Question map
With reference to Buddhist history, tradition and culture in India, consider the following pairs : Famous shrine Location 1. Tabo monastery and temple complex : Spiti Valley 2. Lhotsava Lhakhang temple, Nako : Zanskar Valley 3. Alchi temple complex : Ladakh Which of the pairs given above is/are correctly matched?
Explanation
The Tabo Monastery and temple complex is indeed located in the Spiti Valley of Himachal Pradesh[2], making pair 1 correct.
The Lhotsava Lhakhang temple at Nako is located in the Kinnaur district of Himachal Pradesh[4], not in Zanskar Valley as stated in the question. Zanskar Valley is in Jammu and Kashmir[5], making pair 2 incorrect.
The Alchi monastery is a Tibetan Buddhist monastic complex located in Alchi village in the Leh District of Ladakh[6], making pair 3 correct.
Therefore, only pairs 1 and 3 are correctly matched, making option C the correct answer.
Sources- [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alchi_Monastery
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question disguises Geography as Art & Culture. While Tabo and Alchi are standard textbook examples (Nitin Singhania/CCRT), the real test is Pair 2. The examiner checked if you could distinguish between the 'Kinnaur' region (Nako) and the 'Ladakh' region (Zanskar). Strategy: Always map Himalayan cultural sites to their specific river valleys, not just states.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Confirm whether the Buddhist shrine Tabo monastery and temple complex is located in Spiti Valley, Himachal Pradesh, India.
- Statement 2: Confirm whether the Buddhist shrine Lhotsava Lhakhang temple in Nako is located in Zanskar Valley, India.
- Statement 3: Confirm whether the Buddhist shrine Alchi temple complex is located in Ladakh, India.
- Explicitly states the match between Tabo Monastery and Spiti Valley is correct.
- Directly names Himachal Pradesh as the state containing Spiti Valley in this context.
- States the Tabo monastery and temple complex is located in Tago village of Spiti Valley.
- Specifies Spiti Valley and Himachal Pradesh together, tying the monastery to that region.
- Lists the location line showing Tabo is in Spiti Valley, Himachal Pradesh.
- Provides travel/attraction context reinforcing the geographic placement.
Identifies Spiti as one of the well-known valleys of Himachal Pradesh, establishing that 'Spiti Valley' is a recognized geographic unit within Himachal.
A student could take this as a prompt to check a map or gazetteer for named sites (like Tabo) within the Spiti valley of Himachal Pradesh.
States that Chandra Taal (a high-altitude lake) is located in the Spiti district of Himachal Pradesh, showing that notable high-altitude sites (and districts) are in Spiti.
A student could use this to narrow searches to Spiti district maps or district-level lists of monasteries/temples to look for Tabo.
Notes Chandra Tal is in Lahaul and Spiti district, confirming administrative naming (Lahaul and Spiti) used for the region where high-altitude religious sites occur.
A student could check administrative (district) maps for 'Lahaul and Spiti' to see if Tabo appears as a settlement/monastery within that district.
Mentions Buddhist temples adjacent to high-altitude lakes in Himachal (Nako in Kinnaur), indicating a pattern of Buddhist religious sites occurring in Himalayan valleys of Himachal.
A student could generalize this pattern and look specifically for Buddhist monasteries listed in Himachal’s high valleys (Spiti among them) to see if Tabo appears.
Describes the boundary and watershed between India and Tibet running along Spiti, situating Spiti geographically as part of the trans-Himalayan sector where Tibetan Buddhist sites might be expected.
A student could combine this geographical context with knowledge that Tibetan Buddhism is common in trans-Himalayan valleys and then search for named Tibetan Buddhist sites (e.g., Tabo) in Spiti.
- Explicitly states the pairing 'Lhotsava Lhakhang Temple, Nako - Zanskar Valley' is incorrect.
- Identifies Nako as being in Kinnaur district of Himachal Pradesh, not Zanskar.
- States the Lhotsava Lhakhang temple is situated in Nako village in Kinnaur district, Himachal Pradesh.
- Directly contradicts placement in Zanskar Valley.
- States Lhotsava Lhakhang, Nako is in Himachal Pradesh (cites Frontline).
- Notes Zanskar Valley is in Jammu and Kashmir and therefore the pair is wrong.
