Question map
With reference to 'Changpa' community of India, consider the following statements : 1. They live mainly in the State of Uttarakhand. 2. They rear the Pashmina goats that yield a fine wool. 3. They are kept in the category of Scheduled Tribes. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Explanation
**Explanation:**
Statement 1 is incorrect. The Changpa are listed under the Scheduled Tribe category[2] from Jammu Kashmir, not Uttarakhand. They are a nomadic community living in the Changthang region of Greater Ladakh[3].
Statement 2 is correct. Changthangi goats are reared by the Changpa community, and the breed is mostly reared for its hair to make pashmina[3]. These goats provide pashmina wool, apart from hide, meat and milk[4].
Statement 3 is correct. The Changpa are listed under the ST (Scheduled Tribe)[1]category from Jammu Kashmir.
Therefore, statements 2 and 3 are correct, making option B the right answer.
Sources- [3] https://rln.org.in/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Pastoral-Breeds-Book.pdf
- [4] https://rln.org.in/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Pastoral-Breeds-Book.pdf
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question is a classic 'Eco-Cultural' triad: Community + Habitat + Unique Product. While standard books list tribes, they often miss the specific economic linkage (Pashmina). The question rewards those who link 'Luxury Commodities' (Pashmina) to their 'Human Geography' origins (Changpa/Ladakh) rather than rote memorizing tribal lists.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Directly states the claim that the Changpa live mainly in Uttarakhand.
- This passage provides an explicit (though standalone) assertion matching the statement.
- Cites the Tribal Ministry list placing Changpa under Scheduled Tribes from Jammu & Kashmir.
- Explicitly concludes that the statement claiming they live mainly in Uttarakhand is wrong.
- Links Changpa pastoralist nomads and their Changra/Changra goat pashmina production with Ladakh.
- Associates Changpa activity with Ladakh (not Uttarakhand), supporting the view they do not mainly live in Uttarakhand.
Lists northern states (Jammu & Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, etc.) where Indo‑Aryan tribes are presently found, indicating tribal/ethnic groups are distributed across multiple Himalayan states.
A student could compare the known high‑altitude tribal groups (like Changpa if remembered as trans‑Himalayan pastoralists) against this list to judge whether Uttarakhand is a primary location or one of several possible states.
Describes Uttarakhand as a state that touches the India–China (Tibet) middle sector along a Himalayan watershed, implying it includes high mountain border areas.
One could use a map of Changpa habitat (usually in trans‑Himalayan border zones) and check whether those areas fall within Uttarakhand's Himalayan border described here.
Notes seasonal migration patterns to mountain states (Jammu & Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Sikkim), suggesting pastoral or seasonal high‑altitude use of these states.
If Changpa are a pastoral/seasonally mobile group, this pattern suggests they might be present in several Himalayan states; a student could investigate which specific states host such pastoral migration.
Gives an example of a tribal community (Tharus) concentrated in parts of Uttarakhand and neighboring Uttar Pradesh, showing tribes can be regionally concentrated within specific tehsils/districts.
A student could use this example to reason that being a tribal group does not guarantee statewide predominance—one should check district/tehsil level distribution for Changpa rather than assume Uttarakhand-wide majority.
States that scheduled tribes are mainly concentrated in rural and specific ecological areas across states, implying tribal populations are spatially non‑uniform.
A student could combine this rule with knowledge of Changpa ecology (if known as trans‑Himalayan/pastoral) to narrow likely states that contain appropriate rural high‑altitude habitats, rather than assuming Uttarakhand alone.
- Explicitly names the Changpa as the community rearing Changthangi goats in Changthang (Greater Ladakh).
- States the breed is mostly reared for its hair to make pashmina, directly linking the goats to pashmina fibre production.
- States that Changthang (Changthang/Changthangi) goats provide pashmina wool among other products.
- Describes the Changpa as nomads who herd these goats, tying the community to pashmina production.
- Specifically states that rearing of Pashmina goats is a practice of the Changpa community.
- Links pashmina goat rearing to the community's economy (high income wool), confirming purpose and value of the fibre.
Explicitly names an Indian goat breed (Angora or Himachali / Gaddi/Chamba) that 'provides soft Pashmina (wool)' and links Pashmina production to Indian mountain regions including Jammu & Kashmir.
A student could combine this with basic geography (J&K/Ladakh are high-altitude pastoral regions) and the known association of mountain pastoralists with fine-wool goats to suspect Changpa involvement in Pashmina rearing.
