Question map
Consider the following pairs : Site Well known for 1. Besnagar : Shaivite cave shrine 2. Bhaja : Buddhist cave shrine 3. Sittanavasal : Jain cave shrine How many of the above pairs are correctly matched?
Explanation
The correct answer is Option 2 (Only two) because pairs 2 and 3 are correctly matched, while pair 1 is incorrect.
- Pair 1 is incorrectly matched: Besnagar (Vidisha, Madhya Pradesh) is famous for the Heliodorus Pillar, a stone column erected in honor of Vasudeva. It is a Vaishnavite (not Shaivite) monument. While there are cave shrines nearby at Udayagiri, Besnagar itself is synonymous with the Bhagavata sect.
- Pair 2 is correctly matched: The Bhaja Caves in Maharashtra are a group of 22 rock-cut caves dating back to the 2nd century BC. They represent Hinayana Buddhism and are renowned for their majestic chaitya (prayer hall) and viharas.
- Pair 3 is correctly matched: Sittanavasal in Tamil Nadu is a prominent Jain center. It features the Arivar Koil, a rock-cut cave temple containing celebrated 9th-century murals and stone beds used by Jain ascetics.
Since only pairs 2 and 3 are accurate, "Only two" is the right choice.
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Identity Swap' trap. Besnagar is universally famous for the Heliodorus Pillar (Vaishnavite), not a Shaivite cave. The question tests if you can distinguish between a site's primary identity (Pillar vs. Cave) and its religious affiliation (Vaishnavite vs. Shaivite). Bhaja and Sittanavasal are standard textbook examples found in TN Board and Nitin Singhania.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: Is Besnagar (Vidisha, Madhya Pradesh) an archaeological site well known for a Shaivite cave shrine?
- Statement 2: Is Bhaja (the Bhaja Caves near Pune, Maharashtra) an archaeological site well known for Buddhist cave shrines?
- Statement 3: Is Sittanavasal (Pudukottai district, Tamil Nadu) an archaeological site well known for a Jain cave shrine?
States that notable rock-cut cave groups occur in Madhya Pradesh (e.g., Bagh) and describes characteristics of rock-cut caves and temple types.
A student could use this regional pattern (Madhya Pradesh has important rock-cut sites) plus a map to check whether Besnagar/Vidisha lies near such cave traditions and so might host a cave shrine.
Describes Rashtrakuta-era rock-cut shrines (Ellora, Elephanta) and mentions the monolithic Kailasanath Temple, an explicitly Shaivite creation hewn from rock.
Use this example to reason that rock-cut work in central/west India includes Shaivite cave/monolithic shrines; then investigate whether Besnagar has similar chronological/artistic links.
Explains that some early temples were hollowed out of huge rocks (artificial caves), showing the established practice of cave temples in Indian temple history.
Combine this general rule with local archaeological reports or a map of cave-temple distributions to assess plausibility of a Shaivite cave at Besnagar.
Gives an example of an archaeological cave/shrine find (Baghor in Madhya Pradesh), indicating the region has prehistoric shrine evidence in rock/cave contexts.
A student could note the precedent of shrine finds in Madhya Pradesh and then check site-specific literature for Besnagar/Vidisha to confirm presence or absence of a Shaivite cave shrine.
Lists Upper Palaeolithic and cave-using sites in Madhya Pradesh (Son Valley, Baghor), showing Madhya Pradeshโs archaeological richness including cave contexts.
Use this pattern of multiple cave-related finds in the state to justify further targeted research (site reports, maps) on Besnagar rather than assuming absence or presence from general knowledge.
States that Ajanta and Ellora in Maharashtra are cave groups created for religious purposes and links cave excavation activity in the Deccan with Buddhist patronage (Hinayana at Ajanta).
A student could note that Maharashtra has a regional tradition of Buddhist cave complexes and check whether Bhaja (near Pune) fits geographically and stylistically into this pattern.
Says the Ellora caves include Buddhist monuments among other religions, demonstrating that rockโcut cave shrines in Maharashtra often include Buddhist examples.
