ecosystems.[1] They are a diverse group of viruses which are the most abundant biological entity in marine environments, because their hosts, bacteria, are typically the numerically dominant cellular life in the sea.[2] Additionally, some of these viruses may even persist in marine sediments for more than thousands of years.[3]
**Statement II is incorrect:** They may infect plants, animals, or bacterial cells and may cause a disease.[4] Viruses that infect bacteria are called bacteriophages and are well-documented in scientific literature.
**Statement III is incorrect:** Viruses multiply when they enter a living cell.[4] When viruses infect host cells, they necessarily alter the cellular machinery and transcriptional activity to replicate themselves. The documents reference studies on alga-virus interactions and HSV-1 that reveal sequential transcriptional programs and infection states during viral infection, confirming that viruses do change cellular transcriptional activity.
Therefore, all three statements are incorrect, making option D the correct answer.
Sources- [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41699-4
- [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marine_viruses
- [3] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-47600-1
- [4] Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: The Invisible Living World: Beyond Our Naked Eye > Ever heard of ... > p. 17
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Science & Tech meets Environment' question. It tests basic biological definitions (NCERT Class VIII) against extreme statements ('No virus can...'). The difficulty isn't the technical detail, but the confidence to reject absolute negatives in a high-pressure exam. It is a high-fairness question disguised as a technical bouncer.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Explicitly states marine viruses can persist long-term in sediments, directly answering whether viruses can survive in marine environments.
- Mentions transport on oceanic currents, supporting persistence and movement within marine waters.
- States that viruses are ubiquitous in natural environments, indicating they are present in oceans as well.
- Notes high abundance, diversity, and activity of viruses, supporting that marine viruses persist and are ecologically important.
- Describes marine phages as the most abundant biological entity in marine environments, supporting that many viruses exist and persist in the sea.
- Ties viral abundance to the dominance of bacterial hosts in the ocean, implying ongoing viral presence and activity.
States that polluted water contains pathogens like viruses, implying viruses can be present in aquatic environments.
A student could combine this with knowledge of sewage discharge and coastal sampling to investigate whether marine waters near pollution sources contain viable viruses.
Lists key environmental variables in oceans (temperature, salinity, light) that influence which organisms persist, implying these factors would also affect virus stability.
Use standard facts about how temperature, salinity and light affect biomolecule stability to predict where viruses might persist (e.g., colder, less UV-exposed zones).
Notes higher solar UV-B exposure in tropics affects organisms, suggesting sunlight/UV is an environmental factor that could inactivate viruses at the surface.
A student could infer that viruses may be less stable in surface tropical waters with strong UV, and more stable in deeper or turbid waters with less UV penetration.
Describes ocean currents and thermohaline circulation delivering water masses and oxygen, showing physical transport and mixing that would disperse or dilute microbes and viruses.
Combine with a map of currents to predict dispersion pathways from point sources (e.g., river mouths or sewage outfalls) to assess where viruses might travel and persist.
Explains that UV-induced degradation is much slower for plastics in the sea, indicating that the marine surface environment can reduce degradation processes compared with land.
This suggests that surfaces or particles in the ocean (e.g., plastics, organic particles) might protect attached viruses from inactivation; a student could look for virus association with marine debris.
- Explicitly states viruses may infect bacterial cells.
- Says viruses multiply when they enter a living cell, implying infection of bacterial hosts is possible.
- Explains viruses do not show molecular activity until they infect a cell, supporting the concept that viruses enter and infect cells.
- Frames viruses as dependent on host-cell processes for activity, consistent with infection of bacterial cells.
- Notes viruses reproduce only inside a host organism, reinforcing that viruses must infect living cells to replicate.
- Distinguishes viruses from other microorganisms by their requirement for a host, consistent with bacteriophage biology.
- Contains a paper title explicitly stating that algaβvirus interactions involve sequential transcriptional programs, implying infection-driven changes in transcription.
- Links single-cell observations to distinct infection states and transcriptional programs, supporting that viral infection alters host transcriptional activity.
- Reports single-cell analysis of HSV-1 that 'reveals the activation of anti-viral and developmental programs', indicating viral infection activates specific host transcriptional programs.
- Directly ties viral infection to activation of host gene expression programs at the single-cell level.
- Mentions 'sequential transcriptional programs' in the context of infection and emphasizes single-cell analyses to dissect infection variability.
- Indicates that infection progression is associated with changes in transcriptional programs across cells.
Says viruses multiply when they enter a living cell and may infect plant/animal/bacterial cells, implying viruses act inside host cells.
A student could infer that to multiply inside a cell viruses must interact with host molecular machinery (including transcription), so one could look for changes in host gene expression after infection.
Notes viruses reproduce only inside the host organism, distinguishing them from other microbes and indicating dependence on host cellular systems.
From this dependence a student might predict viruses co-opt host processes (e.g., transcription) and test host transcript levels pre- and post-infection.
States viruses show no molecular movement until they infect a cell, highlighting that their active phase is within host cells.
This suggests the active viral phase involves engaging host biochemistry; a student could examine which host biochemical pathways (including transcription) are active after viral entry.
Identifies HIV's main cellular target (helper T cells), showing viruses can specifically affect certain cell types.
Knowing viruses target specific cells, a student could compare transcriptional profiles of those target cells before and after infection to detect virus-induced changes.
