Question map
Consider the following pairs : Traditions Communities 1. Chaliha Sahib Festival - Sindhis 2. Nanda Raj Jaat Yatra - Gonds 3. Wari-Warkari - Santhals Which of the pairs given above is/are correctly matched ?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 1. This question tests knowledge of cultural traditions and their associated communities/regions in India.
- Pair 1 is correctly matched: The Chaliha Sahib Festival is a significant 40-day fast observed by the Sindhi community. It commemorates the occasion when their ancestors prayed to Varuna Dev (Jhulelal) to protect them from the forced conversions and tyranny of Mirkshah, a local ruler in Sindh.
- Pair 2 is incorrectly matched: The Nanda Raj Jaat Yatra is a famous pilgrimage in Uttarakhand, associated with the Garhwali and Kumaoni people, not Gonds. It involves the symbolic journey of Goddess Nanda Devi to her husband’s home in Nanda Ghunti.
- Pair 3 is incorrectly matched: Wari-Warkari is a centuries-old pilgrimage tradition in Maharashtra. It is associated with the Warkari sect (devotees of Lord Vitthal), not the Santhals. The pilgrimage culminates at Pandharpur.
Since only the first pair is accurate, 1 only is the correct choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question masquerades as a 'Culture' trivia test but is actually a 'Geography' logic test. You don't need to know the Chaliha Sahib festival to solve it; you only need to spot the massive geographic mismatches in pairs 2 and 3. The strategy is not memorizing infinite festival lists, but mapping major tribes and traditions to their home states.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Traditions and communities: Is the Chaliha Sahib festival celebrated by the Sindhi community (Sindhis)?
- Statement 2: Traditions and communities: Is the Nanda Raj Jaat Yatra a traditional ritual of the Gond community (Gonds)?
- Statement 3: Traditions and communities: Is the Wari–Warkari tradition associated with the Santhal community (Santhals)?
Shows existence of a distinct Sindhi literary and cultural tradition in the 18th century, implying an identifiable Sindhi community with its own cultural practices.
A student could use this to justify searching for Sindhi-specific festivals or community observances (like Chaliha Sahib) in regional cultural lists or Sindhi cultural histories.
Lists 'Sindhi' as a distinct linguistic/cultural group, indicating Sindhis form a recognisable cultural region likely to have particular traditions and festivals.
Combine this with a map of Sindhi-speaking areas or diaspora communities to look for festivals named in Sindhi-language sources or community calendars.
States that many festivals are regionally varied and that common festivals may be celebrated under different names across India.
Use this pattern to consider that Chaliha Sahib might be a regional/communally-specific observance (possibly celebrated by Sindhis) and search for equivalent names or local variants in Sindhi contexts.
Encourages checking whether a festival celebrated in one region is observed elsewhere under another name, highlighting how festival names and associations can vary by community.
A student could extend this by comparing festival names and rituals in Sindhi communities and neighbouring regions to see if Chaliha Sahib appears as a local variant.
Notes that many communities have shared practices of community participation, decoration and shared food during festivals — a general pattern for how community festivals are organised.
Use this to frame inquiries into whether Chaliha Sahib involves such community practices among Sindhis by consulting community sources or ethnographies.
States that deities, concepts and rituals have been exchanged between tribal and folk/Hindu traditions (tribal deities sometimes become mainstream Hindu ones).
A student could check whether the Nanda/deity associated with the Jaat has documented tribal origins or syncretic adoption from local tribes to assess possible tribal links.
Gives the geographic distribution of the Gonds across many states and identifies their primary forest/hill habitat.
Compare the geographic location of the Nanda Raj Jaat (region where the yatra is held) with the listed Gond areas to see if there is spatial overlap suggesting Gond involvement is plausible or unlikely.
Describes Gond ritual life: music, dance, ghotals (youth-houses) and community-sanctioned practices — indicating they maintain distinct ritual and festival traditions.
Use this pattern to ask whether the Nanda Raj Jaat’s form (music, dance, communal rites) matches known Gond ritual features, which could suggest or argue against Gond origin/ownership.
Explains that village rituals and festivals often require cooperation of several castes/groups, not just one community.
Investigate participant lists and ritual roles in the Nanda Raj Jaat to determine if it is multi-community (common) or specifically Gond.
Notes that Gonds hold beliefs in sorcery and superstition, implying persistence of distinct ritualistic practices within the community.
Compare the ritual elements of the Nanda Raj Jaat (e.g., rites perceived as 'supernatural' or 'sorcery') with Gond ritual content to see if there are thematic parallels.
Specifies where the Santhals live (Rajmahal Hills, Chotanagpur Plateau across Bihar, Jharkhand, Odisha, West Bengal), giving a clear regional base for the community.
A student could compare this Santhal geographic concentration with the known regional base of Wari–Warkari (if they know/lookup that) to judge overlap or separation.
Describes the Santhals as pioneer settlers in specific eastern areas (moved into Bengal around 1780s and settled Jangal Mahals), reinforcing their eastern/plateau-based regional identity.
Use this to test whether Wari–Warkari activities occur in the same geographic zones or in different regions.
Notes that tribal communities (including Santhals) have distinct cultural ethos (language, religion, traditions) different from other sections of society.
A student could infer that many tribal traditions may be distinct from regionally-specific bhakti traditions unless evidence of syncretism exists.
Explains that bhakti traditions often form around poet-saints and develop distinct communities of devotees, and that they show regional and doctrinal variety (saguna/nirguna).
A student could treat Wari–Warkari as one such regional bhakti community and therefore check whether Santhals historically joined or formed part of that devotees' community.
Gives an example (Virashaiva/Lingayat) of a strong regional/religious community emerging from a bhakti movement, illustrating how bhakti communities can be locality-specific and caste/community-specific.
