UPSC Mains 2015 GS3 Q3 — Land Reforms
In view of the declining average size of land holdings in India which has made agriculture non-viable for a majority of farmers, should contract farming and land leasing be promoted in agriculture ? Critically evaluate the pros and cons. (Answer in 200 words)
Similar Previous Year Questions
No closely related PYQs found in our 11-year corpus — this question explores a relatively unique angle. We only surface matches with substantive topical overlap, not loose adjacency.
Related Prelims MCQs
Build factual foundation — these MCQs cover facts/concepts you'll need for this Mains question.
-
CDS-II 2014 Agriculture & Rural Economy
Which of the following statements relating to Indian agriculture is/are correct ? 1. India has the World’s largest cropped area. 2. Cropping pattern is dominated by cereal crop. 3. The average size of an Indian farm holding is too small for several agricultural operations. Select the correct answer using the code given below:
-
CDS-II 2012 Agricultural development trends
Which of the following are responsible for the decrease of per capita holding of cultivated land in India? 1. Low per capita income 2. Rapid rate of increase of population 3. Practice of dividing land equally among the heirs 4. Use of traditional techniques of ploughing Select the correct answer using the code given below : Code :
-
IAS 2019 Rural development policy
With reference to land reforms in independent India, which one of the following statements is correct?
-
NDA-I 2012 Irrigation and watershed
Which one among the following is the major reason for low agricultural productivity in dry regions of India?
-
IAS 2023 Agricultural development trends
Consider the following statements : 1. India has more arable area than China. 2. The proportion of irrigated area is more in India as compared to China. 3. The average productivity per hectare in Indian agriculture is higher than that in China. How many of the above statements are correct?
Source Map — where to read
"Farming, a major livelihood in India, can become unsustainable if not managed well by applying environment friendly farming practices. Humans have been practising farming for thousands of years to grow food. As the population grew, our dependence on agriculture increased. Between 1950 and 1965, India faced a food crisis due to low crop production. In the mid-20th century, the use of tractors, machines, synthetic fertilisers, and pesticides helped increase food production. This period is known as the Green Revolution. However, these farming methods are now considered unsustainable because of th…"
"\vert 2015 \vert 2. In view of the declining average size of landholdings in India which has made agriculture non-viable for a majority of farmers, should contract farming and land leasing be promoted in agriculture? Critically evaluate the pros and cons. 3. The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 has come into effect from 1 January 2014. What are the key issues which would get addressed with the Act in place? What implications would it have on industrialisation and agriculture in India? 4. Establish the relationship betwee…"
"• Fragmentation of land holding. • Existence of small and marginal farmers. • Regional variation. • Dependence on seasonal rainfall. • Low productivity of land. • Increasing of disguised unemployment. • Disorder in marketing of Agricultural products. • Weak land reformation. According to *iobil Frrest l{riouicn,essessment Report (Food and Agriculrurai Organization (FAO), 4qs5), India has 1.8% of the global forest area with per capita forests of 0.08 ha.…"
"Uttar Pradesh are the states in which consolidation of holdings has been completed. (ii) Land Holding: In India the size of holding is too small. Due to the rapid growth of population during the last few decades and the existing law of inheritance, the agricultural land is divided equally among the male children of the deceased farmer. At present, the per capita available land is only about 0.10 hectare which is much below the world average of about 4.50 hectares. Over 70% of the land holdings are less than one hectare. Such small holdings are not economically viable. In fact, small holdings c…"
"r A diversified farming has several production enterprises or sources of income, but no source of income equal as much as 50% of the total income. It is also called as general farming.…"
How this topic is evolving
The focus has shifted from the basic viability of small landholdings through leasing toward a 'Precision-Cluster-Commodity' (PCC) framework that integrates land use with specialized infrastructure. The 2015 debate on contract farming has matured into institutionalized, district-led planning under the PM Dhan-Dhaanya Krishi Yojana (PM-DDKY), emphasizing capital formation over mere land-size constraints.
While the declining size of land holdings remains a challenge, the shift toward a 'Precision-Cluster-Commodity' framework offers a new pathway for agricultural viability. In light of the PM Dhan-Dhaanya Krishi Yojana (PM-DDKY), evaluate how decentralized, district-led planning and the Agriculture Infrastructure Fund (AIF) can address the structural inefficiencies of smallholder farming. (Answer in 250 words)
Why this framing: Launch of PM Dhan-Dhaanya Krishi Yojana (PM-DDKY) targeting 100 districts for decentralized agricultural planning.