Explains that cellular actions depend on chemistry of cellular components and specific proteins under control, indicating cellular behaviour is alterable by molecular changes.
A student could extend this to reason that introducing viral molecules could change cellular chemistry and thus alter transcriptional activity, motivating assays of host RNA levels after infection.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. Solvable purely by identifying extreme 'No virus can...' wording and applying basic NCERT Science (Class VIII, Ch 2) knowledge about bacteriophages.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Basic Microbiology & Ecosystems. The intersection of 'What is a virus?' (Science) and 'Where do they live?' (Environment).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: 1. Bacteriophages: Viruses that infect bacteria (linked to Ganga water purity). 2. Viral Shunt: Marine viruses kill ~20% of ocean biomass daily, recycling carbon. 3. Retroviruses: Use Reverse Transcriptase to alter host DNA (HIV). 4. Oncoviruses: Viruses that cause cancer (HPV, Hep B) by changing host gene expression. 5. Virophages: Viruses that infect other giant viruses (e.g., Sputnik).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When you see 'No [biological entity] can [basic biological function/habitat]', be skeptical. Biology is the science of exceptions. If NCERT says viruses infect 'plants, animals, or bacteria', Statement II is dead. If viruses hijack cells, Statement III is dead.
Water contaminated with pathogens, including viruses, can cause diseases such as jaundice, cholera and typhoid.
High-yield for UPSC because questions link environmental pollution to public health and policy responses; equips candidates to discuss water quality standards, disease control and sanitation measures. Connects environment with health, governance and disaster management topics.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > z. Effects on human health: > p. 75
Temperature, salinity and light availability determine which organisms can survive and persist across ocean zones.
Important for questions on marine ecology, biodiversity and fisheries policy; helps explain distributional patterns, vulnerability to climate change and ecosystem services. Enables analysis-based answers on impacts of environmental change on marine biota.
- Environment and Ecology, Majid Hussain (Access publishing 3rd ed.) > Chapter 3: MAJOR BIOMES > marine (sea/ocean) ecosystem > p. 29
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 14: Marine Organisms > Distribution r > p. 208
UV intensity and slower photo-oxidative degradation at sea affect the persistence of materials and the survivability of organisms in ocean waters.
Useful for linking physical oceanic processes to pollution fate and biological survival; aids answers on pollutant longevity, pathogen inactivation and mitigation strategies for marine pollution. Bridges physical geography with environmental pollution topics.
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 5: Environmental Pollution > 5.12.1. Plastics as a Waste Material in Marine Environment > p. 96
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 14: Marine Organisms > Distribution r > p. 208
Viruses lack cellular machinery and multiply only after entering a living cell.
High-yield for distinguishing viruses from bacteria and other microbes in biology and public health questions. Explains why antiviral strategies differ from antibacterial ones and underpins concepts of host dependence and viral replication. Useful for questions on pathogen classification, infection mechanisms, and vaccine/therapeutic approaches.
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: The Invisible Living World: Beyond Our Naked Eye > Ever heard of ... > p. 17
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Life Processes > p. 79
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: The Invisible Living World: Beyond Our Naked Eye > Snapshots > p. 24
Viruses can infect diverse hosts, explicitly including bacterial cells.
Important for understanding pathogen-host interactions and implications like bacteriophages as agents affecting bacterial populations or as potential therapeutics. Connects to microbiology, disease ecology, and applied topics such as phage therapy or microbial control.
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: The Invisible Living World: Beyond Our Naked Eye > Ever heard of ... > p. 17
Antibiotics act on bacterial cellular components and therefore do not work against viruses.
Crucial for public health and policy questions on treatment protocols, antimicrobial stewardship, and disease management. Helps answer questions differentiating bacterial vs viral infections and rational drug use.
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Health: The Ultimate Treasure > 3.5.1 Treatment of diseases > p. 39
Viruses reproduce only inside living host cells and therefore depend on host cellular machinery to carry out their life cycle.
High-yield for UPSC biology and health topics because it explains why viruses hijack host processes, underpins antiviral drug targets and vaccine strategies, and links molecular biology to disease outcomes. Mastery enables answers on replication mechanisms, therapeutic interventions, and pathogen-host interactions.
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: The Invisible Living World: Beyond Our Naked Eye > Ever heard of ... > p. 17
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: The Invisible Living World: Beyond Our Naked Eye > Snapshots > p. 24
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Life Processes > p. 79
The Viral Shunt. Since the question touched on marine viruses (Statement I), the next logical question is their function. Marine viruses lyse bacteria/algae, releasing dissolved organic matter back into the water column, preventing carbon from moving up the food chain. This is a key concept in Ocean Carbon Cycle.
The 'Biology of Exceptions' Rule. In the natural world, absolute negatives ('No virus can...') are 99% false. Life adapts to extreme heat, cold, acid, and pressure. Unless the statement violates a fundamental law of physics (e.g., 'No virus can travel faster than light'), assume there is an exception. All three statements used 'No virus can...', making them prime candidates for elimination.
One Health & AMR (GS-3). Link Statement II (viruses infecting bacteria) to 'Phage Therapy'. As antibiotic resistance rises, using bacteriophages to target specific superbugs is a major emerging biotechnology and policy theme.