Question map
With reference to ancient India (600-322 BC), consider the following pairs : I. Asmaka : Godavari II. Kamboja : Vipas III. Avanti : Mahanadi IV. Kosala : Sarayu How many of the pairs given above are correctly matched?
Explanation
Asmaka (or Assaka) was a Mahajanapada located in the Deccan region, on the banks of the Godavari river[1], making the first pair correctly matched. Kamboja was located in the north-western part of the Indian subcontinent, around present-day Afghanistan and Tajikistan. The river Vipas (Beas) flows in the Punjab region, not in Kamboja[2], so the second pair is incorrectly matched. Avanti was a Mahajanapada located in western Madhya Pradesh, with its capital at Ujjain. The main river flowing through Avanti was the Narmada[3], not the Mahanadi (which flows in Chhattisgarh and Odisha)[4], making the third pair incorrect. Kosala was a Mahajanapada in the region of present-day eastern Uttar Pradesh, and the Sarayu river (modern Ghaghara) flowed through it[5], making the fourth pair correctly matched. Therefore, only two pairs (Asmaka-Godavari and Kosala-Sarayu) are correctly matched.
SourcesPROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis is a classic 'Map-based History' question that rewards integrating RS Sharma (Ancient History) with basic Indian Geography. It is not a random trivia question; it tests the fundamental geographical setting of the Second Urbanisation. If you memorized the list of 16 Mahajanapadas without visualizing their locations on a physical map, you likely struggled.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
- Statement 1: In ancient India (600–322 BC), was the kingdom of Asmaka located on the Godavari River?
- Statement 2: In ancient India (600–322 BC), was the kingdom of Kamboja located on the Vipas (Vipasa/Beas) River?
- Statement 3: In ancient India (600–322 BC), was the kingdom of Avanti located on the Mahanadi River?
- Statement 4: In ancient India (600–322 BC), was the kingdom of Kosala located on the Sarayu River?
- Directly states Asmaka (Assaka) was a Mahajanapada located in the Deccan on the banks of the Godavari.
- Explicitly labels the Asmaka: Godavari pairing as correct, answering the location question.
Gives the geographic extent and major tributaries of the Godavari basin, defining the physical region a kingdom 'on the Godavari' would occupy.
A student could use this basin map plus a historical map of kingdoms to see whether Asmaka's reported territory overlaps the Godavari drainage.
States that later polities (the Sātavāhanas) ruled the Godavari basin and identifies key locations (Prathistan/Paithan, Telangana) in the Deccan region.
Use the fact that the Deccan had continuous political activity around the Godavari to judge plausibility that an earlier kingdom (Asmaka) could have been located there.
Notes the economic importance of the Krishna–Godavari river system for agriculture and trade, implying major kingdoms often centered on such river systems.
Apply the general pattern that ancient kingdoms commonly occupied fertile river basins to assess whether Asmaka, if described as a regional kingdom, might plausibly have been based on the Godavari.
Shows that classical/ancient accounts (Greek in this example) identify and place named kingdoms/kingdoms’ rulers in specific geographic zones.
A student could look for comparable ancient textual references that place Asmaka in a named region or alongside other geographically located polities to infer its river-basin affiliation.
- Directly states the Kamboja region is in the north-west (around present-day Afghanistan and Tajikistan).
- Explicitly says the river Vipas (Beas) flows in the Punjab region, not in Kamboja.
- Concludes the Kamboja: Vipas pair is incorrect.
- Places Kamboja in the northwestern part of the subcontinent (Afghanistan, Pakistan, Kashmir).
- States the core area of Kamboja is generally placed further west than the main course of the Vipas (Beas) river.
- Therefore rejects the Kamboja–Vipas matching.
Explicitly identifies 'Beas (Vipasa or Argikiya)' and describes its course in the northwest (Kullu, Kangra, Punjab Plain).
A student could place the Beas/Vipasa on a map and see whether known locations attributed to Kamboja (from other sources) lie along or near this river.
Groups Vipasa (Beas) with Sutlej and Ravi as the Shatadru river group of north-western plains, giving a regional river-system context.
Use the river-group classification to delimit the broader northwestern zone; then check whether Kamboja is described elsewhere as inhabiting this river-group area.
Notes that the northwestern region hosted smaller kingdoms along an ancient route to the Mediterranean, implying a distinct geopolitical zone in the northwest.
Map the northwestern 'route' and kingdoms mentioned by classical accounts to see if Kamboja is repeatedly placed in the same northwest corridor as the Beas/Vipasa.
