Question map
In the context of recent advances in human reproductive technology, "Pronuclear Transfer" is used for
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 4: prevention of mitochondrial diseases in offspring.
Pronuclear Transfer (PT) is a form of Mitochondrial Replacement Therapy (MRT), colloquially known as "three-parent baby" technology. It is specifically designed to prevent the mother from passing on debilitating mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations to her child.
- Mechanism: In this process, the motherβs egg is fertilized with the fatherβs sperm in vitro. The resulting pronuclei (nuclear genetic material) are then removed and transferred into a donor egg that has had its own nucleus removed but retains healthy mitochondria.
- Outcome: The embryo contains the nuclear DNA of both parents (determining physical traits) but the healthy mitochondrial DNA of the donor.
- Distinction: Unlike Option 1, it is not a routine IVF procedure. Unlike Option 2, it does not involve germline modification of sperm. Unlike Option 3, it focuses on disease prevention in live births rather than stem cell research.
Thus, PT is a critical intervention for ensuring that offspring are born free of inherited mitochondrial disorders.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Science in the Headlines' question. While technically complex, the term 'Pronuclear Transfer' was synonymous with the 'Three-Parent Baby' controversy that dominated science news from 2016 to 2019. If you relied only on static biology books, this was a bouncer; if you tracked major biotech breakthroughs, it was a sitter.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: In human reproductive technology, is pronuclear transfer used to fertilize an egg in vitro using donor sperm?
- Statement 2: In human reproductive technology, is pronuclear transfer used for genetic modification of sperm-producing (spermatogenic) cells?
- Statement 3: In human reproductive technology, is pronuclear transfer used to develop stem cells into functional embryos?
- Statement 4: In human reproductive technology, is pronuclear transfer used to prevent transmission of mitochondrial diseases to offspring?
- Defines pronuclear transfer as transplantation of the nuclear genome between fertilized eggs (one from the affected woman and one donated by an unaffected woman).
- Indicates the procedure operates on already-fertilized eggs, so it is not a technique that itself fertilizes an egg using donor sperm.
- States that intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) was performed in patients who underwent pronuclear transfer, showing fertilization (by ICSI) occurs prior to the pronuclear transfer step.
- Does not describe pronuclear transfer as a method that fertilizes eggs with donor sperm; instead fertilization is a separate step (ICSI) before nuclear transfer.
States where fertilisation normally occurs in humans (sperm introduced into vagina, fertilisation in fallopian tube), establishing the basic biological sites and agents (sperm + egg) involved in conception.
A student could use this to contrast natural (in vivo) fertilisation locations with assisted techniques (in vitro) and ask whether pronuclear transfer relates to changing the location or source of gametes.
Describes the female reproductive tract and the normal journey of an egg to the oviduct where sperm encounter it and fertilisation occurs.
One can extend this to note that assisted methods must replicate or replace this meeting of gametes (e.g., IVF) and then consider whether pronuclear transfer is a step that involves donor sperm or manipulation after fertilisation.
Explains that in mammals sperm are deposited inside the female and fertilisation takes place when sperm swim towards the egg, highlighting that fertilisation is an encounter of two gametes.
A student could compare this standard gamete encounter with technologies that perform fertilisation outside the body (in vitro) and then question whether pronuclear transfer is itself the act of fertilisation or a subsequent manipulation.
Mentions freezing of sperm and eggs and biobanks for storage, showing that reproductive cells are handled and stored in assisted-reproduction contexts.
Using this, a student might infer that assisted reproductive technologies manipulate gametes/zygotes and thus investigate whether pronuclear transfer is one such manipulation involving donor gametes.
Notes that blocking the fallopian tube or vas deferens prevents sperm and egg meeting and thus fertilisation doesn't take place, reinforcing that fertilisation requires union of gametes and can be disrupted or bypassed.
A student could extend this to consider that medical interventions can redirect fertilisation (e.g., IVF) and then ask whether pronuclear transfer is an alternative method that uses donor sperm or works after fertilisation.
- Defines pronuclear transfer as a procedure performed on fertilized eggs (zygotes), not on spermatogenic cells.
- Explains the procedure transfers the nuclear genome between fertilized eggs to reduce maternal mtDNA transmission, indicating an embryo-targeted technique.
- Reports clinical use of pronuclear transfer leading to live births, showing the technique is applied at the embryo/zygote stage.
- Clinical outcomes (pregnancies and live births) indicate the intervention is on embryos rather than on sperm-producing cells.
Gives a clear definition of 'Genetically Modified Organisms' as those whose DNA has been altered in a nonβnatural way.
A student could use this definition plus basic knowledge of what pronuclear transfer targets (pronuclei/zygotes) to judge whether that procedure fits the definition when applied to germβline vs somatic cells.
States that sperm (germβcells) are produced in the testes and are specialised reproductive cells.