Specifies Nako Lake is situated in the district of Kinnaur (Himachal Pradesh) and that there are Buddhist temples near the lake, linking 'Nako' to Kinnaur rather than to Zanskar.
A student could use a map or administrative-boundary list to check whether Kinnaur (Himachal Pradesh) and Zanskar Valley (in Ladakh) are distinct locations, thus testing whether a temple in Nako would lie in Zanskar.
Describes the Ladakh region as a distinct, mainly mountainous area with a population distribution different from Kashmir, implicitly distinguishing Ladakh (where Zanskar is located) from other Himalayan districts.
Combine this with the Kinnaur location from snippet 1 and a political/physical map to determine whether Zanskar (part of Ladakh) overlaps Kinnaur (Himachal Pradesh).
Mentions valleys in Ladakh (Puga Valley) as distinct geographic features in that region, providing an example of named valleys belonging to Ladakh rather than Himachal.
Use the pattern that named valleys like Puga are in Ladakh to check whether Zanskar Valley is similarly in Ladakh and therefore separate from Nako in Kinnaur.
Lists many important Himalayan shrines and shows that Himalayan religious sites are spread across different named regions, implying location matters (district/state/region) for assigning a shrine to a valley.
A student could use this general rule—that shrines are tied to specific Himalayan districts/valleys—to look up the district/valley affiliation of Lhotsava Lhakhang and see if it matches Zanskar or Kinnaur.
- Explicitly identifies Alchi Monastery as a Tibetan Buddhist monastic complex located in Alchi village, Leh District.
- States the complex is under the Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council of the Union Territory of Ladakh, India.
- Describes Alchi as part of villages all in the lower Ladakh region.
- Places the Alchi group of monuments explicitly within Ladakh.
- States the Alchi Temple Complex is correctly matched with Ladakh.
- Specifies it is situated in Alchi village of Leh District on the Leh-Kargil Highway in the Ladakh region.
Describes the Ladakh cultural region as having Buddhist dominance and 'Gompas and monasteries'—establishes Ladakh as a Himalayan area where Buddhist temple complexes commonly occur.
A student could note that Alchi, if described in other sources as a 'gompa' or monastery, would plausibly be located in Ladakh and then check a map or gazetteer to see if Alchi lies within Ladakh.
Defines Ladakh as a distinct Himalayan (cold desert) region with river Indus flowing through it—gives geographic boundary/context for locating Himalayan shrines.
A student could use this geographic definition plus a map to determine whether Alchi (if known as a Himalayan site) falls within Ladakh's boundaries.
Notes Ladakh's population is almost equally divided between Buddhists and Muslims—supports the expectation of prominent Buddhist sites in the region.
A student could infer that significant Buddhist shrine complexes named in travel or history sources are likely to be in Ladakh and then compare Alchi's reported location to that expectation.
States that the Himalaya have numerous shrines and pilgrimage centres—indicates a general pattern that religious complexes (including Buddhist ones) are common in Himalayan regions like Ladakh.
A student could treat Alchi as one of many Himalayan shrines and then use regional maps of Himalayan shrines to see if Alchi is placed in Ladakh.
Mentions specific places located in Ladakh (Puga Valley), demonstrating the snippets include place-names within Ladakh that could be cross-referenced with other place-names like Alchi.
A student could cross-reference a map or gazetteer listing Ladakh place-names to locate Alchi relative to other named Ladakh sites (e.g., Puga Valley) to test whether Alchi is in Ladakh.
- [THE VERDICT]: Moderate. Tabo and Alchi are 'Sitter' facts found in basic culture notes; Pair 2 is the 'Trap' requiring precise map knowledge.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Himalayan Buddhist Circuit – specifically the geographic distinction between Spiti, Kinnaur, and Ladakh cultural zones.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize by Valley: Ladakh (Hemis, Thiksey, Diskit, Lamayuru); Spiti (Key, Dhankar, Tabo); Sikkim (Rumtek, Pemayangtse); Arunachal (Tawang).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Stop memorizing lists alphabetically. Group monasteries by 'Valley' (Spiti vs. Zanskar vs. Indus). The valley determines the geography and often the specific Buddhist sect.
The statement concerns location in Spiti Valley; several references identify Spiti and Lahaul & Spiti as distinct high‑altitude valleys/districts in Himachal Pradesh.