The Ṛg Veda names the northwest as 'Sapta Sindhava' — 'land of seven rivers' — indicating a long-standing conceptual region defined by river systems in the northwest.
Relate the 'seven rivers' region to the Beas/Vipasa as one of the rivers; then compare traditional attributions of Kamboja to the broader 'seven rivers' area to assess proximity.
Mentions Kambojas as 'northern rulers' defeated by Chandragupta II, confirming Kamboja as a polity located in the north (though later period).
Combine this northward identification with the geographical location of the Beas/Vipasa to evaluate the plausibility that Kamboja lay in the Beas river region.
- Explicitly labels the Avanti : Mahanadi pairing as incorrect.
- States Avanti was a Mahajanapada in western Madhya Pradesh (Malwa) with capital Ujjain.
- Identifies the main river of Avanti as the Narmada, not the Mahanadi.
- States that the river associated (Mahanadi) is not the river of the region in question.
- Specifies that the Mahanadi flows in Chhattisgarh and Odisha, implying it does not flow through Avanti's territory.
- Describes Avanti as located in West-Central India (the Malwa region of present-day Madhya Pradesh).
- Names Ujjain as its capital, situating Avanti away from the Mahanadi basin.
Describes the Mahanadi's course and region (rises in Chhattisgarh basin, important for Odisha and Chhattisgarh).
Compare the historical location of Avanti (from a historical map or list of mahājanapadas) to the Chhattisgarh–Odisha Mahanadi corridor to see if they overlap.
Gives specific source area (near Sihawa in Raipur district) and basin distribution (large parts lie in Chhattisgarh and Madhya Pradesh/Chhattisgarh).
Use this basin map to check whether Avanti's territory (if placed in central India) would fall inside the Mahanadi basin.
Notes downstream geography (turn at Sambalpur, flows through Eastern Ghats to Bay of Bengal; Cuttack at the delta), showing the river's eastward drainage.
A student can contrast Avanti's reported political/urban centers with the Mahanadi's downstream and delta locations to assess plausibility of Avanti being 'on' the Mahanadi.
States the general historical pattern that early civilizations and major polities developed along river valleys (Indus, Nile, Tigris-Euphrates).
Apply the general rule that kingdoms often sit on major rivers: if Avanti were a major kingdom, check which major river valley (if any) it is historically associated with.
Mentions the sixteen mahājanapadas and locates Magadha in eastern/central subcontinent, situating the political geography of 6th–4th century BCE India.
Locate the list/map of mahājanapadas (external basic source) and see whether Avanti is placed in the same region as the Mahanadi or elsewhere.
- Explicitly states Kosala kingdom was located in the Awadh region (present-day Uttar Pradesh).
- Names Ayodhya and Sravasti as capitals, tying the polity to the Sarayu river corridor.
- Directly says the Sarayu river flows through this region, passing by Ayodhya — linking Kosala to the Sarayu.
- Explicitly pairs Kosala with the Sarayu and marks the pairing as correct.
- States Kosala was a Mahajanapada in present-day eastern Uttar Pradesh.
- Specifies the Sarayu river (modern Ghaghara) flowed through Kosala, directly supporting the claim.
States that around 1000 BCE Vedic Aryans moved to the Kosala region in eastern Uttar Pradesh, locating Kosala in the Upper Ganga valley area.
A student can combine this with a modern map of eastern Uttar Pradesh to see which rivers flow through that region (e.g., Sarayu) to judge whether Kosala overlapped the Sarayu basin.
Lists Ayodhya among major cities during the period of the Aryans; Ayodhya is historically associated with the kingdom of Kosala in many traditions.
A student can locate Ayodhya on a map and check which river it lies on (the modern Sarayu) to infer whether Kosala's principal city sat on the Sarayu.
Describes broad patterns of river course changes and capture into the Ganga system, showing that river identity and courses in northern India have shifted over time.
A student should consider that ancient river courses may differ from modern ones and compare historical/archaeological maps with modern hydrography to assess whether Kosala's boundaries matched the ancient Sarayu.
Notes the Rig Veda names the northwest as the land of seven rivers, indicating Vedic texts use river-based regional labels and that rivers were key geographic markers for ancient polities.
A student could use this pattern—ancient kingdoms being described relative to rivers—to consult Vedic/ancient sources or maps to see whether Kosala is described in relation to the Sarayu.
- [THE VERDICT]: Sitter. This is core static content found in RS Sharma (Chapter: Age of Mahajanapadas) and Tamil Nadu Class XI History.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: The 'Second Urbanisation' (600-300 BC) and the rise of the 16 Mahajanapadas along major river valleys.