Combining this with the fact that pronuclear transfer typically involves pronuclei at fertilisation lets a student distinguish methods acting on spermatogenic cells (in testes) from those acting after fertilisation.
Summarises that fertilisation involves introduction of sperm into the female and that fertilisation occurs in the fallopian tube (i.e., timing/location of spermβegg fusion).
Using this plus outside knowledge that pronuclear transfer is performed around fertilisation/zygote stage helps test whether the technique would be applied to spermβproducing cells (preβfertilisation) or to the fertilised egg.
Explains that germβcells are produced by meiosis and are specialised; highlights that germβcells carry half the chromosome set.
A student could infer that modifying spermatogenic cells would alter gametes prior to meiosis/formation or require intervention in testes, distinct from a pronuclear step after meiosis and fertilisation.
Notes that reproduction involves copying DNA and separation of DNA copies during cell division.
Combine this basic rule about DNA copying with the GMO definition to consider whether intervening at the pronuclear/zygote stage (after DNA replication at fertilisation) differs from intervening in actively spermatogenic cells where DNA is undergoing meiotic divisions.
- Defines pronuclear transfer as a procedure that transplants the nuclear genome between fertilized eggs (zygotes).
- Specifies the technique is used for mitochondrial donation to allow affected women to have genetically related children, indicating a clinical use with fertilized eggs rather than with stem cells.
- Describes that patients were offered pronuclear transfer (in a clinical study context) rather than any stem-cellβto-embryo procedure.
- Reports clinical outcomes (live births) from pronuclear transfer, showing it is applied to fertilized eggs in reproductive practice, not to developing stem cells into embryos.
States that a single cell type can grow, proliferate and make other cell types under right circumstances β a general rule underlying stem-cell potency and embryo development from a single zygote.
A student could use this to reason that procedures manipulating single cells (like pronuclei or stem cells) aim to produce cells that can generate whole embryos, and then check whether pronuclear transfer is a method that preserves such totipotency.
Explains gametes carry half genetic material and their joining forms a new cell with a complete set β indirectly highlighting the role of pronuclei (male and female nuclear contributions) before genome fusion.
One could extend this to infer that techniques dealing with pronuclei manipulate the separate parental nuclear contributions prior to zygote formation, so they may be used in early embryo/embryo-like manipulations.
Describes fertilisation (sperm + egg) forming a zygote and subsequent development into an embryo, giving context for the stage at which pronuclear events occur.
A student could combine this with knowledge that pronuclei exist transiently after fertilisation to judge whether pronuclear transfer is relevant to early embryo creation or modification.
Notes that after fertilisation the zygote divides several times to form an embryo β indicating a clear pre-embryo stage where interventions could affect embryo formation.
Use this to reason that interventions at the fertilisation/pronuclear stage might influence whether a cell population becomes an embryo, and so check whether pronuclear transfer is applied at that stage to produce viable embryos or stem-cell lines.
Explains that embryos implant in the uterus and rely on maternal support to develop into a fetus, implying a distinction between embryo-like cells produced in vitro and 'functional' embryos capable of inβuterus development.
A student can extend this to question whether stem-cell-derived constructs after pronuclear manipulation would be competent for implantation and full development, prompting search for evidence on functionality vs. labβonly embryo/stem cell lines.
- Defines pronuclear transfer as a mitochondrial donation technique that transplants the nuclear genome from an affected woman's fertilized egg into an enucleated fertilized egg from an unaffected donor.
- Explicitly states pronuclear transfer offers affected women the potential to have a genetically related child with a reduced risk of mtDNA disease.
- Concludes that mitochondrial donation through pronuclear transfer is compatible with human embryo viability.
- States that an integrated program involving pronuclear transfer and PGT was effective in reducing transmission of pathogenic mtDNA variants.
- Describes mitochondrial donation techniques as options to prevent transmission of mitochondrial diseases.
- Lists pronuclear transfer among the techniques used to transfer the nuclear genome from oocytes or zygotes.
Mentions 'Embryo Transfer Technology' as a tool to improve genetic constitution and provide 'disease free germplasm' in breeding.
A student could extend this by noting that if embryo transfer is used in animals to reduce transmission of genetic disease, analogous embryo/zygote manipulations (like pronuclear transfer) might be used in humans to prevent hereditary disorders.
Describes where and when fertilisation occurs (internal fertilisation in fallopian tube) and the joining of germ-cells to form a zygote.
Knowing the timing/location of fertilisation lets a student reason that interventions at the zygote/pronuclear stage (before nuclei fuse) are technically plausible for modifying inheritance.
Explains basic heredity: sexually reproducing individuals have two copies of genes and traits are inherited, highlighting that patterns of inheritance matter for disease transmission.
