UPSC Mains 2019 GS3 Q1 — Indian Economy (GST)
Enumerate the indirect taxes which have been subsumed in the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India. Also, comment on the revenue implications of the GST introduced in India since July 2017. (Answer in 150 words)
Similar Previous Year Questions
Related Prelims MCQs
Build factual foundation — these MCQs cover facts/concepts you'll need for this Mains question.
-
CDS-II 2023 Goods and Services Tax
Which one of the following taxes is not subsumed under the Goods and Services Tax in India? (a) Customs Duties (b) Central Excise Duties (c) Service Tax (d) Taxes on Petroleum and Petroleum Products
-
CDS-I 2017 Goods and Services Tax
Which one of the following statements is correct in relation to the GST Bill passed by the Rajya Sabha in August 2016?
-
IAS 2017 Goods and Services Tax
What is/are the most likely advantages of implementing 'Goods and Services Tax (GST)' ? 1. It will replace multiple taxes collected by multiple authorities and will thus create a single market in India. 2. It will drastically reduce the 'Current Account Deficit' of India and will enable it to increase its foreign exchange reserves. 3. It will enormously increase the growth and size of economy of India and will enable it to overtake China in the near future. Select the correct answer using the code given below :
-
CAPF 2020 Government Finance & Budget
Which one of the following has the largest contribution to the Gross Tax Revenue of Government of India in 2019-20 (BE) ?
-
IAS 2012 Finance Commission transfers
Which of the following is/are among the noticeable feature of the recommendations of the Thirteenth Finance Commission? 1. A design for the Goods and Services Tax, and a compensation package linked to adherence to the proposed design 2. A design for the creation of lakhs of jobs in the next ten years in consonance with India’s demographic dividend 3. Devolution of a specified share of central taxes to local bodies as grants Select the correct answer using the codes given below:
Source Map — where to read
"• r India will bring a WTO challenge against any "carbon taxes" that rich countries impose on Indian imports. • e "If they impose such a tax, we will take them to the \{TO dispute settlemenr forum," "W'e will deai lwith this] through hard negotiations" Such barriers are not going to be WT0-compatible and we will fight it…"
"1. Explain the rationale behind the Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act of 2017. How has COVID-19 impacted the GST compensation fund and created new federal tensions? • 2. Enumerate the indirect taxes which have been subsumed in the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India. Also, comment on the revenue implications of the GST introduced in India since July 2017. 3. The public expenditure management is a challenge to the Government of India in the context of budget making during the post-liberalisation period. Clarify it. No question • 4. What are the reasons for the introduction o…"
"• o Carbon tax is the potential alternative to the ,cap and trade' method currently used by the protocol. • r This tax is based on the amount of carbon contained in a fuel such as coai, etc. • r The aim of this tax is to cause less fossil fuel use and hopefully cause. an incentive to use other sources of energy. • c If the carbon tax l4/as implemented it would be gradual and start at a low amount and increase over time to allow better industry'ind technology to be developed -\ ) -l ) t \ \ I : ; { ) 1 ] ) I ?…"
"• The public expenditure management is a challenge to the Government of India in the context of budget making during the post liberalization-period. Clarify it. [2019]• Enumerated the indirect taxes which have been subsumed in the GST in India. Also, comment on the revenue implications of the GST introduced in India since July 2017. [2019]• Explain the rationale behind the Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act of 2017. How has Covid-19 impacted the GST Compensation fund and created new federal tensions. [2020]• Distinguish between capital budget and Revenue Budget. Explain the co…"
"r. Revenue loss to the exchequer For e.g.: It is estimated that in Noida and Greater Noida alone the loss to the exchequer is about Rs. 100 crore, but the impact that sand mining, which is simply put theft on environment and ecology, cannot even be calculated.…"
How this topic is evolving
The discourse on GST has moved beyond the initial 101st Amendment implementation to the fiscal sustainability of 'Sin Taxes' and 'Cesses' as permanent revenue streams. The focus is shifting from simple indirect tax subsumption to a 'calibrated protectionism' framework, where fiscal tools are used for granular market stabilization and protecting domestic industry from global price volatility.
Discuss the evolution of GST from a compensation-led regime to a system increasingly reliant on permanent health-linked 'sin taxes' and cesses. In this context, evaluate how the recent shift towards granular fiscal calibrations impacts the spirit of cooperative federalism. (Answer in 150 words)
Why this framing: Transition from temporary GST compensation cesses to permanent revenue-generating 'sin taxes' and national security cesses.
