Question map
Consider the following pairs : Craft Heritage of 1. Puthukkuli shawls - Tamil Nadu 2. Sujni embroidery - Maharashtra 3. Uppada Jamdani saris - Karnataka Which of the pairs given above is/are correct ?
Explanation
The correct answer is option A (1 only) because only the first pair is correctly matched.
Uppada Jamdani sarees are part of the craft heritage[2] of Andhra Pradesh, specifically from the East Godavari district[1], not Karnataka as stated in pair 3. Therefore, pair 3 is incorrect.
Sujni embroidery is traditionally associated with Bihar and not Maharashtra, making pair 2 incorrect as well.
Puthukkuli shawls are indeed part of Tamil Nadu's craft heritage, specifically from the Puthukkuli region, making pair 1 the only correct match among the three pairs given.
This question tests the aspirant's knowledge of India's diverse textile and craft traditions and their geographic origins, which is an important topic for understanding India's cultural heritage under the UPSC syllabus.
Sources- [1] https://www.incredibleindia.gov.in/en/andhra-pradesh/uppada-jamdani-sarees
- [2] https://www.globalinch.org/craft-category/hand-spinning-khadi/page/13/
PROVENANCE & STUDY PATTERN
Full viewThis question exposes the gap between standard NCERTs and the 'GI Tag' regime. While NCERTs mention broad categories, specific names like Puthukkuli or Sujni come from the GI Registry or CCRT lists. It is a 'List-Based' question requiring rote memorization of State-Craft pairs, specifically those in the news for GI status or cultural festivals.
This question can be broken into the following sub-statements. Tap a statement sentence to jump into its detailed analysis.
Identifies shawl needlework as a recognised regional craft in India (example: Kashmir) and contrasts with named cottage industries in Tamil Nadu.
A student could use this pattern—shawls are regionally identified—to check whether Puthukkuli is listed as a regional shawl-producing centre (e.g., local craft surveys or GI/handicraft lists for Tamil Nadu).
States Tamil Nadu is a major cotton/textile producer with many textile centres (Coimbatore, Tirunelveli, Salem, etc.), showing a strong regional textile tradition.
Combine this with a map or directory to see if Puthukkuli lies within Tamil Nadu textile districts or near known weaving clusters, which would make shawl production plausible.
Describes the existence of specialised craft centres and the movement of craftsmen and traders into the Tamil country, implying regional craft specialisations develop through trade and local centres.
Use this rule to search for historical or contemporary craft centres named Puthukkuli or nearby towns to assess whether shawl weaving emerged there.
Gives an example of a specialised ancient craft industry (bead-making in Kodumanal, Tamil Nadu), showing that Tamil Nadu has localized craft specializations with archaeological and historical evidence.
Extend by checking whether Puthukkuli appears in regional craft histories, archaeological records, or local craft gazetteers as a specialised textile/shawl centre.
Emphasises that craft production has been an important economic activity with specialised sites, suggesting modern craft specializations (like shawls) could be regionally identified.
A student could apply this general principle to look for documentary evidence (handicraft lists, state board material, GI registrations) linking Puthukkuli to shawl-making in Tamil Nadu.
Mentions Marathi documents and village surveys showing substantial numbers of artisans in villages and fluid artisan/peasant roles.
A student could use this to infer Maharashtra has a documented village craft tradition and then look up whether Sujni appears in such Marathi records or village artisan lists.
Describes Maharashtra as a major producer of cotton goods with many textile-producing centres (Mumbai, Sholapur, Pune, etc.).
Since Sujni is a textile/embroidery-related craft, a student could check if Sujni is practiced in these textile regions or linked to Maharashtra's cotton textile economy.
Notes that spinning and weaving (cotton textiles) were widespread across India and that various regions produced specialised textiles.
Use the pattern that regions often have specialised textile crafts to investigate whether Sujni is regionally specialised in Maharashtra or elsewhere.
States weaving was undertaken by women and craft specialisation deepened in later Vedic/early historic periods, showing gendered continuity in textile crafts.
A student could consider gendered patterns of textile craft transmission and ask whether Sujni (an embroidery form) is carried by similar women-led traditions in Maharashtra.
Explains crafts were organised institutionally (guilds, hereditary occupations) in historical Indian polities.
One could extend this to check whether Sujni has historically recognised craft communities or guild links in Maharashtra.
- Explicitly links Uppada Jamdani sarees to Andhra Pradesh and its weaving community.
- Describes Uppada Jamdani as an icon/treasure of Andhra Pradesh's textile history, implying regional attribution to Andhra Pradesh (not Karnataka).
- Identifies Uppada as being in the East Godavari district of Andhra Pradesh.
- Describes the Uppada Jamdani saree weaving (features and materials), tying the craft to Andhra Pradesh geographically.
Lists named sari types tied to places (e.g., Banarasi, Kanjivaram, Mysore), implying saris are often region-specific craft traditions.
A student could check whether 'Uppada Jamdani' is similarly place‑named and then locate Uppada on a map to see if it lies in Karnataka or another state.
Notes that specialised weaves and sari styles are distinctive and not easily reproduced by mills, showing that particular sari weaves constitute identifiable craft heritage.
Use this rule to treat 'Uppada Jamdani' as a specialised weave and then verify its regional origin against a map or regional craft lists.
Explains the sari has many local historical forms and regional continuity, reinforcing that sari types are cultural markers tied to specific areas.
Combine this with knowledge of where Uppada Jamdani is produced to infer whether it belongs to Karnataka's traditions or another region.
Describes crafts as predominantly urban‑based, hereditary and regionally organised (guilds, leaders), suggesting craft forms are rooted in particular local communities.
