Question map
With reference to Manipuri Sankirtana, consider the following statements : 1. It is a song and dance performance. 2. Cymbals are the only musical instruments used in the performance. 3. It is performed to narrate the life and deeds of Lord Krishna. Which of the statements given above is/are correct ?
Explanation
The correct answer is option B (statements 1 and 3 only).
Manipuri Sankirtana is a performing art form involving ritual singing, drumming and dancing performed in temples and domestic spaces in Manipur[1], confirming that statement 1 is correct as it combines both song and dance.
Statement 2 is incorrect because cymbals are not the only instruments used. Instruments used in Manipuri dance performances include the pung (barrel drum), pena (bowed string instrument), kartal (small cymbals), and flute[2]. Other common instruments are the harmonium, pena, bansuri, shankh (conch), and esraj[3]. Thus, multiple instruments accompany the performance, not just cymbals.
Statement 3 is correct as Sankirtana practices centre on the temple, where performers narrate the lives and deeds of Krishna through song and dance[4]. The performances are specifically dedicated to depicting stories of Lord Krishna.
Therefore, only statements 1 and 3 are correct, making option B the right answer.
Sources- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meitei_Sankirtana
- [2] https://www.britannica.com/art/manipuri
- [4] https://ich.unesco.org/en/RL/sankirtana-ritual-singing-drumming-and-dancing-of-manipur-00843
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question is a classic 'UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage' pick. While Sankirtana was inscribed in 2013, UPSC cycles through this list frequently. The phrasing is lifted directly from the UNESCO citation ('Ritual singing, drumming and dancing'). If you memorize the UNESCO list, you must read the 3-line official description for each entry.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Explicitly describes Meitei/Manipuri Sankirtana as a performing art that involves multiple performance modes together.
- Specifically lists 'ritual singing' and 'dancing' as components performed in its practice.
- Mentions the UNESCO inscription that names the element using the exact combined terms.
- Labels the practice with the phrase linking singing and dancing together as part of the tradition.
- The UNESCO page title for the element uses 'ritual singing, drumming and dancing', confirming the combined nature of the practice.
- An official heritage entry framing Sankirtana with both singing and dancing.
Describes a bhakti leader (Chaitanya) who popularised group devotional singing accompanied by ecstatic dancing — a model where singing and dancing are combined in religious performance.
A student could note this bhakti pattern (combined singing+dancing) and check whether Manipuri Sankirtana, as a bhakti/ritual performance from the northeast, follows the same combined pattern.
Reports that temples appointed singers, percussionists, musicians and dance masters, implying religious performances often integrated song, music and dance.
Use this rule that temple ritual arts fuse music and dance to investigate if Manipuri Sankirtana, linked to temple/bhakti contexts, similarly combines both elements.
Provides an example where female singers 'sing before him and dance until dusk', showing in practice that performers both sing and dance in the same event.
A student can generalise from such market/religious performance examples to hypothesise Manipuri Sankirtana may also be a combined singing+dancing performance and then verify with region-specific sources.
Notes that temple choreography originated in folk dancing and that trained dancers were maintained by temples, indicating a tradition where narrative/religious themes are rendered through dance together with music.
Apply this pattern of temple-sponsored dance+music to test whether Manipuri Sankirtana, if performed in temple/bhakti contexts, uses both song and dance together.
Literary example (Silappadikaram) records people 'singing and dancing' together when honouring a visitor, showing longstanding cultural pairing of song and dance in ritual/social events.
A student might use this general cultural pattern of joint singing+dancing to consider whether a named regional ritual (Manipuri Sankirtana) fits that broader practice and seek confirmation.
- Explicitly lists multiple instruments used in Manipuri performances, not just cymbals.
- Names pung (drum), pena (bowed string), kartal (small cymbals), and flute, showing cymbals are one of several instruments.
- States that dances are based on cymbals and the pung, indicating multiple core instruments.
- Also lists other common instruments (harmonium, pena, bansuri, shankh, esraj), further showing cymbals are not the only instruments.
- Specifically names the Pung (mridanga) alongside the Kartal (pair of cymbals) as instruments accompanying Nata Sankirtana.
- Shows that cymbals are used together with at least one other instrument (pung) in the Sankirtana tradition.
States that temples had dancers, musicians and players of musical instruments as part of temple paraphernalia, implying ritual/temple performances commonly involve multiple instruments.
A student could check whether Manipuri Sankirtana, being a ritual performance, follows the common temple pattern of using more than one instrument.
Notes that traditional dance items are portrayed with musical instruments in temple sculpture/painting, suggesting multi-instrument accompaniment for ritual/dance forms.
