Question map
With reference to the history of India, consider the following pairs : Famous Place Present State 1. Bhilsa - Madhya Pradesh 2. Dwarasamudra - Maharashtra 3. Girinagar - Gujarat 4. Sthanesvara - Uttar Pradesh Which of the pairs given above are correctly matched ?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 1 (1 and 3 only) based on the following historical and geographical facts:
- Pair 1 is correctly matched: Bhilsa (modern-day Vidisha) is located in Madhya Pradesh. It was a significant center of trade and commerce during the Gupta period and is famous for the Heliodorus pillar and Udayagiri caves.
- Pair 3 is correctly matched: Girinagar refers to modern-day Junagadh in Gujarat. It is historically significant for the Girnar hill inscriptions of Ashoka, Rudradaman I, and Skandagupta.
- Pair 2 is incorrectly matched: Dwarasamudra (Halebidu) was the capital of the Hoysala Empire and is located in Karnataka, not Maharashtra.
- Pair 4 is incorrectly matched: Sthanesvara (Thanesar) was the capital of the Pushyabhuti dynasty (Harsha's lineage) and is located in Haryana (near Kurukshetra), not Uttar Pradesh.
Since only pairs 1 and 3 are accurate, Option 1 is the right choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Historical Geography' question. While standard books mention these capitals under their respective dynasties, they rarely provide a direct 'Ancient Site = Modern State' table. The fairness is high because these are major capitals (Hoysala, Pushyabhuti, Shunga/Gupta), not obscure villages. Success requires reading history with a modern political map open.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: In the history of India, is the ancient place Bhilsa (Bhelsa/Vidisha) located in present-day Madhya Pradesh?
- Statement 2: In the history of India, is the ancient city Dwarasamudra (the Hoysala capital) located in present-day Maharashtra?
- Statement 3: In the history of India, is the ancient place Girinagar located in present-day Gujarat?
- Statement 4: In the history of India, is the ancient site Sthanesvara (Sthaneshvara) located in present-day Uttar Pradesh?
- Explicitly names Vidisha and locates it in Madhya Pradesh.
- Refers to an ancient monument (Heliodorus pillar) as being near Vidisha, linking an archaeological/historical site to the modern state.
Identifies the Hoysalas as 'of Dvarasamudra (Karnataka)' while naming the Yadavas as based at Devagiri (present Maharashtra), establishing a pattern that associates Dvarasamudra with Karnataka rather than Maharashtra.
A student could check modern-state boundaries on a map to see whether Dvarasamudra falls inside present-day Karnataka or Maharashtra.
States that the Hoysalas ruled parts of southern India 'mostly present-day Karnataka', reinforcing a geographic association of the Hoysala polity with Karnataka.
Combine this with a map of medieval Hoysala territory to judge whether their capital lies within modern Karnataka.
Explains that the Yadavas ruled most of Maharashtra (Devagiri) in the 13th century, giving a contrastive example of a major Deccan capital that is in present-day Maharashtra.
Use this contrast (Yadava/Devagiri = Maharashtra) to differentiate which medieval capitals correspond to modern Maharashtra versus Karnataka.
Defines the Deccan region as encompassing parts of present-day Telangana, Andhra, Karnataka and Maharashtra, indicating that medieval polities in the Deccan might belong to different modern states and must be located more precisely.
A student should not assume 'Deccan' = Maharashtra; instead, they should locate Dvarasamudra specifically on a map of the Deccan to resolve the question.
Shows that ancient dynasties (e.g., Satavahanas) ruled territories spanning present-day Maharashtra and Karnataka, illustrating that historical kingdoms often crossed modern state boundaries.
Use this pattern to justify checking precise historical-place identifications (coordinates or modern district names) rather than inferring state from the dynasty alone.
Mentions a rock inscription of Junagadh, near Girnar in Gujarat, linking an ancient place-name (Girnar) to present-day Gujarat.
A student could compare the name 'Girinagar' with 'Girnar/Girinagar' on a map or in gazetteers to assess whether the ancient name corresponds to a site in Gujarat.
Lists Dholavira as an ancient Harappan city located in Gujarat, showing that significant ancient sites are indeed situated in present-day Gujarat.
Use this pattern (ancient sites located in Gujarat) and check archaeological or historical lists for Girinagar to see if it is similarly recorded in Gujarat.
Describes the Gujarat Coastal Plain and geographic extent of the state, providing geographic context for locating ancient sites within modern Gujarat.
Combine this geographic outline with the probable coordinates or descriptions of Girinagar to judge whether it falls within Gujarat's present-day boundaries.
Gives an example (Hastinapura) of an ancient/epic-associated site identified by archaeology in present-day Meerut, Uttar Pradesh, showing that sites from textual tradition can be located in UP.
A student could use this pattern to check whether textual references to Sthanesvara correspond to an archaeological site within UP (e.g., by comparing classical place-names and modern UP map).
Identifies Sārnāth (near Varanasi) as an important ancient Buddhist site in present-day Uttar Pradesh, illustrating that major ancient religious sites are located in UP.
One could compare the religious/administrative role of Sthanesvara in texts with known UP sites (like Sarnath/Varanasi) and then check modern maps or gazetteers for a match in UP.
Notes Baghor in Uttar Pradesh as an early shrine site, showing UP contains prehistoric/ancient ritual sites.
Use the example of Baghor to justify searching UP archaeological records and place-name directories for Sthanesvara/Sthaneshvara entries.