Question Decoded — examiner's intent
- Directive verbs
- Critically evaluate
- Scope keywords
- declining average size of land holdingsagriculture non-viablecontract farmingland leasingpros and cons
- Implicit sub-parts
- Analysis of how small land size leads to non-viability (scale issues, mechanization hurdles).
- Positive impacts of contract farming and leasing on farmer income and productivity.
- Structural risks including land alienation, corporate dominance, and weak bargaining power.
- Necessary regulatory safeguards and the role of the Model Land Leasing Act/APMC reforms.
- Common pitfalls
- Focusing too much on general agricultural distress instead of specifically addressing land fragmentation.
- Failing to distinguish between 'land leasing' (legalizing tenancy) and 'contract farming' (production agreements).
- Missing the 'Critical' aspect by only listing benefits without discussing the threat to smallholder autonomy.
- Neglecting to mention the state-level legislative context or the Model Acts proposed by NITI Aayog.
- Dimensions required
- Economic (Economies of scale)Legal/Regulatory (Tenancy laws)Social (Rights of sharecroppers)Technological (Modern inputs and mechanization)
- Marks allocation hint
Allocate 30 words to the link between fragmentation and non-viability. Devote 70 words to the 'Pros' of both mechanisms. Use 70 words for a critical evaluation of 'Cons' and risks. Reserve the final 30 words for a balanced way forward focusing on 'Farmer Producer Organizations' (FPOs) as a safeguard.
How examiners have framed this topic over the years
Evolution from purely economic land-use debates to multidimensional explorations of land reforms, ethical migration crises, and long-term environmental food security.
While the 2015 GS3 question focused on the economic viability of small holdings through private sector interventions like contract farming, subsequently in 2016 (GS3) and 2023 (GS3), the examiner pivoted back to the structural fundamentals of land reforms and the efficacy of land ceiling policies. The framing further evolved in 2020 (GS4) to treat small land holdings not just as an economic constraint, but as a catalyst for ethical crises, including tribal migration and child labor exploitation. Most recently in 2024 (GS1), the examiner shifted the focus from land ownership structures to the environmental sustainability of these agricultural zones, specifically linking resource depletion to national food security.
PYQs this pattern was synthesized from
Answer Skeleton — fill this in
Introduction
Average landholding in India has declined to 1.08 hectares, with 86% of farmers categorized as small or marginal [Agriculture Census 2015-16]. Promoting contract farming and land leasing aims to overcome this fragmentation by enabling "scale of economy" without transferring land ownership.
Merits of Promotion
- Input and Tech Infusion: Contract farming brings private investment, modern seeds, and precision technology to small plots [Economic Survey 2022-23].
- Price Certainty: Pre-agreed prices shield farmers from market volatility and "distress sales" during harvest gluts.
- Formalization of Tenancy: Legalizing land leasing provides security to "invisible" tenant farmers, allowing them access to institutional credit and insurance [NITI Aayog Model Land Leasing Act, 2016].
Critical Concerns and Risks
- Asymmetric Bargaining Power: Small farmers often lack the legal capacity to negotiate fair terms with large agribusinesses, leading to exploitative contracts.
- Risk of Exclusion: Corporates may prefer "clusters" or larger farmers to reduce transaction costs, further marginalizing the smallest holders [Yojana, Agriculture Issue].
- Ecological Impact: Shift towards monoculture and intensive chemical use to meet "export quality" standards can degrade long-term soil health.
Strategic Prerequisites
- Aggregation through FPOs: Strengthening Farmer Producer Organizations to act as intermediaries, balancing the power dynamic [Economic Survey 2021-22].
- Dispute Redressal: Establishing local, time-bound arbitration mechanisms to prevent farmers from getting entangled in lengthy civil court litigation.
- Digital Records: Modernization of land records through SVAMITVA to provide clear titles for leasing [PRS Legislative Research].
Conclusion
While contract farming and leasing are essential to make agriculture "business-viable," they must be accompanied by robust regulatory oversight. The focus should be on a "partnership model" that protects the tiller's rights while leveraging private efficiency to achieve the goal of doubling farmers' welfare.
Ready to practice?
Take this question, write your own answer in 200 words, and get an instant, rubric-based evaluation showing where you stand.
Open evaluation workspace →