Use this rule that Maharashtra cave complexes frequently contain Buddhist shrines to consider Bhaja as plausibly part of that corpus and then verify Bhaja's religious affiliation from a map or site list.
Notes that rockโcut shrines in Maharashtra (Ellora, Elephanta) are major examples of the regional rockโcut tradition under medieval dynasties.
A student could infer there is a strong local tradition of rockโcut religious caves and thus look up whether Bhaja is listed among Maharashtra's rockโcut Buddhist shrines near Pune.
Identifies Ajanta, Ellora and Bagh as the most notable rockโcut cave groups, showing that these cave groups are prominent archaeological sites associated with religious cave architecture.
From this pattern that notable cave sites are catalogued by region, a student could compare lists of famous Maharashtra cave sites to see if Bhaja appears among Buddhist cave shrines.
Explains Ajanta caves were excavated for Buddhist purposes (Hinayana) and gives geographic context within Maharashtra (distance from Aurangabad).
A student might use this example of a named Buddhist cave complex and the given geography to check maps and site inventories to determine whether Bhaja, near Pune, is similarly a Buddhist cave complex.
Explicitly names Sittannavasal among prominent rock-cut cave temples of the early Pandyas and notes paintings in the Sittannavasal cave temple.
A student could combine this with a map of Tamil Nadu and sources on religious cave-temples to check whether Sittannavasal is identified as Jain in other references.
Describes features of Jain caves (figures of Mahavira, Parsvanatha, Yaksha, attendants) showing what a 'Jain cave' typically contains.
Compare the iconographic features listed here with descriptions or images of Sittannavasal to see if they match Jain cave-shrine characteristics.
States that in Tamil Nadu there is stronger archaeological evidence for Jainism than Buddhism, implying Jain cave-sites are present in the region.
Use this regional pattern to prioritize checking Sittannavasal in archaeological/Jain-site lists for Tamil Nadu.
Gives the broader pattern that rock-cut cave complexes in India include Jain monuments (example: Ellora has Jain cave temples).
Use the general occurrence of Jain rock-cut caves (e.g., Ellora) as a precedent to consider Sittannavasal plausibly part of the same phenomenon and verify via site-specific sources.
Notes that Chalukyas built Jain temples and that mandapa-type caves are preserved at Aihole, indicating rock-cut and temple forms were used for Jain worship in south India.
Extend this architectural pattern to inspect whether Sittannavasal's cave-temple architecture corresponds to known South Indian Jain cave-temple types.
- [THE VERDICT]: Moderate. Pair 1 is the 'Trap'. Besnagar = Heliodorus Pillar (Vaishnavite). Source: Standard NCERT/TN Board (Class 11, Ch 11 for Sittanavasal).
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Ancient Architecture Typology (Cave vs. Structural vs. Pillar) and Sectarian affiliation (Buddhist vs. Jain vs. Brahmanical).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize these siblings: 1) Bhaja's neighbors: Karle (Largest Chaitya), Bedse, Junnar, Kanheri. 2) Sittanavasal's cousins: Armamalai (Jain paintings, Vellore), Tirumalaipuram (Pandya paintings). 3) Besnagar's neighbor: Udayagiri Caves (Vidisha) - famous for Varaha (Vaishnavite) and Shaivite caves, but Besnagar itself is the Pillar site.
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Do not just memorize 'Site = State'. Create a 3-column matrix: [Site Name] | [Primary Architecture (Cave/Stupa/Pillar)] | [Religion]. If a site is famous for a Pillar (Besnagar), a 'Cave' description is an immediate red flag.
Cave shrines are part of the broader tradition of rock-cut and artificially hollowed temples in India.