UPSC often asks about physiographic divisions, valley/district locations and administrative geography. Mastering which valleys correspond to which districts and their high‑altitude character helps answer location-based questions and link physical geography to cultural sites. Prepare by mapping valleys to districts and noting key landmarks.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 2: Physiography > 2. The Himachal Himalaya > p. 15
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Chandra Tal > p. 29
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Chandra Taal Lake > p. 31
Confirming a monastery’s location requires awareness that Buddhist temples/monasteries occur in Himachal’s Himalayan valleys (e.g., temples near Nako Lake).
Questions test distribution of religious sites across regions. Knowing that Buddhist centres exist in Himachal’s high valleys (Kinnaur, Spiti regionally) aids elimination in multiple‑choice and short‑answer items. Study regional cultural geography and site distributions from textbook maps and excerpts.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Nako Lake > p. 30
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 2: Physiography > 2. The Himachal Himalaya > p. 15
References highlight high‑altitude features (Chandra Tal/Chandra Taal) and seasonal accessibility in the Spiti/Lahaul area, giving contextual grounding for remote cultural sites like monasteries.
Understanding terrain, elevation and seasonal access is useful when questions link physical constraints to human settlement/cultural site locations. Practice by linking physical features (lakes, passes) to human geography (settlements, monasteries) on regional maps.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Chandra Tal > p. 29
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Chandra Taal Lake > p. 31
Reference [1] explicitly places Nako Lake in Kinnaur (Himachal Pradesh), showing the importance of district/state identification for Himalayan sites.
UPSC questions often require identifying the administrative location of physical or cultural sites. Knowing how to map a site to its district/state helps distinguish similar-sounding places and avoid conflating regions (high-yield for geography and culture papers). Practice by cross-checking multiple authoritative sources (gazetteers, NCERT, official district pages).
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Nako Lake > p. 30
Evidence mentions Buddhist temples at Nako (Himachal Pradesh) [1] and notes Buddhist population/centres in the Ladakh region [7], highlighting regional spread across different Himalayan areas.
Questions on religious and cultural geography frequently probe where religious communities and shrines are concentrated (Himachal vs Ladakh vs other Himalayan zones). Master this to answer location, cultural landscape, and demographic questions. Study regional chapters in NCERTs and authoritative state-level geography texts; create comparison tables of sites by state/region.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Nako Lake > p. 30
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: Regional Aspirations > Jammu and Kashmir > p. 115
No reference names 'Lhotsava Lhakhang' or links Nako to Zanskar; [1] gives Nako's district, demonstrating that lack of an explicit citation prevents confirmation.
UPSC answers must be source-backed; learn to recognise when provided material is insufficient to confirm a factual claim. This skill is vital for prelims/verifying statements in comprehension/GS papers. Train by practicing source-evidence matching and flagging unsupported assertions.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > Nako Lake > p. 30
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: Regional Aspirations > Jammu and Kashmir > p. 115
The question asks about a Buddhist temple's location; references state Ladakh has Buddhist dominance with gompas and monasteries.
High-yield for UPSC: religious and cultural regionalisation questions often ask which areas have Buddhist cultural influence. Connects to topics on cultural geography, regional identities, and mapping religious sites. Prepare by memorising cultural regions and key cultural features from standard texts and maps.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > Fig. 13.16 Christian Population (2011) > p. 60
- Politics in India since Independence, Textbook in political science for Class XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 7: Regional Aspirations > Jammu and Kashmir > p. 115
Phugtal Monastery (Zanskar). Since the exam incorrectly placed Nako in Zanskar, the 'Shadow Fact' is the actual famous monastery of Zanskar, known for its honeycomb structure built into a cliffside. Also, watch out for Sumda Chun (Ladakh), often called Alchi's 'sister' site.
The 'Geography Override'. Look at Pair 2: 'Nako'. Even if you haven't heard of the temple, 'Nako Lake' is a standard Geography fact located in Kinnaur, Himachal Pradesh. 'Zanskar' is a distinct range/valley in Ladakh. A place in Kinnaur cannot be in Zanskar. Eliminate Pair 2 immediately.
Mains GS2 (IR/Soft Power): These monasteries (Tabo, Alchi, Tawang) form the 'Vajrayana Corridor'. India leverages this shared Buddhist heritage as strategic Soft Power to counter China's influence in the Himalayan belt.