States that some wool is derived from Cashmere goats (distinctly named among animals producing fine wool).
Knowing that 'Pashmina' is a form of Cashmere and that Changthangi is a high-altitude Cashmere breed, a student could use this to link Cashmere-producing goats to communities in cold upland regions like where Changpa live.
Describes nomadic herding in temperate/steppe upland regions where herders obtained wool from goats and sheep—showing a general pattern that upland/nomadic pastoralists produce wool.
Combine this pattern with a map showing the Changpa as high-altitude pastoralists to infer they may rear wool-producing goats adapted to cold steppe conditions.
Notes wool is highly desired in colder/upland regions and that sheep/goat rearing is common in less-favoured highland areas, implying fine-wool animals are favored in cold climates.
A student could use the climatic requirement for fine-wool breeds (cold uplands) plus knowledge that Changpa inhabit cold highlands to plausibly link them with rearing fine-wool goats.
Explains India has a broad spectrum of native goat breeds and that introduction of exotic breeds has occurred—highlighting India's livestock diversity including regional/indigenous goats.
A learner could use this to argue that a region-specific breed like Changthangi (a native highland goat) is plausible within India's documented livestock diversity and regional specialization.
- Explicitly states that the Tribal Ministry lists Changpa under the Scheduled Tribe (ST) category.
- Directly ties the Changpa community to the ST classification and specifies the region (Jammu & Kashmir).
- Describes the Changpa as a distinct pastoral community (Changpa) and their traditional lifestyle in Changthang.
- Provides contextual evidence about the community referenced in the classification source.
Defines Scheduled Tribes as 'Adivasis' who led a secluded life usually in hills and forests, linking ST status to isolation and traditional habitat.
A student could compare the Changpa's known habitat (high‑altitude, secluded trans‑Himalayan pastoral areas) with this habitat criterion and then check state/ST schedules for communities from those areas.
Describes common social/cultural characteristics of Scheduled Tribes (living in areas of isolation, distinct socio‑economic norms, village headman institution).
Use these characteristics to see if Changpa social organization and isolation fit the pattern, and then inspect official lists for tribal communities in the relevant union territory/state.
States that the Government has included 427 communities as Scheduled Tribes and refers to an official schedule/list of included communities.
A student could consult that official list (Eighth Schedule reference in the snippet) or Gazette notifications for the 427 communities to verify whether 'Changpa' appears.
Notes that the number and composition of Scheduled Tribes have changed over time and that many ethnic groups have applied to be included.
This suggests checking both historical and recent lists/notifications because Changpa might have been added or considered for inclusion; consult updated government publications or census appendices.
Mentions that there are 'main tribes' listed in sources, implying published enumerations of prominent tribal groups.
A student could look up such lists (e.g., statewise/central compilations of main tribes) to see whether Changpa feature among tribes of northern Himalayan regions.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter if you know Pashmina geography; Trap if you confuse Himalayan states. Source: Current Affairs (DownToEarth/The Hindu) on Pashmina growers' hardships.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Human Geography > Transhumance & Pastoral Tribes of the Himalayas.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize these Pastoral/Transhumant pairings: (1) Gaddis & Gujjars (Himachal - Sheep/Goats), (2) Bakarwals (J&K - Goats/Sheep, Pir Panjal), (3) Bhotias (Uttarakhand - Trade/Sheep), (4) Monpas (Arunachal - Yaks/Sheep), (5) Maldharis (Gujarat - Cattle/Buffalo), (6) Todas (Nilgiris - Buffalo).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Do not study tribes in isolation. Always tag them with: (1) State, (2) PVTG Status (Yes/No), and (3) Key Livelihood (e.g., Pashmina, Honey, Shifting Cultivation). The livelihood often dictates the geography.
To judge whether a specific tribal community (e.g., Changpa) is concentrated in a particular state, one must understand overall patterns of scheduled-tribe distribution shown in the references.
High-yield for both prelims and mains: questions often ask about state-wise tribal distributions and demographic patterns. Connects demography, cultural geography and policy (reservations/programmes). Best prepared by studying census-backed maps and state-wise tribal lists to link tribes to ecological/physiographic zones.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > Source: Census of India, 2001. > p. 22
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > Geographical Distribution > p. 38
Reference evidence shows some tribes (e.g., Tharu) have clear concentrations in Uttarakhand, illustrating how some communities are state-centric while others may not be.