A student could investigate whether Uppada Jamdani has a hereditary/local weaving community located in Karnataka or elsewhere.
Gives examples of distinct regional cultural artifacts (e.g., Togalu Gombeyaata in Karnataka), showing educational sources classify crafts by state/region.
Use such state-based classification to look for Uppada Jamdani in lists of state crafts—if not listed under Karnataka, it likely belongs to another state.
- [THE VERDICT]: Bouncer for static-only students; Sitter for GI-Tag trackers. Source: GI Registry updates or CCRT website.
- [THE CONCEPTUAL TRIGGER]: Art & Culture > Regional Handicrafts & Geographical Indications (GI).
- [THE HORIZONTAL EXPANSION]: Memorize these specific confusions: Sujni (Bihar) vs Sozni (Kashmir); Kasuti (Karnataka) vs Kantha (West Bengal); Pochampally (Telangana) vs Patan Patola (Gujarat); Toda Embroidery (Tamil Nadu).
- [THE STRATEGIC METACOGNITION]: Do not just memorize the name; map it to the *community* or *geography*. Puthukkuli = Toda Tribe = Nilgiris = TN. Uppada = Coastal Andhra. Visualizing the map eliminates the 'neighboring state' trap.
References show crafts are regionally specialised (e.g., shawl needlework in Kashmir vs cracker-making in Tamil Nadu).
High-yield for geography/economy questions: knowing which states specialise in which cottage/handicraft industries helps eliminate distractors in MCQs and frame short-answer responses; link these pairs to resources, culture and local demand. Revise as a list of state–craft associations and examples.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 11: Industries > Others > p. 66
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 11: Industries > Tamil Nadu > p. 15
Evidence names Tamil Nadu textile centres (Coimbatore, Chennai, Madurai, etc.), which is relevant when assessing whether a specific textile (like a shawl) originates there.
Useful for questions on industrial geography and regional economies: connect modern textile hubs with traditional crafts to judge continuity/change; prepare by mapping major towns to industries and noting where traditional crafts are absent or prominent.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 11: Industries > Tamil Nadu > p. 15
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 11: Industries > Others > p. 66
Sources discuss craft markets, specialised craft centres and presence of diverse artisans and traders in Tamil regions, which frames where crafts historically developed.
Important for history and economic development questions: helps answer why certain crafts emerged locally, their trade links and artisanal exchanges; study primary literary/archaeological references and tie them to craft specialisation patterns.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 5: Evolution of Society in South India > 5.6 Society and Economy > p. 69
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 1: Early India: From the Beginnings to the Indus Civilisation > Craft Production > p. 11
Marathi documents and village surveys note substantial numbers of artisans in villages of Maharashtra — relevant when judging whether a specific embroidery tradition may be rooted in rural artisan communities.
High-yield for UPSC: helps link primary/local documentary evidence to questions on craft origins and cultural heritage; connects social history, rural economy and craft distribution. Useful for questions asking how to attribute cultural practices to regions using archival/village evidence.
- THEMES IN INDIAN HISTORY PART II, History CLASS XII (NCERT 2025 ed.) > Chapter 8: Peasants, Zamindars and the State > 2.3 Village artisans > p. 204
Sources show Maharashtra as a major centre of cotton textile mills and bulk cloth production, which is a different strand from small-scale hand-embroidery traditions like Sujni.
Important for aspirants to separate industrial geography from handicraft heritage when answering questions on regional crafts, policy impacts, and economic history; links industry/location topics with craft continuity and livelihoods.
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 11: Industries > Maharashtra > p. 13
- Geography of India ,Majid Husain, (McGrawHill 9th ed.) > Chapter 11: Industries > Maharashtra > p. 14
Evidence on weaving and craft specialisation in historical sources provides context to evaluate whether an embroidery style is part of longer textile traditions in a region.
Helps frame answers that require connecting present-day crafts to historical patterns (craft guilds, specialization, textile regions); useful across cultural history and material culture questions.
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 4: Emergence of State and Empire > Crafts and Goods > p. 57
- History , class XI (Tamilnadu state board 2024 ed.) > Chapter 2: Early India: The Chalcolithic, Megalithic, Iron Age and Vedic Cultures > Craft Production > p. 29
References list well-known sari types (e.g., Banarasi, Kanjivaram, Paithani, Patan Patola, Muga, Mysore) and note the sari's regional variations and history.
High-yield for cultural geography and art-culture questions: helps identify state-specific textile traditions and distinguish origins of named saris. Connects to questions on regional craft identity, textile economies, and cultural diversity; learn by mapping famous sari names to states and production centres.
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 8: Unity in Diversity, or 'Many in the One' > Textiles and Clothing > p. 128
- Exploring Society:India and Beyond. Social Science-Class VI . NCERT(Revised ed 2025) > Chapter 8: Unity in Diversity, or 'Many in the One' > Textiles and Clothing > p. 129
The 'Sujni' vs 'Sozni' trap. Sujni is quilting from Bihar; Sozni is fine needlework from Kashmir. UPSC often swaps these phonetically similar terms to confuse aspirants.
Use Linguistic Intuition. 'Uppada' is a distinct Telugu place name (Andhra Pradesh). 'Jamdani' is historically linked to the Bengal-Andhra corridor. Karnataka is unlikely. If 3 is wrong, Options C and D are eliminated. You are left with A vs B. 'Sujni' is a Hindi-belt term (Bihar), whereas Maharashtra is known for Paithani or Himroo. Thus, 2 is likely wrong.
Connect to **Tribal Development (GS2)** and **Inclusive Growth (GS3)**. Puthukkuli is the exclusive livelihood of the Toda tribe (a PVTG in Nilgiris). Preserving this craft is directly linked to protecting PVTG heritage and economy.