States that there are Harappan and pre-Harappan archaeological sites in Punjab, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh, indicating UP is part of the geographic range of ancient Indian sites.
A student might extend this geographic pattern by checking if Sthanesvara appears in lists of ancient sites within the broader region that includes UP.
Describes the Aryan expansion into western Uttar Pradesh (Ganga–Yamuna doab), implying the doab contains many ancient cultural/political centres.
One could use this to motivate checking historical/epic references and maps of the Ganga–Yamuna doab for a place called Sthanesvara/Sthaneshvara in present-day UP.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. All four are major historical cities covered in standard NCERTs (RS Sharma/Satish Chandra) and TN Board History.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Historical Geography & Capital Cities. The shift from asking 'Which Dynasty?' to 'Where is it now?'.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Map these immediately: Anhilwara (Patan, Gujarat), Manyakheta (Malkhed, Karnataka), Vengi (Eluru, AP), Dhanyakataka (Amaravati, AP), Tamralipti (Tamluk, WB), Sopara (Nalasopara, Maharashtra), and Tripuri (Jabalpur, MP).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: When you read 'Hoysalas ruled from Dwarasamudra', do not stop there. Ask: 'Is Dwarasamudra in Karnataka or Tamil Nadu today?' Visualizing the modern boundary is the only way to retain this.
Vidisha is an ancient urban site now situated in present-day Madhya Pradesh, so mapping ancient names to current states is essential.
High-yield for UPSC because many questions require locating historical sites within present-day political boundaries; links historical geography with archaeology and aids quick elimination in prelims and precision in mains answers.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 6: The Age of Reorganisation > Invasions of the Indo-Greeks > p. 134
The Heliodorus pillar near Vidisha exemplifies Indo-Greek cultural and diplomatic links associated with that locality.
Important for understanding foreign contacts in ancient India and using material culture as evidence; frequently appears in culture/ancient history questions and helps frame answers with concrete archaeological examples.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 6: The Age of Reorganisation > Invasions of the Indo-Greeks > p. 134
Bhils refers to a tribe with distribution in Madhya Pradesh, whereas Bhilsa/Bhelsa (Vidisha) is a named ancient place; candidates must avoid conflating tribe names with toponyms.
Clarifies common confusions in both prelim and mains questions where social groups and place-names intersect; strengthens accuracy in answers on cultural geography and historical settlements.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > The Bhils > p. 31
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 6: The Age of Reorganisation > Invasions of the Indo-Greeks > p. 134
Identifies which medieval South Indian dynasties correspond to which present-day states (for example, Hoysalas → Karnataka; Yadavas → Maharashtra).
High-yield for UPSC because many questions ask to place historical polities on the modern map; it links history with political geography and helps eliminate wrong options in polity/GS prelim and mains geography-history integrated questions.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 12: Bahmani and Vijayanagar Kingdoms > Introduction > p. 175
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: Reshaping India’s Political Map > THINK ABOUT IT > p. 30
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: The Rise of the Marathas > Who are the Marathas? > p. 62
Focuses on identifying historic capitals (e.g., Dvarasamudra for the Hoysalas; Devagiri/Daulatabad for the Yadavas) and locating them in present states.
Crucial for answering source-based and map-based questions; mastering this reduces errors in chronology+geography linkage and supports essay and answer-writing where placement of centres of power is required.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 12: Bahmani and Vijayanagar Kingdoms > Introduction > p. 175
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: The Rise of the Marathas > Who are the Marathas? > p. 62
Covers the territorial extent and regional divisions of medieval polities in the Deccan and south India, showing which areas belonged to which dynasties.
Useful for conceptual questions on regional interactions, invasions (north–south movements), and state formation; connects to art/architecture, trade routes and later politico-military developments tested in prelims and mains.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 12: Bahmani and Vijayanagar Kingdoms > Introduction > p. 175
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science, Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 2: Reshaping India’s Political Map > THINK ABOUT IT > p. 30
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 5: Evolution of Society in South India > Introduction > p. 63
Identifying where ancient towns and sites fall in present-day political geography is essential to answer whether a historical place is in a given modern state.
High-yield for UPSC: questions often ask to locate ancient sites in current states or districts. Mastering this enables quick elimination of wrong options in map-based and history‑geography linkage questions and links history with physical and cultural geography.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 6: The Beginnings of Indian Civilisation > Town-Planning > p. 90
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 4: Emergence of State and Empire > Sources > p. 47
The 'Trap' in Option 2 (Dwarasamudra - Maharashtra) likely stems from the Yadava capital, Devagiri (Daulatabad), which *is* in Maharashtra. The Shadow Fact is: Devagiri/Seuna dynasty = Maharashtra; Warangal/Kakatiya = Telangana; Dwarasamudra/Hoysala = Karnataka.
Use the 'Dynasty-State Association' hack. Dwarasamudra = Hoysala Dynasty. Hoysala Art (Belur/Halebid) is the cultural identity of Karnataka. Therefore, Pair 2 (Maharashtra) is false. Eliminate options C and D. Now you only need to check Pair 4 (Sthanesvara). Sthanesvara = Thanesar = Kurukshetra = Haryana (not UP). Pair 4 is false. Answer is A.
GS1 (Art & Culture): The location of the capital dictates the architectural style. Dwarasamudra (Halebidu) is the epicenter of the 'Vesara' or 'Hoysala' style of temple architecture (Star-shaped platforms), distinct from the Nagara style of Bhilsa (Vidisha) or the Dravida style further south.