Compare visual/ethnographic records of Manipuri Sankirtana to see if multiple instruments are depicted or mentioned.
Mentions a variety of named instruments (lute, flute, drum) in Late Vedic musical references, showing historical precedent for ensembles of different instruments in Indian music.
Use general knowledge of Indian musical ensembles to hypothesize that a regional ritual like Sankirtana likely employs several instrument types, then verify with sources on Manipur.
Describes syncretic musical practice (Sufi Sama) and the introduction/use of distinct instruments (Rabab, Sarangi), illustrating that religious/ritual musical traditions often include varied instruments.
Analogize from other Indian ritual traditions that use multiple instruments and investigate whether Manipuri Sankirtana shows similar diversity.
Lists woods used for making musical instruments, implicitly indicating a practical material basis for producing many kinds of instruments in India.
A student could use this to reason that regions with instrument-making materials commonly support a range of instruments for rituals like Sankirtana and then look for regional instrument lists.
- Official UNESCO description of Manipuri Sankirtana.
- Explicitly states performers narrate Krishna's lives and deeds through song and dance.
- Encyclopedic description of Meitei/Manipuri Sankirtana.
- Directly says the core practice narrates the lives and deeds of the Lord in temple performances.
- Detailed article on Meitei/Manipuri Sankirtana.
- States performers narrate the many stories of Krishna during performances.
Shows a pattern in Bhakti literature where poets (Sur Das) composed songs/poems specifically about Krishna's bal-lila and devotion to Krishna.
A student could infer that regional devotional performance forms (like Sankirtana) often take Krishna's lila as subject and check whether Manipuri devotional genres follow this similar pattern.
Describes Chaitanya's Vaishnava movement as explicitly centred on exalting Krishna, indicating Bhakti movements produced practices focused on Krishna worship and celebration.
A student could generalize that Vaishnava ritual-performance traditions (especially those influenced by Chaitanya) narrate Krishna; then investigate whether Manipuri Sankirtana is part of a Vaishnava practice in the region.
Notes that Azhwars composed hymns where themes are mostly Krishna's childhood, showing a devotional pattern of narrating Krishna's life in sung hymns.
A student could extend this pattern to hypothesize that other regional sung/ritual traditions (Sankirtana) might similarly narrate Krishna's deeds and then verify with sources on Manipuri ritual forms.
Provides an example of regional devotional culture (Mirabai and a Tamil sculpture) portraying Krishna as focal deity and subject of songs and imagery.
Use the example to support the idea that Indian devotional arts frequently depict Krishna; thus check whether Manipuri performing arts include such Krishna-focused narratives.
Mentions sculptural panels depicting village life with cows and cowherds (Krishna-related imagery), illustrating a broader artistic tendency to depict Krishna's pastoral episodes.
A student might infer that performing traditions tied to temple/folk arts (like Sankirtana) could adopt similar pastoral/Krishna themes and then look for ethnographic or liturgical descriptions of Manipuri Sankirtana.
- [THE VERDICT]: Moderate. A 'Sitter' if you prepared the UNESCO ICH list thoroughly; a 'Trap' if you relied on general knowledge and fell for the 'only cymbals' extreme statement.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: The 'UNESCO Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity'. Every entry on this list is a potential question.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the 'Trinity' (Region + Deity + Key Prop) for other ICH entries: 1. Ramman (Uttarakhand, Bhumiyal Devta, Masks); 2. Mudiyettu (Kerala, Kali vs Darika, Floor drawing); 3. Kalbelia (Rajasthan, Snake charmer community, Poongi); 4. Kutiyattam (Kerala, Sanskrit theatre, Mizhavu drum); 5. Chhau (East India, Martial/Masks).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Do not just memorize the name of the art form. You must profile it: Is it dance, theatre, or song? Which deity is central? What is the primary instrument? The UNESCO website's 'Description' tab is the exact source of these statements.
Several references describe devotional contexts where group singing is explicitly accompanied by ecstatic or sustained dancing, indicating a recurrent pattern of combined musical and physical devotional expression.
High-yield for culture/Bhakti-Sufi questions: helps answer questions about forms of devotional expression, regional variants, and performance features. Connects Bhakti movements, Sufi sama', and public devotional practices; useful for comparative questions on ritual forms. Prepare by noting defining features (group singing, ecstatic movement) and region-specific examples from sources.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Syncretism: Bhakti Movement in India > Chaitanya (1485-1533) > p. 194
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART II, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Through the Eyes of Travellers > Music in the market > p. 128
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART I, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 2: Kings, Farmers and Towns > The Pandya chief Senguttuvan visits the forest > p. 36
References show temples maintaining trained dancers and appointing musicians and singers, indicating formal, institutional settings where music and dance are combined as part of ritual life.