A student could combine this with outside knowledge that some genetic elements (e.g., mitochondrial DNA) are inherited differently to hypothesize targeted techniques aimed at altering non-nuclear inheritance.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter for newspaper readers; Bouncer for static-only aspirants. Derived from the 'Three-Parent Baby' (Mitochondrial Replacement Therapy) news cycle.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Biotechnology > Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) > Mitochondrial Inheritance (Maternal).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize these siblings: Spindle Transfer (the alternative method), Maternal Spindle Transfer (MST), 'Three-Parent Baby' (legal in UK first), Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) vs Nuclear DNA, and the fact that mtDNA is strictly maternally inherited.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: UPSC Science questions prioritize 'Application' over 'Mechanism'. Don't memorize the step-by-step lab procedure; memorize the *problem* the technology solves (e.g., preventing mitochondrial disease) and the *ethical debate* surrounding it.
Fertilisation in humans normally occurs in the fallopian tube after sperm enter via the vaginal route.
High-yield for questions on human reproduction, causes of ectopic pregnancy, and mechanisms by which assisted reproduction may need to bypass natural sites; connects reproductive anatomy to clinical or policy issues such as infertility management and maternal health.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > What you have learnt > p. 126
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.3 (b) Female Reproductive System > p. 124
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 13: Our Home: Earth, a Unique Life Sustaining Planet > Sexual reproduction in animals > p. 223
Male germ-cells (sperms) are formed in testes and female eggs are produced by ovaries; delivery pathways determine how gametes meet.
Essential for basics of reproductive biology, questions on puberty, sex determination, contraceptive targeting, and interpreting infertility pathways; enables elimination-based MCQs about organ function and reproductive processes.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.3 (a) Male Reproductive System > p. 123
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.3 (b) Female Reproductive System > p. 124
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.3 Reproduction in Human Beings > p. 121
Blockage of vas deferens or fallopian tube prevents sperm-egg meeting and therefore prevents fertilisation.
Useful for questions on surgical contraception, infertility causes, and public-health interventions; links anatomy to clinical outcomes and policy discussions about family planning and reproductive health.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.3 (d) Reproductive Health > p. 125
Sperm are produced in the testes and delivered through the vas deferens; locating spermatogenic cells is foundational when assessing whether a procedure could target sperm formation.
High-yield for questions on human reproduction, infertility and reproductive interventions; connects anatomy to applied biotechnology and legal/ethical debates. Mastery helps answer questions that ask which tissues or stages a reproductive technique could affect.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.3 (a) Male Reproductive System > p. 123
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > What you have learnt > p. 126
Gametes carry half the genetic material as a result of meiosis, so any manipulation of pronuclei or zygotes depends on understanding haploid vs diploid genetic contributions.
Essential for conceptualizing how genetic changes propagate to offspring and for evaluating techniques that act at gamete or zygote stages; links to genetics, inheritance and biotechnology topics frequently examined in UPSC.
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 13: Our Home: Earth, a Unique Life Sustaining Planet > Special cells for reproduction > p. 221
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.1 Why the Sexual Mode of Reproduction? > p. 120
Fertilisation in humans occurs in the fallopian tube, which is where pronuclei form after gamete fusion; knowing this locates the developmental window relevant to pronuclear interventions.
Useful for questions distinguishing stages (gamete vs zygote) and procedural feasibility in reproductive technology; connects physiology to clinical and ethical considerations in assisted reproduction.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > What you have learnt > p. 126
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.3 Reproduction in Human Beings > p. 122
Meiosis creates specialised haploid germ-cells that combine to form a zygote; understanding gamete nuclear content is essential when considering any manipulation of nuclei.
High-yield for UPSC because questions often test basics of sexual reproduction and chromosome number restoration. Connects to genetics, developmental biology and assisted reproductive techniques; mastering it helps answer questions on gamete manipulation, inheritance and developmental outcomes.
- Science , class X (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: How do Organisms Reproduce? > 7.3.1 Why the Sexual Mode of Reproduction? > p. 120
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 13: Our Home: Earth, a Unique Life Sustaining Planet > Special cells for reproduction > p. 221
The 'Spindle Transfer' technique. It is the direct alternative to Pronuclear Transfer but is performed *before* fertilization (on the unfertilized egg), whereas Pronuclear Transfer happens *after* fertilization (on the zygote). UPSC loves swapping these timelines in statements.
Etymological Logic: 'Pronuclear Transfer' means moving the nucleus. If you move the nucleus to a new cell, you are leaving behind the old cell's 'body' (cytoplasm). Biology basics tell you that Mitochondria live in the cytoplasm, not the nucleus. Therefore, moving the nucleus is a way to escape bad cytoplasm (Mitochondria). Option D is the only one dealing with non-nuclear components.
Connect this to GS-4 (Ethics) and GS-2 (Governance): The debate on 'Designer Babies' and Germline Editing. Does curing a disease justify altering the human gene pool permanently? This links to the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill and bioethics committees.