Question map
Consider the following in respect of Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS) : 1. Inaugural IONS was held in India in 2015 under the chairmanship of the Indian Navy. 2. IONS is a voluntary initiative that seeks to increase maritime co-operation among navies of the littoral states of the Indian Ocean Region. Which of the above statements is/are correct ?
Explanation
The correct answer is option B because only statement 2 is correct.
The inaugural Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS) was held in New Delhi on 14 February 2008[3], not in 2015 as stated in statement 1. Therefore, statement 1 is incorrect.
IONS was launched by the Indian Navy[3], and it is a voluntary initiative that seeks to increase maritime co-operation among navies of the littoral states of the Indian Ocean Region by providing an open and inclusive forum for discussion of regionally relevant maritime issues[4]. This confirms that statement 2 is entirely correct.
Since only statement 2 is accurate while statement 1 contains a factual error regarding the year (2008 vs 2015), the correct answer is option B - "2 only."
Sources- [1] https://cimsec.org/criticality-ions-maritime-security-construct/
- [2] https://cimsec.org/criticality-ions-maritime-security-construct/
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Genesis Trap.' IONS was in the news around 2016/17, but UPSC ignored the current event and asked about its birth (2008). Standard books fail here; this requires a 'Background Check' habit for every organization mentioned in Current Affairs.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Was the inaugural meeting of the Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS) held in India in 2015?
- Statement 2: Was the inaugural Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS) chaired by the Indian Navy?
- Statement 3: Is the Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS) a voluntary initiative?
- Statement 4: Does the Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS) seek to increase maritime cooperation among the navies of the littoral states of the Indian Ocean Region?
- Explicitly names an inauguration of IONS in New Delhi with a date, showing the event took place in India.
- Provides the year 2008 for the IONS seminar inauguration, contradicting the 2015 date in the statement.
- States that the Indian Navy assembled Chiefs-of-Navy in New Delhi and that the chiefs launched the Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS).
- Indicates the launch/launching event occurred in New Delhi, supporting that the inaugural meeting was held in India (and earlier than 2015).
Gives a specific example that conferences of Indian Ocean littoral states have been held long before 2015 (e.g., first conference at Cairo in 1964).
A student could use this pattern to infer that multilateral Indian Ocean forums have earlier origins and so should check IONS founding date against earlier conference history.
Shows India had established major regional maritime/Indian Ocean institutions (e.g., tsunami warning centre in 2007) well before 2015.
One might extend this to expect India’s involvement in regional naval forums earlier than 2015 and therefore verify whether IONS began before or after such institutions.
Describes India’s significant geopolitical role and cooperative programmes with littoral states of the Indian Ocean.
A student could use India’s longstanding regional engagement as a reason to check records of multilateral naval initiatives (like IONS) across a broader multi-year timeline, not just 2015.
Emphasises India’s central geographical and strategic position in the Indian Ocean, implying India is a likely host/participant but not proving timing.
Combine this with external timelines (e.g., list of IONS meetings) to judge whether India hosted the inaugural meeting or hosted at a later date.
Notes historical naval presences and foreign bases in the Indian Ocean region, indicating longstanding naval activity in the area.
Use this to motivate checking when formal regional naval dialogue forums like IONS were initiated relative to prior naval activity.
- Explicitly states that IONS was launched by the Indian Navy.
- Specifies the launch date and location (14 February 2008, New Delhi), indicating Indian Navy leadership/hosting of the inaugural event.
- Describes the Indian Navy assembling Chiefs-of-Navy in New Delhi and launching the Indian Ocean Naval Symposium.
- Implies the inaugural initiative was led/initiated by the Indian Navy through its convening role.
States India 'occupies an important geographical position in the central arc of the Indian Ocean' and has 'significant economic and technical co-operation programmes in the littoral states'.
A student could reason that a country with central geographic position and active cooperation programmes is likely to lead or chair regional maritime initiatives, so they should check records of initial IONS leadership for Indian chairing.
Describes India setting up regional ocean initiatives (DOARS, National Tsunami Early Warning Centre) and plans for networking with neighbouring Indian Ocean states.
From India initiating regional maritime/technical cooperation, a student might infer India had the institutional capability and precedent to chair multilateral Indian Ocean forums and should verify whether IONS followed that pattern.
Records direct deployment of Indian naval forces in the region (Maldives 1988), showing India exercises operational naval leadership in the Indian Ocean littoral.
Operational naval leadership suggests the Indian Navy could plausibly have been chosen to chair a regional naval symposium; a student could use this pattern to prioritize checking Indian Navy involvement in IONS' inception.