Important for questions on state/societal support for arts and continuity of traditions; links cultural history with political patronage and social institutions. Master by compiling examples of temple roles, patronage patterns, and how they preserved performance traditions.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > Bhakti and the Arts > p. 130
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 11: Later Cholas and Pandyas > Religion > p. 162
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 11: Later Cholas and Pandyas > Brihadishvarar Temple > p. 163
Evidence shows singing-and-dancing occurring in bazaars, festivals and communal celebrations, illustrating that combined performance appears in both sacred and secular contexts.
Useful for answering questions about social functions of performance, cultural diffusion, and everyday religiosity; helps frame essays/answers about how devotional forms permeate public life. Prepare by noting examples and contrasts between market/festival and temple settings.
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART II, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 5: Through the Eyes of Travellers > Music in the market > p. 128
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > The Nagas > p. 36
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART I, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 2: Kings, Farmers and Towns > The Pandya chief Senguttuvan visits the forest > p. 36
The provided references list multiple instruments (lute, flute, drum, etc.), implying Indian musical practices commonly use a variety of instruments rather than a single one.
Questions on cultural practices often test recognition of diversity within traditions. Mastering this concept helps aspirants avoid overgeneralisation (e.g., 'only one instrument used') and enables comparison across regional forms. Prepare by cataloguing instrument types mentioned across sources and linking them to specific regional practices.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 2: Early India: The Chalcolithic, Megalithic, Iron Age and Vedic Cultures > Other aspects of Life > p. 31
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 10: Advent of Arabs and Turks > Music and Dance > p. 152
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 15: The Marathas > Serfoji II > p. 239
References note instruments introduced through cultural contacts (Rabab, Sarangi, clarinet, violin), showing tradition evolution by incorporating new instruments.
UPSC often asks about cultural syncretism and adaptation. Understanding how external influences change performance ensembles is high-yield for questions on cultural change, continuity and exchange. Study examples of instrument diffusion and the historical contexts that brought them.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 10: Advent of Arabs and Turks > Music and Dance > p. 152
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 15: The Marathas > Serfoji II > p. 239
Evidence cites temples and courts as sites with musicians, dancers and players of musical instruments, indicating institutional patronage shapes instrument use.
Institutional patronage is a frequent UPSC theme linking art forms to political and social history. Knowing the role of temples/courts helps answer questions on preservation, sponsorship and documentation of musical forms. Revise temple/court roles and examples where musical ensembles are recorded in inscriptions and art.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 11: Later Cholas and Pandyas > Builders of Temples > p. 162
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 11: Later Cholas and Pandyas > Brihadishvarar Temple > p. 163
Multiple references show poets and bhakti leaders centring their compositions on Krishna (e.g., Sur Das, Chaitanya, Azhwars), which is directly relevant to any claim about performances narrating Krishna's life.
High-yield for UPSC cultural history questions: understanding that Krishna was a dominant devotional theme helps explain regional bhakti expressions and literary/performative traditions. Links Bhakti movement, devotional poetry, and temple arts; learn by mapping key poets, regions, and themes.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Syncretism: Bhakti Movement in India > Sur Das > p. 195
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Syncretism: Bhakti Movement in India > Chaitanya (1485-1533) > p. 194
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > Azhwars > p. 130
The 'Lai Haraoba' festival. While Sankirtana is Vaishnavite (Krishna), Lai Haraoba is the pre-Hindu animistic ritual of Manipur honoring 'Umang Lai' (forest deities). UPSC loves contrasting the 'Sanskritized' tradition (Sankirtana) with the 'Indigenous' tradition (Lai Haraoba).
Apply the 'Rhythm Heuristic'. Statement 2 says 'Cymbals are the ONLY musical instruments.' In Indian performing arts (especially dance), a percussion instrument (drum) is essential for keeping the beat (Tala). A dance without a drum is extremely rare. The 'Pung' (drum) is the soul of Manipuri dance. 'Only' + 'Missing Drum' = 100% False. Eliminate 2 -> Answer is B.
History (Bhakti Movement): Manipuri Sankirtana is a direct result of the 'Gaudiya Vaishnavism' movement led by Chaitanya Mahaprabhu spreading to the Northeast in the 15th-18th centuries. This links a Culture fact to the Medieval History timeline.