Question Decoded — examiner's intent
- Directive verbs
- Enumeratecomment on
- Scope keywords
- indirect taxessubsumed in the Goods and Services Tax (GST)revenue implicationssince July 2017
- Implicit sub-parts
- Classification of subsumed taxes into Central vs. State categories.
- Impact on the Tax-to-GDP ratio and tax buoyancy post-2017.
- Transition from 'revenue neutrality' to revenue growth (including the Compensation Cess issue).
- Structural changes in tax collection efficiency and formalization of the economy.
- Common pitfalls
- Listing direct taxes like Income Tax or Corporate Tax by mistake.
- Forgetting to mention taxes still outside GST (Petroleum, Alcohol, Electricity) as a counter-point to 'revenue implications'.
- Vague qualitative comments like 'revenue increased' without mentioning the 1.5-1.7 lakh crore average monthly collection benchmarks.
- Spending too many words on the list of taxes and leaving no room for the 'commentary' on implications.
- Ignoring the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the initial revenue trajectory.
- Dimensions required
- Fiscal/EconomicFederal (Center-State relations)Administrative (Ease of Doing Business)Temporal (Pre-2017 vs. Post-2017 comparison)
- Marks allocation hint
Spend approximately 50 words on the enumeration, clearly separating Central (Excise, Service Tax) and State (VAT, Luxury Tax) levies. Use the remaining 100 words for the commentary, focusing on data-backed trends in revenue growth, buoyancy, and the shift toward a wider tax base.
How examiners have framed this topic over the years
Transitioned from specific tax changes (2018) to structural GST analysis (2019), then to fiscal federalism (2020) and global trade-linked subsidies (2023).
Before 2019, the examiner focused on specific, localized tax reforms such as LTCGT and DDT in the 2018 budget. In 2019, the lens shifted toward a structural overview of the GST transition, focusing on subsumed taxes and revenue implications. Subsequently, in 2020, the framing moved from tax mechanics to the broader strain on fiscal federalism, specifically analyzing the Compensation Act rationale amidst the COVID-19 crisis. By 2023, the scope widened to link fiscal tools like agricultural subsidies with international trade governance under the WTO lens.
PYQs this pattern was synthesized from
Answer Skeleton — fill this in
Introduction
The Goods and Services Tax (GST), launched on July 1, 2017, via the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, is a comprehensive, multi-stage, destination-based tax that replaced the previous fragmented indirect tax regime to create a unified national market. [Laxmikanth, Ch. 101st Amendment]
Central Taxes Subsumed
- Central Excise Duty and Additional Excise Duties on goods of special importance.
- Service Tax which was previously levied on a wide range of professional services.
- Countervailing Duty (CVD) and Special Additional Duty of Customs (SAD) to ensure parity with domestic taxes. [NCERT Class 12 Macroeconomics, Ch. 5]
State Taxes Subsumed
- State VAT/Sales Tax and Central Sales Tax (CST) on inter-state trade.
- Entry Tax and Octroi which previously hindered the free movement of goods across state borders.
- Luxury Tax, Lottery Tax, and Entertainment Tax (excluding those levied by local bodies). [PRS Legislative Research - GST Overview]
Positive Revenue Implications
- Buoyancy and Formalization: Significant increase in the tax base; monthly gross collections consistently exceeding ₹1.7 lakh crore in FY 2023-24. [Economic Survey 2023-24]
- Removal of Cascading Effect: Seamless Input Tax Credit (ITC) has reduced the overall tax burden on final consumers, potentially increasing consumption-led revenue.
- Improved Compliance: Use of the GSTN portal and E-way bills has reduced tax evasion and leakages.
Revenue Challenges and Constraints
- Compensation Concerns: The end of the 5-year guaranteed compensation period in 2022 created fiscal stress for several states.
- Inverted Duty Structure: Technical anomalies where inputs are taxed higher than finished goods, leading to refund claims and revenue blockage. [Yojana, GST@5 Issue]
Conclusion
While GST has successfully streamlined India's tax architecture and improved revenue productivity, further rationalization of tax slabs and the inclusion of petroleum products are essential. Strengthening Cooperative Federalism through the GST Council will ensure long-term fiscal stability for both Center and States.
Ready to practice?
Take this question, write your own answer in 150 words, and get an instant, rubric-based evaluation showing where you stand.
Open evaluation workspace →