Useful for answering state-tribe matching questions: knowing representative tribes and their key districts enables elimination-style reasoning in objective tests and richer answers in mains. Prepare by memorizing major tribes and their district-level concentrations and studying livelihood/ecology links.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > The Tharus > p. 36
Understanding Uttarakhand's creation and Himalayan physiographic context helps assess whether cold‑climate high‑plateau pastoral communities (like Changpa) are likely to be based there or elsewhere.
Bridges political geography (state formation) and physical geography (Himalayan zones) — frequently tested nexus in GS papers. Learn by mapping state boundaries, dates of reorganization, and matching physiographic regions with ethnic/livelihood patterns.
- Introduction to the Constitution of India, D. D. Basu (26th ed.). > Chapter 14: The State Legislature > Chhattisgarh > p. 294
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > The Middle Sector > p. 33
References identify Pashmina (soft wool) as produced by specific goat breeds (e.g., Cashmere/Angora/Himachali).
High-yield for UPSC: questions often ask which animal products come from which breeds and regions (e.g., Pashmina from Cashmere-type goats). Master this to answer mapping and resource questions; learn breed → product pairs and their economic significance. Prepare by tabulating major fibre types (Pashmina/Cashmere, mohair, etc.) with source species and uses.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 7: Resources > Goat Rearing > p. 36
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 26: Agriculture > Generrl > p. 258
Evidence links certain goat breeds (Angora/Himachali) and Pashmina production to Himalayan states such as Himachal Pradesh and Jammu & Kashmir.
Useful for geography and economy questions that ask state-wise specialization in livestock. Connects to topics on rural livelihoods and state-level resources; typical question patterns include map/state–product matches and short notes. Prepare by memorising key breeds and the states where they are concentrated, and understanding livelihood linkages.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 7: Resources > Goat Rearing > p. 36
- Environment, Shankar IAS Acedemy .(ed 10th) > Chapter 9: Indian Biodiversity Diverse Landscape > 9.3.4. Livestock genetic diversity > p. 158
References discuss mountain pastoralists, seasonal movements, and nomadic herding as the context in which sheep/goat wool production occurs.
Frequently tested in both history (pastoral communities) and geography (livestock systems, adaptation to climate). Helps answer questions on mobility, resource use, and socio-economic patterns of mountain communities. Prepare by comparing mountain pastoralism with plateau/desert pastoralism and noting implications for animal husbandry.
- India and the Contemporary World - I. History-Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: Pastoralists in the Modern World > New words > p. 101
- Certificate Physical and Human Geography , GC Leong (Oxford University press 3rd ed.) > Chapter 20: The Temperate Continental (Steppe) Climate > Economic Development > p. 192
Determining whether a specific community (e.g., Changpa) is a Scheduled Tribe requires knowing the typical features used to classify STs; the references describe who Adivasis/Scheduled Tribes are.
High-yield for UPSC: questions often ask about categories of disadvantaged groups, their socio-cultural traits, and implications for policy. Mastering this helps answer whether a community fits the criteria for ST status and links to welfare/reservation policy and tribal development programmes. Prepare by studying constitutional definitions and social characteristics, and practice applying criteria to case communities.
- Democratic Politics-II. Political Science-Class X . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Gender, Religion and Caste > Social and Religious Diversity of India > p. 39
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > Geographical Bases of India Federalism > p. 9
- Contemporary World Politics, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 6: Environment and Natural Resources > Spoonful of Ecology > p. 97
The 'Chiru' (Tibetan Antelope) vs 'Changthangi Goat'. While Changpas rear goats for Pashmina (Legal), the Chiru is hunted for 'Shahtoosh' wool (Illegal/Banned). UPSC often swaps these animals to create a trap statement.
Use the 'Product-Place Association' hack. 'Pashmina' is historically and globally synonymous with 'Cashmere' (Kashmir/Ladakh). Statement 1 places the community in Uttarakhand. Statement 2 links them to Pashmina. These two are geographically dissonant. If Pashmina = Ladakh/Kashmir, then 'Mainly Uttarakhand' is false. Eliminate 1 -> Answer derived.
Link to Economy (GI Tags) & Environment. 'Kashmir Pashmina' has a GI tag. The survival of the Changpa lifestyle is now a major Environmental issue due to climate change melting glaciers in Ladakh, forcing migration (Climate Refugees).