Notes presence of multiple foreign naval powers in the Indian Ocean, implying regional naval forums might be chaired by a prominent littoral navy as a counterbalance.
Given foreign naval presence, a student could reason organizers might select a strong regional navy (e.g., India) to chair inaugural talks and should compare lists of chairs to test the statement.
Mentions historical conferences of heads of littoral states (first held in Cairo 1964), indicating a pattern of multilateral Indian Ocean meetings among regional states.
Recognizing the precedent of region-wide conferences, a student could look up procedural norms from earlier forums (who chaired/hosted) to assess whether the Indian Navy being inaugural chair of IONS fits those precedents.
- Explicitly labels IONS as a "voluntary initiative" in describing its purpose.
- Directly links the voluntary nature to increasing maritime cooperation among navies, matching the statement.
- Clearly states IONS "is a voluntary initiative" and defines its scope (littoral states of the Indian Ocean Region).
- Provides additional context that it is an open and inclusive forum, reinforcing the voluntary, cooperative character.
Mentions littoral states seeking to 'impose voluntary restrictions' and to curb super-power rivalry — indicates regional maritime arrangements can be framed as voluntary measures.
A student could infer that regional maritime forums (like a naval symposium) might likewise be voluntary and check IONS's charter or membership rules for voluntary participation.
Records a conference of Heads of littoral states (1964) and Non-Aligned call to make the ocean a 'zone of peace' — shows precedent for informal/collective regional initiatives among Indian Ocean states.
One could compare IONS to these historical, state-led conferences to assess whether it follows the same non-binding, cooperative pattern.
Notes 47 littoral countries and their common desire for the ocean to remain a 'zone of peace' amid great-power rivalry — implies multilateral, interest-based cooperation rather than forced membership.
A student can use this to reason that naval cooperation mechanisms in the region are likely membership-based and voluntary, then verify IONS membership lists and participation rules.
Describes India's economic and technical co-operation programmes with littoral states — example of voluntary, cooperative regional engagement by states around the Indian Ocean.
Use this pattern of voluntary bilateral/multilateral cooperation to hypothesize IONS is similarly a cooperative, voluntary forum and then check official IONS documentation.
Lists 'Member countries' and 'Outreach countries' for a regional aquatic mission, illustrating that regional initiatives often have voluntary membership and outreach categories.
A student could analogize that IONS might also have a voluntary/member structure and verify by examining its membership/outreach criteria.
- Explicitly defines IONS as a voluntary initiative with the stated aim of increasing maritime co-operation.
- Specifies the target group: navies of the littoral states of the Indian Ocean Region.
- Repeats that IONS operates "amongst navies of the littoral states of the Indian Ocean Region."
- Describes IONS' purpose to provide a forum and to achieve mutually beneficial maritime security outcomes through member cooperation.
- Directly states IONS is a voluntary initiative that seeks to increase maritime cooperation.
- Specifically references cooperation among navies, aligning with the claim's focus.
Identifies the existence of 47 littoral states and emphasises their concern about security and desire for the Indian Ocean to remain a 'zone of peace', implying a need for cooperative security arrangements.
A student could extend this by checking whether regional security initiatives (like IONS) are logical mechanisms these littoral states would adopt to realise a 'zone of peace'.
Notes historical conferences of heads of littoral states (e.g., Cairo 1964) calling for cooperative identification of the ocean as a zone of peace — showing a pattern of multilateral, littoral-state cooperation initiatives.
A student might infer that later, more specialised forums (naval symposia) could follow this pattern and then check IONS' stated aims to confirm.
Mentions regional organisations (ASEAN, SAARC, Indian Ocean Rim Association) as vehicles to foster regional economic and technical cooperation and to address maritime threats like piracy.
One could reasonably look for similar organisational responses focused specifically on naval cooperation (e.g., a naval symposium) to tackle maritime security challenges.
States a general need to bring economic cooperation among littoral states and advocates formation of regional organisations such as an 'Indian Ocean Community'.
A student could generalise that littoral states favour regional institutions, so checking whether a naval symposium exists to foster cooperation among navies is a plausible next step.
Highlights India's active economic and technical cooperation programmes with littoral states, indicating a precedent of bilateral/multilateral engagement in the region.
Use this pattern to hypothesise that maritime/naval cooperation forums fit within existing regional cooperation practices and then verify IONS' remit.
- [THE VERDICT]: Trap (Date Swap). Statement 1 claims 2015; the actual founding was 2008. This is a factual error designed to catch those who only read recent headlines.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Indian Ocean Geopolitics & Regional Maritime Security Architectures.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize the 'Birth Certificates' of IOR bodies: IORA (1997, Mauritius), MILAN (1995, Port Blair), Indian Ocean Commission (1982, Port Louis), Colombo Security Conclave (2011), SAGAR (2015).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When an organization appears in news, do not stop at 'PM attended summit.' Open its 'About Us' page. Extract: 1. Founding Year, 2. First Host, 3. Binding vs. Voluntary nature.