A student could use this pattern to hypothesize that Warkari, like Virashaiva, may primarily involve a different regional/community base and so verify if Santhals are included or not.
- [THE VERDICT]: **Conceptual Trap**. The difficulty is artificial. Wari-Warkari is a core Bhakti theme (Maharashtra), while Santhals are Eastern India (Jharkhand/WB). The mismatch is 1000+ km.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: **Cultural Geography**. The intersection of Tribal Demography (Where do Gonds live?) and Regional Pilgrimages (Where is Nanda Devi?).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: **Tribal/Regional Festivals to Map**: 1. **Medaram Jatara** (Koya Tribe, Telangana), 2. **Chapchar Kut** (Mizos), 3. **Wangala** (Garos, Meghalaya), 4. **Ambubachi Mela** (Assam), 5. **Losar** (Monpas, Arunachal/Ladakh).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: **The Cross-Mapping Technique**. Never study festivals in isolation. Always tag them with a State. When you see a Tribe-Festival pair, ask: 'Does this Tribe live in that State?' If the geography doesn't overlap, the pair is false.
Several references explain that many Indian festivals are tied to lunar or luni‑solar calendars and therefore change dates each year.
High‑yield for culture/religion questions: knowing calendar bases (lunar vs solar) helps explain timing and regional observance differences, and appears in questions about festival dates and their astronomical basis. Links to geography (astronomy/time) and history (calendar reforms). Useful for answering why festival dates vary and for comparing ritual calendars across communities.
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 11: Keeping Time with the Skies > 11.3 Are Festivals Related to Astronomical Phenomena? > p. 183
- Science ,Class VIII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 11: Keeping Time with the Skies > Discover, design, and debate > p. 188
Evidence notes that some festivals are celebrated across India under different names and that states observe New Year and other festivals according to local cultures.
Important for UPSC: helps frame answers on cultural unity and diversity, shows how a single festival form can have regional variants — useful for essays and GS papers on cultural integration, federalism in culture, and identity politics. Enables questions asking to identify regional names or explain shared cultural practices.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 8: Unity in Diversity, or 'Many in the One' > Festivals Galore > p. 131
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 8: Unity in Diversity, or 'Many in the One' > LET'S EXPLORE > p. 132
References highlight community organisation, joint decoration and food-sharing as central aspects of many festivals.
Useful for sociology and polity sections: illustrates the social role of festivals in community bonding, non‑economic collective action and local governance. Helps answer questions on social capital, communal rituals, and grassroots social organisation; can be tied to case studies and policy implications.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 13: The Value of Work > THINK ABOUT IT > p. 193
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 8: Unity in Diversity, or 'Many in the One' > Festivals Galore > p. 131
Knowing where the Gonds are concentrated helps assess whether a regional ritual could plausibly originate with them.
High-yield for culture/tribal questions: links ethnography to regional history and policy. Mastering distribution aids answers on regional cultural practices, tribal demographics, and resource/administrative issues. Useful for questions asking origins or regional ownership of festivals and for mapping culture to state/region-level studies.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > The Gonds > p. 29
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > 2. Dravidians > p. 7
Shows that tribal deities and rituals can be absorbed into broader Hindu traditions and vice versa, which is central when judging the tribal origin of a pilgrimage or festival.
High-yield for religion/society topics: explains fluid boundaries between tribal and Hindu practices and helps answer questions on the origins and evolution of religious festivals. Connects to chapter-level themes on bhakti, local deities becoming pan-Hindu, and helps frame source-based questions on ritual provenance.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 7: India's Cultural Roots > What is a tribe? > p. 121
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART II, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 6: Bhakti-Sufi Traditions > 1.2 Difference and conflict > p. 142
Evidence on Gond ritual life (youth-houses, music/dance, village ritual cooperation) indicates distinctive community ritual forms that must be considered when attributing a festival to the Gonds.
Important for UPSC cultural anthropology and rural society questions: knowing specific Gond institutions (ghotals), ritual behavior and inter-caste cooperation helps evaluate claims about festival authorship and social function. Enables answering comparative questions on tribal ritual forms vs. pan-Indian festivals.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > The Gonds > p. 30
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > Caste and Village Community > p. 5
References describe the Santhals' Dravidian/Austric linguistic roots, large population, and their habitat (Rajmahal Hills, Chotanagpur Plateau, Bihar, Jharkhand, Odisha, West Bengal, Tripura, Assam). This grounds any claim about cultural association by locating the community.
High-yield for questions on tribal demography and regional cultural traditions: knowing origins, language family, and geographic spread helps evaluate plausibility of links between specific traditions and communities. Connects to topics on tribal policy, regional history, and cultural geography. Useful for comparing which traditions are regionally plausible to be adopted by a tribe.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 13: Cultural Setting > The Santhals > p. 33
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART III, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 9: COLONIALISM AND THE COUNTRYSIDE > 2.2 The Santhals: Pioneer settlers > p. 240
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 1: Geographical Diversity of India > LET'S EXPLORE > p. 17
Medaram Jatara (Sammakka Saralamma Jatara). It is often cited in culture sources alongside Kumbh Mela as one of the largest congregations, specifically celebrated by the Koya tribe in Telangana. It is a prime candidate for a future 'Tradition-Community' pair.
The 'Geographic Distance' Hack.
1. Locate the Tradition: Nanda Raj Jaat -> Nanda Devi -> Uttarakhand.
2. Locate the Community: Gonds -> Central India (MP/Chhattisgarh).
3. Logic: A traditional community festival does not originate 800km away from the community's habitat. Eliminate.
GS1 (Indian Heritage) & GS2 (Social Justice): Link these festivals to the 'Tribal Panchsheel' policy. How does state promotion of tribal festivals (like Hornbill) affect indigenous identity versus tourism revenue?