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Map the remaining key Mahajanapadas to their rivers: Magadha (Ganga/Son), Vatsa (Yamuna), Gandhara (Indus/Kabul), Matsya (West of Yamuna/Jaipur), and Anga (Champa/Ganga confluence).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: History is Geography in motion. Never read a history chapter about kingdoms without an open atlas. The specific river determines the agricultural surplus, trade route, and strategic defense of the capital.
The Godavari is the largest peninsular river, rising in Nasik and draining a basin that spans Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Odisha and Andhra Pradesh.
High-yield for geography and ancient history questions: knowing the Godavari's origin, length and basin area explains settlement patterns, resource distribution and regional boundaries. Connects to river-based economic and political questions on the Deccan.
- CONTEMPORARY INDIA-I ,Geography, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Drainage > The Godavari Basin > p. 21
Agriculture and economic stability in the Deccan were centered on the Krishna–Godavari river system, supporting kingdoms and trade.
Useful for questions linking physical geography to state formation and economy: explains why polities clustered around major rivers, influenced capital locations, and sustained trade networks. Helps answer polity, economy and settlement questions in ancient India.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 6: The Age of Reorganisation > The Sātavāhanas > p. 125
- CONTEMPORARY INDIA-I ,Geography, Class IX . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 3: Drainage > The Godavari Basin > p. 21
The Sātavāhanas moved to and ruled the Godavari basin, with Prathistan (Paithan) as a key capital in Maharashtra.
Directly relevant for Deccan political history: connects archaeological, numismatic and inscriptional evidence to territorial control of the Godavari region. Helps address questions on regional dynasties, chronology and trade networks in South India.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 5: Evolution of Society in South India > 5.2 South India under the Satavahanas > p. 65
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond ,Social Science-Class VII . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 6: The Age of Reorganisation > The Sātavāhanas > p. 125
Vipasa is the ancient name for the Beas River, establishing modern–ancient name equivalences useful for mapping historical places.
High-yield for historical geography questions: knowing ancient and modern river names lets aspirants place kingdoms and battle sites on modern maps, links textual references to physical geography, and aids answers on regional continuity and change.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > SARASWATI-THE MYSTERY OF A LOST RIVER > p. 26
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > The Beas (Vipasa or Argikiya) > p. 10
The northwestern plains rivers are classified into groups that pair Shatadru (Sutlej) with Vipasa (Beas) and Parusani (Ravi), providing a framework for locating regions.
Useful for questions on settlement patterns and political boundaries: understanding river-group classifications helps infer where ancient polities might have been located and connects physical geography with ancient history.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > SARASWATI-THE MYSTERY OF A LOST RIVER > p. 26
Sapta Sindhava names the northwest as the land of seven rivers, framing Vedic-era regional geography.
Important for Vedic and early-historic questions: this concept helps interpret Rigvedic references, trace cultural-geographical regions, and supports arguments about river-based civilization cores and migration corridors.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 5: India, That Is Bharat > How Indians Named India > p. 77
The Mahanadi rises near Sihawa in Raipur (Chhattisgarh) and flows east through Odisha to the Bay of Bengal, so any kingdom claimed to be on this river would need to be located in that general area.
High-yield for map-based history and geography questions: knowing major river courses helps eliminate or confirm proposed locations of ancient states. Connects physical geography (river basins) with historical settlement and political boundaries, useful for questions matching kingdoms to rivers or explaining economic bases of states.
- INDIA PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT, Geography Class XI (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 3: Drainage System > River Systems of the Peninsular Drainage > p. 23
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > The Mahanadi > p. 20
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 3: The Drainage System of India > The Mahanadi > p. 21
The Capitals on Rivers: Ujjain (Avanti) is on the Shipra (tributary of Chambal), Pataliputra (Magadha) is at the confluence of Ganga and Son, and Varanasi (Kashi) is on the banks of Ganga (Varuna/Assi). Expect a 'Capital City : River' match next.
Use the 'Compass Check'. Avanti is historically the region of Malwa (Western MP). The Mahanadi flows through Chhattisgarh and Odisha (East India). They are geographically incompatible. Similarly, Kamboja is the extreme North-West (Afghanistan/Pamirs), while the Vipas (Beas) is a Punjab river much further south-east. Geographic disconnect eliminates them instantly.
Mains GS-1 (History & Geography): The location of these Mahajanapadas explains the 'Second Urbanisation'. The surplus agriculture from the fertile alluvial soil of these specific river basins (Ganga-Yamuna doab, Sarayu, Godavari) created the economic base for the first large standing armies and state structures.