Reference [1] records early multilateral conferences of littoral states and the 1970 call to identify the Indian Ocean as a 'zone of peace', which is directly relevant to understanding regional maritime dialogues and inaugural conference traditions.
High-yield for UPSC: explains historical precedents for regional maritime forums and diplomatic initiatives; connects to Non-Aligned Movement and maritime diplomacy topics. Mastering this helps answer questions on the evolution of regional cooperation and policy language used in Indian Ocean fora.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > Response of the Bordering Countries > p. 73
References [4] and [6] emphasize India's central geographic and strategic importance in the Indian Ocean, a key factor in hosting or participating in regional naval/strategic meetings.
High-yield: frequently tested in geography, international relations, and security topics; links to energy routes, 'Oilline' concept, and maritime strategy. Understanding this aids in assessing why India might host regional initiatives and the strategic rationale behind such events.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > India and the Geopolitics of the Indian Ocean > p. 78
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > INDIA AND THE GEO-POLITICS OF THE INDIAN OCEAN > p. 63
Reference [9] describes the growing American and Soviet/Russian naval presence and foreign defence installations in the region, highlighting the security environment that shapes naval dialogues and symposia.
High-yield: useful for questions on maritime security, great-power competition, and defence diplomacy. Helps frame why regional navies engage in symposiums and cooperative mechanisms to manage security concerns and foreign presence.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > History > p. 72
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > INDIA AND THE GEO-POLITICS OF THE INDIAN OCEAN > p. 63
Reference [5] records an early conference of Heads of littoral states of the Indian Ocean, linking the statement's topic to regional multilateral meetings among Indian Ocean states.
High-yield for UPSC because questions often ask about regional groupings, maritime diplomacy, and historical antecedents (e.g., 'zone of peace'). Mastering this helps answer questions on how multilateral maritime forums evolve and India's role in them; connect with topics on diplomacy and regional security.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > Response of the Bordering Countries > p. 73
References [6] and [9] document direct Indian Navy involvement in neighbouring island states (Maldives, Seychelles), relating to the Navy's leadership and influence in the Indian Ocean region.
Important for UPSC because India's naval missions illustrate power projection, security policy, and military diplomacy. Knowing concrete operations aids answers on 'Indian strategic reach' and civil-military dimensions of foreign policy; useful for case-based questions on regional security.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > GEOPOLITICS OF SOUTH ASIA > p. 60
- Rajiv Ahir. A Brief History of Modern India (2019 ed.). SPECTRUM. > Chapter 39: After Nehru... > Foreign Relations > p. 732
References [4] and [2] describe foreign naval presence and India's strategic position in the Indian Ocean, which frames why forums like IONS would be significant and who might chair or lead them.
High-yield: UPSC frequently tests Indian Ocean geopolitics, bases, and great-power naval dynamics. Mastery helps in questions on maritime strategy, foreign military presence, and India's strategic choices; enables analysis of why India might host or chair regional maritime initiatives.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > History > p. 72
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > India and the Geopolitics of the Indian Ocean > p. 78
IONS concerns naval cooperation among Indian Ocean littoral states; several references identify and discuss the littoral countries and their shared interests.
High-yield for UPSC: questions often probe regional groupings, maritime diplomacy and security. Mastering which countries are littoral, their concerns and India’s role helps answer questions on regional forums, maritime strategy and trade routes. Connects to topics on maritime boundaries, regional organisations and geopolitical strategy.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > Response of the Bordering Countries > p. 72
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 16: India–Political Aspects > India and the Geopolitics of the Indian Ocean > p. 78
The Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA). Unlike IONS (which is for Navy Chiefs), IORA is a diplomatic/ministerial body established in 1997 with its Secretariat in Ebene, Mauritius. Expect a question swapping IORA's mandate with IONS.
Apply the 'Motherhood vs. Specificity' rule. Statement 2 is a 'Motherhood Statement' (voluntary, cooperation, good intentions) -> 99% likely to be TRUE. Statement 1 contains a rigid fact ('Inaugural... 2015'). In UPSC, specific dates for inaugurations are often swapped to create a trap. If you know IONS is older than 'just recently' (2015 was very close to the 2017 exam), you can eliminate S1.
Link this to GS-2 (India & Neighborhood) and GS-3 (Security). Use the keyword 'Net Security Provider' and 'SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region)' when discussing IONS in Mains.