High-yield for paper I/GAT: helps identify and classify archaeological/architectural sites by form (natural cave vs. artificial rock-cut). Connects to questions on temple evolution, patronage and regional styles; enables elimination of wrong site-type options in MCQs and structured questions.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Rock-cut and Structural Temples > p. 98
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART I, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Thinkers, Beliefs and Buildings > Fig. 4.24 An image of Durga, Mahabalipuram (Tamil Nadu), c. sixth century CE > p. 106
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > II. Elora - Ajanta and Mamallapuram > p. 127
Major cave groups (Ajanta, Ellora, Bagh, Udayagiri) exemplify how cave sites are regionally clustered and dated.
Useful for mapping and chronology questions: knowing major cave complexes, their locations and date ranges helps answer questions on cultural diffusion, dynastic patronage and regional art schools; supports comparative analysis of sites.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 7: The Guptas > Rock-cut and Structural Temples > p. 98
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > II. Elora - Ajanta and Mamallapuram > p. 127
Cave complexes often contain Buddhist, Hindu and Jain monuments, indicating varied religious functions of rock-cut sites.
Important for culture and art sections: distinguishes iconographic and functional differences across religious cave architecture and links to patronage and sectarian history; aids answering questions on religious syncretism and architectural adaptation.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 8: Harsha and Rise of Regional Kingdoms > Architecture > p. 114
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART I, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 4: Thinkers, Beliefs and Buildings > Fig. 4.24 An image of Durga, Mahabalipuram (Tamil Nadu), c. sixth century CE > p. 106
Maharashtra contains major rock-cut cave complexes (Ajanta, Ellora, Elephanta) that include Buddhist cave shrines and other religious monuments.
High-yield for UPSC questions on Indian rock-cut architecture and cultural geography; links to religious pluralism and regional art developments and enables comparative questions on site distribution and significance.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 8: Harsha and Rise of Regional Kingdoms > Architecture > p. 114
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > II. Elora - Ajanta and Mamallapuram > p. 127
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > II Ellora, Ajanta and Mamallapuram Ellora > p. 132
Buddhist cave sites are characterized by architectural forms such as chaityas (prayer halls), viharas (monastic cells) and stupas, and by mural and sculptural decoration.
Essential for answering questions on identifying and distinguishing religious architecture; connects art-history, sectarian developments (e.g., Hinayana patronage), and regional variations in temple form.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > 9.4Ajanta > p. 128
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 5: Evolution of Society in South India > Archaeological > p. 63
Cave excavation was carried out over long periods with patrons ranging from kings to merchants, and site dates span centuries (examples include c. 200 BCEโ200 CE for early caves and later phases up to c. 950 CE).
Useful for dating monuments, attributing patronage patterns, and framing questions on state versus mercantile support for religious art; helps in temporal comparison of sites across regions.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > 9.4Ajanta > p. 128
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 9: Cultural Development in South India > II. Elora - Ajanta and Mamallapuram > p. 127
Tamil Nadu preserves prominent rock-cut cave temples such as Sittannavasal which are notable for their architecture and mural paintings.
High-yield for architectural and cultural history questions: recognising regional examples of rock-cut architecture helps answer questions on Pandya-era temple-building, regional art styles, and site-based matching questions. Connects to topics on temple architecture, regional dynasties and material culture.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 11: Later Cholas and Pandyas > Temples > p. 171
Udayagiri Caves (Madhya Pradesh) vs. Udayagiri Caves (Odisha). MP = Gupta period, Hindu/Jain (Varaha Avatar). Odisha = Kharavela period, Jain (Hathigumpha Inscription). Expect a 'swap' question between these two identical names.
The 'Primary Fame' Filter: In 'Well known for' questions, if the description contradicts the *most famous* attribute of the site, it is false. Besnagar is synonymous with the Heliodorus Pillar (Bhagavatism/Vaishnavism). 'Shaivite Cave' contradicts both the architecture (Pillar vs Cave) and the sect (Vaishnavite vs Shaivite). Reject Pair 1 immediately.
Mains GS1 (Art & Culture) to GS2 (Soft Power): The spread of rock-cut architecture (like Bhaja on trade routes) mirrors the spread of Buddhism via the 'Dakshinapatha'. Use these sites as examples of how trade funded religious art.